4 ms·
But Zuckerburg says "if we were starting [FaceBook] now and we decided that [the default sharing of information now] would be the social norms now and we just w
by petercooper 17y ago
But Zuckerburg says "if we were starting [FaceBook] now and we decided that [the default sharing of information now] would be the social norms now and we just went for it." wouldn't really get the message across..
Anyway, there's already a guideline:
You can make up a new title if you want, but if you put gratuitous editorial spin on it, the editors may rewrite it.
So editors are already rewriting headlines, and I've seen it done. Perhaps a compromise would be to extend that guideline to suggesting editors may edit actual headlines, although I'd be sad to see it since writing punchy headlines is an art. If the story were false or overly sensational, should we be voting it up?
So I vote no; let the votes gauge quality, not guidelines. But I'd have no big beef with HN moderators editing the headlines where they were over the top.
- anonjon 17y agoYou need some guidelines so that you know how to vote/when to flag. It is very possible that I like an article and hate the misleading headline.
- mmt 17y agoIt is very possible that I like an article and hate the misleading headline. In this situation, I both upvote and flag. Typically, if the title is sensationalist enough and the article is good, there will have been enough upvotes to prevent automatic deletion.
- j_baker 17y agoAlright, but I'd argue at a very minimum that headlines at least shouldn't be misleading like the zuckerburg one. After all don't we already have a guideline to omit the x from "x things about y"? Isn't that editing the original title?
- pg 17y agoWe already do edit titles. Particularly Smashing Magazine type titles ("50 CSS Guides You Have to Read Now" -> "CSS Guides"), those that bait HN specifically, and those that are false, like this one. We also fix typos and solecisms in titles, even if they occur in the original.
- ivankirigin 17y agoWe need a standard for changing a title to convey it is clearly heavily editorial. It should say the name and as bland a topic summary as possible, in part as punishment for clickbait. In this case, perhaps: "Marshall Kirkpatrick on facebook privacy settings"