6 ms·
A Democracy of Netbooks
- 3pt14159 17y agoA very philosophical approach, but the main reason I have a netbook is that I can carry it with one hand and it does most of what I need a computer to do. I can read man pages about wget on the bus, I can test out little Ruby ideas I have and see what happens. I can send out a quick message to my friends. Just a really neat little machine. Now that being said, I don't have a smart phone (data plans were too expensive for my tastes) or a regular laptop (too heavy) so maybe my netbook partially fills two technological gaps in my life.
- antidaily 17y agoSame here. Pretty happy with the Dell Mini 9 (1.6ghz atom w/ 2gb ram and 16gb ssd) I bought a year ago. It was around $340 and I was able to put Windows 7 RC on it. It's been great for vacations and meetings where I don't want to lug around (or risk theft of) my macbook pro. It's pretty fast too.
- michael_dorfman 17y agoI don't care how "smart" your smartphone is, it will never escape those corporate shackles. Smartphones are simply not free enough to deliver the type of democratic transformation that netbooks -- mobile PCs cheap enough and fast enough and good enough for everyone to afford -- absolutely will. In Europe, at least, smartphones are sold unlocked, and can be used with any WiFi-- so I don't really see in what sense they are "not free enough", or shackled to any corporation.
- jackowayed 17y agoThey also usually fail the "Runs my software." criterium. The most smartphones still have gatekeepers on what software you can install on them (with the iPhone being the primest example). And even the ones that let you install any software don't usually let you install software that can do anything because of security concerns. Hopefully Android will win and this won't be an issue, but for now it definitely is.
- rimantas 17y agoGeneral population does not have this problem. They do not care about feature lists, MHzs of CPU, they do not count watts and do not carry replaceable batteries. They do not give a damn how open or how closed the ecosystem is. Either device works for them or it does not. I guess very few geeks get that, and Jeff is sure not one of them. And it would be a mistake to think that Apple is going to release something along the lines of the slate MS presented at CES. The rumor goes, that Jobs has asked, what good the the new tablet device could do besides browsing internet in the restroom. I guess they are not going to release one if it does not have an answer to this question.
- waterlesscloud 17y agoThe general population cares about being able to do what they want to do on their machines. If there's software people really want they they aren't "allowed" to run on their machine by the gatekeepers, they will, as they have countless times in the past, vote with their wallets.
- jrockway 17y agoUsers don't care about whether the platform is open directly. But they do benefit from the openness. An example that has been beaten to death; Google Voice. On my open phone, I dial with the normal dialer and my call is connected via Google Voice. On the iPhone, that is not possible. You have to go to a web page, dial a number, and wait for Google to call you. Not a good "user experience".
- iuguy 17y agoSymbian, the most popular OS on handsets of 2009 (according to http://www.webpronews.com/topnews/2009/05/27/comparing-smartphone-market-share-by-operating-system http://www.webpronews.com/topnews/2009/05/27/comparing-smart...) lets you run any software you want (unless specifically locked down, which I've never seen) and even allows you to install Python with a built in on-phone interpreter. A lot of people seem to act as though the iPhone is the second coming but it's not. The main reason the iPhone does better on the net seems to be more about the quality of the built-in browser than anything else.
- deleted 17y ago[deleted]
- drewcrawford 17y agoI don't know... I wonder if the netbook thing is a fad. I bought an eeepc. I spent a few weeks hackintoshing / writing drivers for it. That was fun, I guess. It runs sloooow as molasses though. I can see Steve's point. Tried a few Linux distros... all were either too slow or not powerful enough. Maybe I should try Windows 7? I don't know if I've just gotten addicted to my dual-core MBP or what. But the aggregate cost of waiting another second or so each page load makes me want to scream inside.
- brecht 17y agoNetbooks are the manifestation of a sort of inverse Moore's law, the race to the bottom in consumer electronics. I don't understand people who say they use these things on a daily basis. Do they have baby hands and eagle-eyed vision? Maybe I've been using Macs for too long, but mashing on a 0.8mm plastic bit for a left click just makes me want to break something. I go from a 15 inch screen to one of those 10 inch jobs and I want to kill myself. For any situation where one may conceivably use a netbook, either an iPhone or a real laptop always seems to be a better choice. And Jesus H. Christ, this article is exactly the sort of eye-roll-inducing, echo-chamber sycophancy that makes Jeff Atwood such a pain in the ass to read. "...this pivotal moment in computing ... I'm talking about unlimited access to the complete sum of human knowledge, and free, unfettered communication with anyone on earth ... Netbooks aren't an alternative to notebook computers. They are the new computers." Gag me. I mean, there's a point in there, probably, somewhere, beneath all the layers of self-important ego-stroking. But Atwood just can't seem to write a persuasive piece without resorting to this Ivory Tower holier-than-thou bullshit. I can't be the only one that thinks this, can I?
- samdk 17y agoI'd recommend an older Linux distro or Windows XP and using Chrome as your browser (rather than Firefox). My Eee boots in about 25 seconds (15 from hibernate) and feels quite fast.
- maclifer 17y agoAgreed. A friend just installed Ubuntu Netbook Remix on my Asus 1000HE and it's very nice. I'm not a power user or Linux "geek" but have to say I love it. It felt great to completely blow Win XP off the unit... it became a completely new computer all over again after having it for 8 months. Really turned it into a new experience. Very fast. Easy to use. Chrome works beautifully. The whole experience makes XP appear even more ridiculously slow (and bloated) than i'd realized. Oh, one last thing - Chrome is incredible! What a difference it makes - super fast, quick loading, no bloat. I loaded it at work on an older Win XP Pro unit and it made IE8 look so poorly executed. I've also used Chrome on our fleet of macs at home and am impressed with its speed.
- samuel 17y agoI wouldn't call that "thing" a netbook, but a small laptop. The iBook was about the same size and nobody called it a "netbook". For me "a netbook" it's something similar to a product really called Netbook, the Psion Teklogix's "Netbook Pro". It was a little laptop with touchscreen, flash storage, and an Xscale processor running Windows CE. I used to work for a warehousing company, and warehouse managers loved it. They could browse the Intranet, run a TN5250 terminal, answer email, etc... at any point of the warehouse, carrying almost no weight and, the most important thing, with near zero waiting time. It just booted in seconds. It was outrageusly expensive, may be something like 2000eur. I understand that's the device Google has envisioned for its Google OS (but much cheaper obviously). A non-x86 CPU, flash storage, may be a touchscreen... something just different from the laptop you would use to run Windows, not just smaller.
- Zak 17y agoI agree fully. I've been largely disappointed with the netbook market simply being low-end laptop PCs. Something like the Touchbook might actually interest me (but give it more cores, please).
- gwern 17y ago> I wouldn't call that "thing" a netbook, but a small laptop. The iBook was about the same size and nobody called it a "netbook". I agree. I'm surprised Jeff missed the obvious rhetorical reply: 'Netbooks aren't lame laptops; laptops are lame netbooks.' (And then one would go on to enumerate the advantages of size, battery-life, etc. and give the little mini-history of computer trends.)
- Zak 17y agoI'm not sure about being cheaper without the Microsoft tax. A few months ago, I was browsing a variety of netbook models and found no significant discounts for Linux. Dell actually charged more for Ubuntu than XP on one model. I think the reason is all the bundled trial software; they make enough money from the bundling to offset the Windows license and maybe even make a little profit. I think this, more than any pressure from Microsoft, cooperative marketing or lack of user demand is the reason PC manufacturers are reluctant to offer Linux and make it hard to find when they do.
- rauljara 17y agoHe seems big on the "no monthly contracts" thing. But an increasing number of netbooks are being sold with data plans, and there's no reason to think this trend won't continue. Consumers prefer the monthly fees and subsidized purchase price to the lump sum buy-it-all-at-once price, even though it ends up costing them more. The idea that you can buy a semi-useful service and get an essentially free netbook is a very psychologically (if not economically) appealing notion, and one that I am sure companies will increasingly exploit.
- iamelgringo 17y agoI did a lot of transatlantic flying this past year. I bought an acer aspire one, gave it 2gb of ram, bought a 9 cell extra battery, installed windows 7 ultimate and never looked back. Between both my batteries, I have 16 hours of constant laptop usage. It's enought to get me from barcelona to san francisco without a plug in. I really couldn't be happier. I just never think about running out of power any more. And, I have a full dev box at my disposal that's lighter and smaller than most of the books I carry around with me to read.
- wvenable 17y agoThe thing I find with netbooks is that almost everyone is universally happy with them: geeks and non-geeks alike. It seems the only people really complaining are technology writers looking for more readers.
- leoc 17y agoAlso companies who sell expensive laptops (eg. Sony), and the companies who supply them expensive laptop components (eg. Intel, Microsoft). This may have something to do with the tech writers' sourness on netbooks too.
- Xichekolas 17y agoPeople are happy with netbooks unless they expect their laptop to be a desktop replacement. As the owner of a nice beefy desktop, I find my eeepc to be delightful. Hour for hour, I probably even spend more time on it, but I never have to feel the frustration of not being able to do something, because I have my desktop machine.
- wvenable 17y agoMost netbook owners I know also have laptops (usually as their primary desktop replacement). So I guess laptops have becomes desktops and netbooks have become laptops as far as people are using them now.
- dws 17y agoBeware of sample bias: People who have netbooks may be universally happy with them, but you're not hearing from the population who found the keyboards too small to type on comfortably (even for short-haul typing such as emails) and opted for something with a full-sized keyboard. Jeff found a model with a full-sized keyboard, but those are very recent. Stores in my area don't stock them yet.
- wvenable 17y agoIt's not really sample bias; had those people returned their netbooks or complained bitterly how small they are, then I'd have posted an entirely different comment. I didn't even want a netbook, it was given to me as a gift from someone looking specifically to get me a completely superfluous technology item. I didn't think I'd use it since I have a really nice laptop. I have no complaints with the keyboard -- it's the lack of vertical pixels that is annoying.
- nzmsv 17y agoI wonder if Chrome OS would still fit the requirement of "runs my software". Yes, you can navigate to any web app you want, but there is no control of the hardware.
- jmtulloss 17y agoI think there will be more control of hardware as time goes on. Palm provided methods of accessing hardware in the browser for webOS, I suspect Google will do something similar for web pages that you give permission to.
- netcan 17y agoIt is very bizarre that netbooks, of all things, are something that people react to in such an idealistic (not sure if that it the right word) way. There are some interesting debates like cloud vs local power or reinventing (touch screen) vs tweaking (small keyboard) embedded but you can talk about these separately if they are really what you are getting at. Netbooks are just another range of options in the computer family alongside normal laptops, desktops, desktop replacements, workstations, etc.). Why would anybody possibly object to that? I mean there are plenty of reasons for plenty of people not to by one (I don't have one) or not to personally like them (eg can't adjust to the keyboard). Why do people object to (or defend) their existence?
- iuguy 17y agoMy netbook is an old Sony Vaio SRX51P/B that I bought for £2000 back in 2001. It had sat on the shelf for a couple of years as the Lucent Orinoco WiFi chipset didn't support WPA, had 256mb of RAM and the hard drive kept crapping out. I recently put a 30gb hard drive in, an atheros USB wifi stick and installed Arch Linux on there and it's fantastic. It's not as quick as a modern laptop but is more than capable of basic browsing and xterm-based fun. Aside from the two years that I haven't used it, the overall cost works out at roughly £250 per year. It has a 10.4" screen and aside from the memory is roughly comparable to an EEE PC 701 in terms of performance. I'm more than happy with it and it still holds a charge, 9 years later.
- knieveltech 17y agoNetbook as victory of the proletariat? I think not.