3 ms·
Without having looked at the numbers, my knee-jerk interpretation of the ad was "The gummint is taking OUR HARD-EARNED MONEY and just giving it to LIBRARIES, an
by PhasmaFelis 11y ago
Without having looked at the numbers, my knee-jerk interpretation of the ad was "The gummint is taking OUR HARD-EARNED MONEY and just giving it to LIBRARIES, and the damned things AREN'T EVEN OPEN LATE."
There are less awful interpretations, but most people don't spend a lot of time pondering the implications of bus station ads; they really should have known better than to run something that could possibly be interpreted that way. And I can't think of any interpretations that are actually positive. I mean, at root, they're trying to remind us that they pay taxes which are spent on government services. And...what? So does everybody else. We're supposed to praise them? Feel sorry for them?
- _delirium 11y ago> I can't think of any interpretations that are actually positive. I can think of what they might've been aiming for. My read is that it was attempting to come off as cutesy/joking but didn't pull it off. I think I've seen this ad style before, though I'm drawing a blank on a good example. A fake "you're welcome" from a brand, "You're welcome for [thing], make sure to spend/not spend it [in accordance with knowing in-joke]. Love, Your Friends at Brand". The problem here was that instead of cutesy in-joke, it came off as a mix of smug on one hand, and complaining about libraries on the other, which isn't really the right tone for what the campaign is trying to achieve. One thing I'd be curious about is where the ads originated. Is it AirBnB itself being tone-deaf, or did they contract the campaign out to an ad agency that bungled it?
- JoBrad 11y agoTheir other ads say things like "Don't spend it all in one place." So I think the smug interpretation wasn't far off.