4 ms·
You don't need more feedback from other, unfunded founders. You need feedback from customers. Networking with other founders isn't a very useful activity once y
by smt88 11y ago
You don't need more feedback from other, unfunded founders. You need feedback from customers. Networking with other founders isn't a very useful activity once you already have your co-founder. If you're not coding, spend all of every day on customer discovery.
- xmly 11y agothen why yc alumni network exists? Why yc provides mentors? Whose feedback is more valuable, mentors or customers?
- smt88 11y agoThe entire assumption of YC (and all investors, really) is that they're able to select companies that are likely to succeed. I'm not saying YC (or anyone) is good at it, but let's pretend that they are. You're proposing to create a group of people who YC has decided are not likely to succeed. That doesn't make any sense. YC alumni might want to be in a network so they can collaborate, make deals with each other, or find new jobs when their own company fails. Why would you want to do that with the rejected group? Why not try to do that with other companies in general? There are lots of opportunities to meet other founders in any city with a decent level of entrepreneurship.
- xmly 11y agoSee, you already give me feedback and you are not my customer.
- jjoe 11y agoYou're stopping short of saying YC-rejected groups are failures (less likely to succeed) ergo their advice will certainly fall short. But then we learn better from failure in general and the failure of others. I think that rejected YC companies are one step closer to success. So why not...
- smt88 11y ago> we learn better from failure in general and the failure of others If they've been rejected from YC, they're not failures. They're still working on their idea. You can't learn from their failure until they actually fail. It's also really hard to learn from the failures of others. Most people only learn the hard way. I'm one of them, so I don't meant that in a judgmental way at all.
- brudgers 11y agoI think the process of applying is useful for some people At least for me, it took me outside my comfort zone. I've always just operated under my own name and spokesmodelling "a company" instead for the video created a cognitive shift that I didn't know existed. This article is probably a reasonable way to look at not getting accepted: http://mathwithbaddrawings.com/2015/09/30/why-ive-stopped-doing-interviews-for-yale/ http://mathwithbaddrawings.com/2015/09/30/why-ive-stopped-do...
- brudgers 11y agoThere's actually a subtle difference in YC's criteria. YC selects against false positives rather than against false negatives. This means that YC selects with the knowing that some rejected companies are likely to succeed. YC also selects against companies that do not fit it's model, e.g. the recent thread where the founder wanted to organize as a UK LTD rather than a Delaware corporation. To put it another way, even though asshole founders can succeed, YC purportedly selects against possible asshole founders when they are identifable. Part of this I suspect is general principle. Part, I suspect, is that asshole founders create additional work. Finally, most entrepreneurs in most cities are not founding the sort of businesses that YC and the rest of Silicon Valley would classify as startups. Outside the bubble, an LLC that opens a restaurant gets called "a startup". While there are people in most markets doing businesses that take rocket fuel and either blow up or reach orbit, that model is much rarer out in the regular world.
- GFischer 11y agoYou can also use Show HN and Hacker News itself if you need more feedback (especially if it's your target demographic). If we're not your target, you might not get the feedback you need. Edit: there are lots of other networks available too. Getting into YC is extremely hard due to the sheer amount of applications they get, but they're not the only mentorship opportunity you can get. In my case, we're being mentored by a local university, they don't have YC's pedigree but they helped several very succesful companies by local standards.
- brudgers 11y agoOn the one hand I agree that networking with other founders is pretend work that's easier than the real work of finding customers. On the other, my read of the question is that the goal is to overcome the disadvantage of a narrow network of which solo founding is a symptom. While there are people who can solo found a startup, there are people who can't and among those people some, though not all that should, realize that the first hurdle to creating a probable successful startup is expanding their network to include viable potential cofounders. The analogy to YC's alumni network would be that YC alumni from different initial companies sometimes join together to form new companies or go to work for successful YC companies based on network effects. That said, I don't at all disagree that product and customers are in general much more important than networking with other entrepreneurs. That doesn't mean that for some people finding a cofounder isn't a priority or that expanding a professional network could not be more important "right now" for long term success. Logistics also matter...so long as they don't displace head down determination to work like a rented mule.