7 ms·
What we should always keep in mind when bosses of ad funded services speak about what users want is that these users are not their customers. Users are just an
by fauigerzigerk 17y ago
What we should always keep in mind when bosses of ad funded services speak about what users want is that these users are not their customers.
Users are just an indirect means to make advertisers happy, and that indirection is a complex thing. If Facebook can make advertisers happy by hurting users without losing them they will.
Facebook has a history of deception. Nobody should be surprised to hear the kind of disingenuous nonsense coming from Mr. Zuckerberg.
- jacquesm 17y agoI can't stand the guy, but at least he's eating his own dogfood: http://www.facebook.com/markzuckerberg http://www.facebook.com/markzuckerberg
- bootload 17y ago"... at least he's eating his own dogfood ..." This is pretty recent, I mean post 2009DEC14 because I checked. Prior to that the site was by friending only. But do you really think this is his private account where his friends hang out for all to see? ~ http://www.facebook.com/search/?q=Mark+Zuckerberg&init=quick http://www.facebook.com/search/?q=Mark+Zuckerberg&init=q...
- jacquesm 17y agoI'm sorry, I don't go to great lengths to figure out what mr. Zuckerberg is up to, I just put his name in google and that page popped out. It ought to be a rule that anybody associated with a company like that (say, Google, Facebook, etc) should have all their data public and with privacy settings at 'default'.
- rythie 17y agoHe is updating twice a month! most people on Twitter update a lot more than that - I don't think he is keeping up with the trend.
- jacquesm 17y agoThat's more frequently than I update mine.
- kelnos 17y agoThat's actually his "fan" page. His FB profile page is here: http://www.facebook.com/zuck http://www.facebook.com/zuck ... and I'm surprised to see it seems to be mostly open.
- richardw 17y agoIs it? I see "Mark only shares some of his Profile information with everyone." and the rest looks pretty locked down to me. Who are his friends? Where pics?
- kelnos 17y agoAhh, I guess he has his profile set to "friends of friends," so I can see his profile info since he and I have mutual friends.
- adriand 17y agoI'm not so sure that "users are not their customers". I was thinking about this yesterday when I talked to my father-in-law (probably the only person I know without Internet or a computer) about a rapidly growing Facebook group opposed to the suspension of parliament in Canada. He asked me to add him to the list, but I told him he'd have to be on Facebook for that to happen. He replied, "oh, so only customers of Facebook can join?" I thought his use of the word "customers" was odd, because I was thinking that "users" would be more appropriate. But then I got to thinking. Yes, advertisers are clearly customers of Facebook: they pay money in return for a service. But these advertisers wouldn't pay a dime were it not for Facebook's users, who represent to advertisers either existing or potential customers. In that sense, users are very clearly customers, though not necessarily customers of Facebook. However, time is money, and users of Facebook are spending a lot of it on Facebook ("spending time" on Facebook: the connection between time and money is clear). Furthermore, the time they spend on Facebook is crucial to Facebook's ability to attract and retain advertisers. This makes them very much like customers, I think: they are purchasing a service from Facebook with something valuable (their time), and if they did not do so, the company would fail.
- fauigerzigerk 17y agoI don't necessarily disagree with everything you said. What you describe is part of that complex indirection I mentioned. But at the end of the day it's not definitions of "customer" that matter so much as what kinds of incentives this triangle structure comprising service provider, user and advertiser actually provides to each party. (As far as definitions go you could just as well say that users are merchandise in this case) There is clearly a vested interest on the part of service providers to make users hand over control of as much data as possible, no matter if it's good or bad for them. How convenient that all of a sudden society has changed its attitude towards privacy, and users now _want_ service providers to help them share share share everything with everyone else. I wonder where Mr. Zuckerberg's sociological studies may lead us next. Maybe society changes again and users want Facebook to send product recommendations in their name? It's such a hassle to maintain all those friendships manually. Clearly, we need help in feeding our friends with fresh, valuable information every day! How about an automated Friendfeed? ;-)
- 17y ago