3 ms·
"'The results of the current study suggest that we may actually treat people more harshly when their problem is described in disease terms,' Mehta wrote. 'We sa
by tokenadult 17y ago
"'The results of the current study suggest that we may actually treat people more harshly when their problem is described in disease terms,' Mehta wrote. 'We say we are being kind, but our actions suggest otherwise.' The problem, it appears, is that the biomedical narrative about an illness like schizophrenia carries with it the subtle assumption that a brain made ill through biomedical or genetic abnormalities is more thoroughly broken and permanently abnormal than one made ill though life events. 'Viewing those with mental disorders as diseased sets them apart and may lead to our perceiving them as physically distinct. Biochemical aberrations make them almost a different species.'"
- jacquesm 17y agoThis happens with 'regular' handicapped people too, as soon as there is anything at all visibly/perceivably wrong with your body people will also automatically assume that you are somehow mentally damaged and/or different from 'us' the 'normals'. I've seen this up close with a friend who is paralyzed from the waist down and gets treated like a child on plenty of occasions. He's whip smart and runs a successful electronics business and he can get really steamed up about this (rightly so).
- hga 17y agoI'm committing the sin of not reading the fine article, but if you've spent any time around an uncontrolled (i.e. unmedicated) schizophrenic you realize their thinking is fundamentally broken. They are in a sense "thoroughly broken and permanently abnormal" in a way that only medicine can treat. Cognitive Behavioral therapy can help and sometimes fix a lot of things like standard depression, but there's absolutely no substitute for antipsychotics for the schizophrenic and mood stabilizers for the bipolar (which hopefully TFA pointed out). My mom became an RN at a fascinating time in the '50s: she did 3 months of her residency in a psych ward, and then a few years later she was amazed to see one of the "hopeless" cases from there working at her hospital in a service role. That was after the first antipsychotics came out, and they truly are wonder drugs. All that said, the thesis might be correct, although I seriously wonder if the layman's view of the mentally ill is that nuanced. A lot of people don't want to have anything to do with the "mentally ill", full stop....