3 ms·
No offense meant to Aphyr, whose work is awesome, but conflicts of interest are incredibly corrosive. The sales cycle for consulting services requires a "gotta
by wpietri 11y ago
No offense meant to Aphyr, whose work is awesome, but conflicts of interest are incredibly corrosive. The sales cycle for consulting services requires a "gotta keep the customer happy" attitude. That's hard to square with truly impartial judgment. It's not that you give in to the dark side; once you take somebody's money you're no longer impartial, so you end up having to try to simulate it.
It's even harder to square with the appearance of impartial judgment. What if a product is honestly great? If we decide that he's being fair because he says both positive and negative things, he has an incentive to create the appearance of fairness rather than actual fairness.
There's a reason that systems where truth is important (e.g., legal proceedings, medicine, science) have complicated rules around conflicts of interest. I hope he finds a way to find funding that doesn't put either his judgment or his reputation at risk. Consider, e.g., Consumer Reports: they get money from their subscribers, not advertisers or manufacturers. Maybe he could let database users fund all his public Jepsen work.