5 ms·
It might actually be a good thing for the taxpayers of that country when looked at narrowly, which is often why these deals are done, but if every EU nation doe
by ZeroGravitas 11y ago
It might actually be a good thing for the taxpayers of that country when looked at narrowly, which is often why these deals are done, but if every EU nation does it to their neighbour then overall it's a classic case of "race to the bottom" and taxpayers all across the EU will lose out.
- pjmlp 11y agoSpecially when companies play the game "trick the government", like e.g. Nokia. They moved their plant from Germany to Romania, got the "Company of the Year" award from the Romanian government and about two years later moved the factory again to an Asian country. In the process they got two angry governments and now they are as they are.
- ptaipale 11y agoThey didn't really "move" plants around; they were expanding production on different markets to meet needs on these countries and continents, and also withdrawing manufacturing in some places (the big mistake in Germany, I understand, was the purchase and attempted conversion of an old television factory in Bochum). While I don't fully understand the case with the Romanian plant and why it was shut down so soon, what Nokia is now has little to do with their plant management strategy (except that I think it was efficient as long as plants were needed) and everything to do with senior management's product decisions (not production management). (FWIW, Nokia is currently a profitable company, just not in the phone terminal business.)
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- TeMPOraL 11y ago> They didn't really "move" plants around; they were expanding production on different markets to meet needs on these countries and continents, and also withdrawing manufacturing in some places Ah, the tactical decisions. "We're not retreating, we're just advancing in a different direction."
- ptaipale 11y agoIndeed. For another example, the trade union of horse carriage drivers for People's Co-Op Stores in Finland (Elanto) is still on strike (which started in 1930 and never ended). They just moved on to advance in a different direction (i.e. started driving lorries, and the union eventually merged/became part of the local "teamsters" union).
- distances 11y agoThere were no angry governments, that is just your sour grapes about the globalization. Finland lost production to Germany, Germany to Romania, and Romania to Asia, and blaming a single company is quite naive. Nokia's downfall was due to software issues, and certainly had nothing to do with improved efficiency thanks to production optimization.
- pjmlp 11y agoWhich just proves you are not located in NRW German state nor in Romania.
- lucio 11y agoSo companies should be forced at gunpoint to produce on a specific country?
- furyg3 11y agoI think the Swedish and Romanian taxpayers were held at gunpoint in this scenario
- lucio 11y agoBy their own governments I assume. If you want to do an experimental check: just try to not pay taxes for a while, and you'll find yourself at the wrong end of a govt. gun eventually.
- TeMPOraL 11y ago> By their own governments I assume. Which itself was held at gunpoint by Moloch[0]. That's how it works - everyone has to play and lose because those who don't play lose first to those who do. [0] - http://slatestarcodex.com/2014/07/30/meditations-on-moloch/ http://slatestarcodex.com/2014/07/30/meditations-on-moloch/
- AnthonyMouse 11y ago> It might actually be a good thing for the taxpayers of that country when looked at narrowly, which is often why these deals are done, but if every EU nation does it to their neighbour then overall it's a classic case of "race to the bottom" and taxpayers all across the EU will lose out. The problem is that countries refusing to compete with each other doesn't actually help all of them. Countries like Germany have strong infrastructure, high availability of qualified labor, etc. If Romania had the same taxes as Germany then who would expand into Romania? And of course taking taxes off the table would just shift the issue to spending. If you required countries to have a uniform (presumably high) tax rate then they could just spend the money on things that encourage companies to expand there and you're right back to the same situation. Countries compete with each other to attract capital. The only way to stop that is to prevent the movement of capital across national borders, which is a completely unrealistic bad idea.
- VSerge 11y agoTo answer your question, everyone interested in paying much lower salaries to their workforce may decide to locate a factory in Romania. Market size, cost of operation, infrastructure, neighboring markets, and many more factors play an important role in such decisions. Taxes are far from being the most meaningful factor, and governments dumb enough to offer such deals are acting disgracefully towards both their tax-paying citizenry and their EU partners who don't engage in this race to the bottom.
- AnthonyMouse 11y ago> To answer your question, everyone interested in paying much lower salaries to their workforce may decide to locate a factory in Romania. Market size, cost of operation, infrastructure, neighboring markets, and many more factors play an important role in such decisions. Of course there are many factors that go into it. What matters is how the country stacks up on balance. Countries that stack up unfavorably have no financial capacity to address their shortcomings because you can't build infrastructure or education with no money and governments can't collect money with no tax base. What they can do is lower taxes to attract investment so they can get 5% of something instead of 30% of nothing. Their primary alternative for attracting investment is to abandon safety and environmental regulations, which is not better.
- commandar 11y agoAn example I can think of offhand is AMD (now Global Foundaries) choosing to locate one of their new fabs in Dresden after being offered lucrative tax benefits by the German government. AMD got to save money on the fab, Germany got long term economic investment in the former east. It was pretty much a win-win deal.