6 ms·
> It's a status game, and I luckily started to notice it while very young. You see this often when engineers meet. If the group is new, and haven't establish
by rdtsc 17y ago
> It's a status game, and I luckily started to notice it while very young.
You see this often when engineers meet. If the group is new, and haven't established a status hierarchy already, they will quickly start throwing jargon around at each other, to show who is more knowledgeable and try to make others look stupid. That quickly establishes who is who on the status ladder and then the meeting or discussion proceeds on. I think of apes beating their chests and throwing sticks around to show their might.
Once you become aware of it, it is quite amusing to watch. I started chuckling during a meeting we had with 2 new consultants, and everyone started looking at me strange...
But there is an upside to it. To a certain extent it is necessary to establish a hierarchy, because a senior engineer's opinion is worth listening to a lot more than a junior's engineers opinion. Time is money. If Joe is a senior engineer and we have all as a group accept it, we will drill down and explore his suggestions, if Steve, a junior engineer proposes something, we won't consider it as seriously. For us to consider Steve's suggestions, he'll have to prove himself.
I think it is necessary to emphasize that this extends to professional domain knowledge. It is absolutely unacceptable to put anyone down because of their religion, sex orientation, skin color, or body shape. Otherwise, at least were I work, we have no qualms telling people they are full of shit, when it comes to domain knowledge.
- CamperBob 17y agoIt is absolutely unacceptable to put anyone down because of their religion Wait, I can't make fun of Scientologists?
- rdtsc 17y agoYou can, but do it in your own time, not at work.
- Confusion 17y agoIf a consultant turns out to be a Scientologist, it will make me seriously doubt his sanity, as well as his moral fiber. That makes it very much relevant to work. Political correctness can be very harmful, if it causes you too ignore the real impact that who someone is can have.
- bootload 17y ago"... You see this often when engineers meet. If the group is new, and haven't established a status hierarchy already, they will quickly start throwing jargon around at each other, to show who is more knowledgeable and try to make others look stupid. ..." Great observation. Mean girls and Queen-bee behaviour in engineers ~ http://www.amazon.com/Queen-Bees-Wannabes-Boyfriends-Realities/dp/0307454444 http://www.amazon.com/Queen-Bees-Wannabes-Boyfriends-Realiti... "... But there is an upside to it. ..." In the natural world, "status hierarchy" is used to protect the integrity of groups at the expense of pions. So there is upside. You see it in Bees for example: ~ http://www.thaindian.com/newsportal/sci-tech/researchers-unravel-secret-of-queen-bees-behaviour_100227498.html http://www.thaindian.com/newsportal/sci-tech/researchers-unr... "... I think it is necessary to emphasize that this extends to professional domain knowledge. It is absolutely unacceptable to put anyone down because of their religion, sex orientation, skin color, or body shape. ..." It's naive to think telling people "they are full of shit" won't have repercussions. If opinion is disregarded with such emotion it will have negative impacts on the team and team members. Queen bees use "homovanillyl alcohol" (HVA) to chemically interfere and suppress worker drones. Maybe in human teams, status is enforced through social pressure? "... Evolution has provided queen bees with a chemical that selectively blocks aversive learning but leaves reward learning intact ..." Now that's an idea worth exploring. How to knock down potentially inefficient ideas more efficiently?
- rdtsc 17y ago> It's naive to think telling people "they are full of shit" won't have repercussions. Yes, it does have repercussions. It usually doesn't come to that. But the benefit outweighs the repercussions. It creates a level of trust between us, because we cut through bullshit and passive aggressive "fake niceness". We yell at each other, but then we also apologize to each other. We mitigate the repercussion by screening heavily based on personality when we hire. When we hire people we make it explicit that this is the environment. Candidates spend a whole day with us, we go to lunch together, we do a debug session, we ask them to participate in some mock-up or simple design spec with a group of engineers and white-board. Some otherwise good engineers didn't end up working for us because we didn't like their personality, some were terrified that we threw the "f" word around too much, some thought us as not too "politically correct". So far this has worked for the company for 20 years, I've been with them for 3 years and I really like it.
- jackchristopher 17y agoIn improv acting we explicitly learn how status transactions work. Note that "status" in this context means something slightly different: http://greenlightwiki.com/improv/Status http://greenlightwiki.com/improv/Status Understanding status changed how I fundamentally view interactions. I've wanted to submit (or even write) something on this for HN, but I haven't figured an angle to do it from.
- jerf 17y agoSounds interesting. "Here's what I learned about status in improv class" sounds like a good enough angle to me!
- jackchristopher 17y agoA lot here are from SF. It's an improv hub. BATS Improv has classes, and I highly recommend them for really anyone. But specifically "nerds" would immensely benefit. Improv basically teaches you to be relentlessly prosocial. You learn what an interesting social interaction (or scene) looks like. You learn conversation and organization skills; how to lead, how to follow, how to work on teams, how to speak. It's all roleplaying. Actually, you learn the gist of what they would teach your in the "seduction community". Those are more specialized skills. But there's no social stigma attached. And that's not a knock on them either.
- rdtsc 17y agoThat was a very interesting read. Thank you. Yes, it seems like improv, is really good at emphasizing and making explicit human interactions. This might be applicable to AI agent research and design. If you do your write-up, I will gladly read!
- jackchristopher 17y agoYeah, the first AI would pass the Turing test by insulting the researchers. :) But seriously, depending on what you mean by AI (general or narrow), you're right. If it was interacting in a realistic social way with humans, it'd have to understand "status". Actually, I know of some people working on AGI that are aware of the "status" concept. Although they seem to conflate the improv meaning with general social status. On Less Wrong.com they talk about it from time to time.
- ntoshev 17y agoUnlike the conversations in question, engineers have something to back their status - proficiency, domain expertise. It's one thing to establish the expert in the room, and totally different to see who will be able to project the hardest empty shell of self-confidence around himself.