3 ms·
It was a good article until Desaultel's ignorant claim that "full disclosure is a farce." His supporting arguments actually support a reasonable delay between d
by nickpsecurity 11y ago
It was a good article until Desaultel's ignorant claim that "full disclosure is a farce." His supporting arguments actually support a reasonable delay between disclosure to the software provider and to the public rather than entirely counter full disclosure. The difference between many companies' approach to handling vulnerability reports before and after full disclosure speaks for itself:
https://www.schneier.com/essays/archives/2007/01/schneier_full_disclo.html https://www.schneier.com/essays/archives/2007/01/schneier_fu...
I got to experience plenty of that myself when I started. They (a) didn't care, (b) called me a liar, or (c) called me well-intentioned but too incompetent to assess the [non-existent] risk to their users/customers. This continued while Microsoft and other big names got smashed by more attacks than we could keep track of which were often easily prevented (eg buffer overflows). Eventually, many companies were forced to do something for real about their software quality thanks to all the attacks and disclosures w/ exploits as proof. Microsoft adopting SDL and mitigation practices is probably the greatest success of full disclosure given their near monopoly on desktops.
Interesting enough, he kind of contradicts his own position later. He first argues against full disclosure as purely damaging with no benefit because nobody can keep systems updated at the necessary rate. Then, he says security in his testing improved from 4 minutes to 1 hour to break thanks to awareness from all the breaches in the news that he implies are partly due to full disclosure. So, did they have zero benefit or did they plus black hats benefit via awareness? Even he can't seem to buy his own claim twice in the same article...
- newsignup 11y ago> Then, he says security in his testing improved from 4 minutes to 1 hour to break thanks to awareness from all the breaches in the news that he implies are partly due to full disclosure. We can think of it as a silver lining.
- nickpsecurity 11y agoI think it's more a necessity given human nature and these types of people (i.e. head in sand). A known weakness of human mind is responding go immediate threats more than what data shows it even if data is clear and is a huge threat. People also react better to stories. Both full disclosure and breaches in media create the impression of immediate threat with incentives to CYA or do some real security. So, more like parents slapping their kids hands or spanking them for trying to touch a hot stove except with most kids continuing despite all the burned hands and sore asses around them. Crazy stuff. It's why I don't worry what happens to the careless anymore as they cause their own problems. Full disclosure mainly benefits those who pay attention and try to keep a solid baseline.