5 ms·
He assembled two broken clocks together into a $20 box he bought. He didn't make a clock, exactly, but he didn't claim to. And it changes nothing. To claim tha
by TazeTSchnitzel 11y ago
He assembled two broken clocks together into a $20 box he bought. He didn't make a clock, exactly, but he didn't claim to.
And it changes nothing. To claim that he was trying to make it look like a bomb for attention is absurd.
- nikolay 11y agoIt does change things as the media (including the social media) has presented things much differently.
- hugh4 11y agoWhy is it absurd? Whether it's true or false is another issue (I don't claim to know his motivations) but absurd?
- rayiner 11y ago> And it changes nothing. To claim that he was trying to make it look like a bomb for attention is absurd. What is more absurd: that a teenager violated a school rule to get attention, or that a whole bunch of school administrators and police officers couldn't tell an alarm clock apart from a bomb?
- fein 11y agoWhat's most absurd is that his parents weren't wise enough (optimistic theory) to tell their kid that this was a very shitty idea. This is a case of parents using their child as a publicity stunt (pessimistic theory).
- beeboop 11y agoThe administration knew it wasn't a bomb. If they actually thought it was a bomb, even slightly, they would have had a bomb drill. They have bomb drills for anonymous phone calls for shit's sake. They knew it was a hoax and he was attention seeking which is why he was sent to the office.
- dragonwriter 11y ago> The administration knew it wasn't a bomb. If they actually thought it was a bomb, even slightly, they would have had a bomb drill. That may make unwarranted assumptions about competence of the particular officials involved. Though, I'd say that if they thought it was a bomb, then their reaction was just as bad as if they didn't, for a different set of reasons.
- TazeTSchnitzel 11y agoThat's irrelevant to the question of Ahmed's intent
- dogma1138 11y agoWhat's more absurd that he was suspended for either a silly prank, or for plugging an alarm clock with exposed wires and a transformer into an AC socket which went off during a class, refused to cooperate with the school administrators, and later then police or that Google invited him to the Science Fair for putting a radio shack clock in a box which put him in the same club as other attendees like 17 year old Olivia Hallisey who got her spot for inventing a new faster, cheaper, and more reliable method of detecting Ebola http://googleforeducation.blogspot.co.uk/2015/08/spotlight-on-young-scientist-olivia.html http://googleforeducation.blogspot.co.uk/2015/08/spotlight-o... or 13 year old Pranav Sivakumar who designed a machine learning algorithm that can detect Quasars through gravitational lensing which is now also being used to discover dark matter clusters http://googleforeducation.blogspot.co.uk/2015/08/spotlight-on-young-scientist-pranav.html http://googleforeducation.blogspot.co.uk/2015/08/spotlight-o...?
- qyv 11y agoWhy is it so absurd? Because young people never do stupid things for attention? Was the school/police reaction over the top? Yes, for sure. Is the counter-reaction given to this kid in an effort to appear to appear to be on the side of goodness and rationality equally silly? Absolutely.
- InclinedPlane 11y agoBecause he didn't, period. There are only two scenarios here that are tenable. Either he built a real bomb and brought it to school or he didn't build a real bomb. If he didn't build a real bomb then the question becomes whether or not he attempted to scare people with a hoax bomb. Unquestionably he didn't build a real bomb. Moreover, he didn't attempt to scare anyone with a fake bomb either. He brought a clock to school. He insisted to everyone that it was a clock. And he tried to avoid showing it to people. That is not a hoax bomb in any sense of the word. If you don't have a hoax bomb and you don't have a real bomb then what do you have? Panic, and bigotry. Nothing more.
- tedks 11y agoThat is not how zero-tolerance policies are enforced in any school district.
- dragonwriter 11y ago> That is not how zero-tolerance policies are enforced in any school district. Zero-tolerance policies are their own can of worms, but neither such policies nor any possible explanation of their enforcement explains the characterizations made after the fact by both school and law enforcement officials regarding the supposed "hoax bomb".
- tedks 11y agohttp://www.irvingisd.net/cms/lib010/TX01917973/Centricity/Domain/1454/Irving%20ISD%20Student%20Code%20of%20Conduct%202015-2106%20English.pdf http://www.irvingisd.net/cms/lib010/TX01917973/Centricity/Do... http://pol.tasb.org/Policy/Download/367?filename=FOD(LEGAL).pdf http://pol.tasb.org/Policy/Download/367?filename=FOD(LEGAL).... These are the relevant documents. They are short enough to read them in less than 5 minutes. Can you tell me what the legally-mandated punishment is for bringing a non-weapon that resembles a weapon onto school grounds is? It's easy to bikeshed about "characterizations", but there are legally no other ways the school district could have reacted on the day they were making decisions.
- Consultant32452 11y agoCan we at least admit to ourselves that what he built would have passed for a bomb in a movie? Because while I agree the whole thing was handled poorly, it's not completely implausible to think that was a bomb.
- nitrogen 11y agoCan we at least admit to ourselves that what he built would have passed for a bomb in a movie? Can we at least admit that movies have approximately zero relevance to reality?
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- blakeyrat 11y agoEven in movies, bombs usually have this thing known as "explosives" attached to them somewhere.
- dragonwriter 11y ago> Can we at least admit to ourselves that what he built would have passed for a bomb in a movie? In the same way that a person dressed in the black garb worn by stagehands, by theatrical convention, passes as invisible. The appearance of bombs in movies is an artistic convention designed to provide dramatic tension. > Because while I agree the whole thing was handled poorly, it's not completely implausible to think that was a bomb. The school action would be even more ludicrously inappropriate if they did think it was a bomb.
- notahacker 11y agoTo be fair, it changes the narrative from "smart kid builds ingenious working electronic clock" to "tinkering kid disassembles clocks to make them (coincidentally or otherwise) look like Hollywood depictions of a bomb". The background context has the kid messing about with plenty of other electronic devices for fun, but it also has a politically-active father turning up at well-publicised Quran-burning events and claiming shock that the Quran was burned. It's not exactly beyond the realms of possibility that he might have seen the potential for his son's electronic experimentation to end in a suspension and similar barrage of publicity, even if the son himself is merely an innocuous hacker type with a fondness for electronics. Obviously any suggestion of intent still doesn't excuse the way the police reportedly handled things, or make Dawkins' attitude any less ridiculous.
- noobermin 11y ago>It's not exactly beyond the realms of possibility that he might have seen the potential for his son's electronic experimentation to end in a suspension and similar barrage of publicity. Even if Ahmed was being a delinquent, I can in no way understand how anyone can think this is true. Unless the father encouraged his son to take a bomb lookalike to school, how the hell could he, a 14 year old boy, have foreseen the act as attracting as much attention as it has? How could anyone?