4 ms·
Your argument is fallacious. An analogy of your argument: gravity exerts harmless levels of physical force on your body, therefore the government has the righ
by colordrops 11y ago
Your argument is fallacious.
An analogy of your argument: gravity exerts harmless levels of physical force on your body, therefore the government has the right to exert harmless levels of physical force on your body.
By the way, radiation exposure is cumulative throughout your lifetime. There is no safe minimum level of radiation exposure. How much radiation you get on a flight is irrelevant to the topic at hand.
- hugh4 11y agoThe government already entitles itself to do far worse things than bounce a few photons off me now and then -- eg every year they pry open my wallet and entitle themselves to a very large fraction of my income.
- nosuchthing 11y agoYou're free to move to other municipalities without public services, infrastructure, and taxes.
- TeMPOraL 11y agoYou should also be wary to chose the new place carefully, there are many areas on Earth where the background radiation is higher than in NY with a scan-van on every corner working constantly.
- dguaraglia 11y agoSo, by that argument, we should just let the government do anything then? I once had a similar argument with a friend who insisted there should be stricter gun laws "because the government already has tanks and planes, so the second amendment doesn't make any sense anymore; they could always bomb the shit out of the public if they wanted." I think the opposite is truth: we need to act now while we still have some power, rather than assume a defeatist attitude and let our children and their children at the mercy of a fully omnipotent government.
- VLM 11y agoA far better gravitational analogy, assuming I did the numbers right in my head, when a cop stands a normal distance away from me while talking to me, the gravitational force he exerts on my body is assaulting me with about ten billionths of a newton. Depending on how many donuts he's eaten in his career the force might be higher but it would be in the "dozens of billionths of a newton" for sure. And no means no, and no level of assault is acceptable. Having a cop stand to either side of me superficially would balance the gravitational force, but unfortunately I'd still be getting violently physically assaulted by tidal forces as my flesh stretches out ever so microscopically toward them both.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- nitrogen 11y agoBy the way, radiation exposure is cumulative throughout your lifetime. There is no safe minimum level of radiation exposure. How much radiation you get on a flight is irrelevant to the topic at hand. AIUI the "linear no threshold" model of radiation is widely accepted, but not universally accepted. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Linear_no-threshold_model#Controversy https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Linear_no-threshold_model#Cont...
- TeMPOraL 11y ago> By the way, radiation exposure is cumulative throughout your lifetime. There is no safe minimum level of radiation exposure. How much radiation you get on a flight is irrelevant to the topic at hand. It still doesn't matter; assuming the official values are correct within two orders of magnitude, those scans still get dwarfed by the natural background radiation you are exposed to every day. Complaining about this, or expecting someone to get consent for such levels of radiation, is ridiculous (yes, there are very important reasons for which one should oppose those scans, but radiation is not one of them). It's just failure of thinking by refusing to do the math. By the same token, why should we allow you to increase risk of heart attack of everyone here by using scary-sounding words like "radiation exposure" in the comments? Stress adds up too. Please meditate over this handy reference chart: https://xkcd.com/radiation/ https://xkcd.com/radiation/.
- colordrops 11y agoI think most of us here are aware of the basic nature of radiation exposure and have also seen this popular XKCD chart. I personally had to learn a lot about radiation exposure due to a bout with thyroid cancer and radiation treatment and scans. But that is not the point. It's not about the dangers of radiation. It's about the right to expose people to radiation at all, regardless of the danger level. By your reasoning, it would be OK for the police to take a few pennies here and there from large bank accounts.
- TeMPOraL 11y ago> By your reasoning, it would be OK for the police to take a few pennies here and there from large bank accounts. By my reasoning it's ok for the police to drive around in their cars even though they add up to traffic, which costs a lot of people some pennies lost in gasoline and opportunity cost. The only reason we're talking about it is because "radiation" sound scary while other things, like "time lost in increased traffic" do not. At the levels of danger we're talking about here we should not be bringing concept of people's rights, lest we want to also regulate disagreeing in Internet comments because of increased heart attack risk from stress.