2 ms·
Whats the alternative to CA being able to delegate signing? Would you prefer having browsers constantly being updated with new lists of CA's, maybe one new per
by belorn 11y ago
Whats the alternative to CA being able to delegate signing? Would you prefer having browsers constantly being updated with new lists of CA's, maybe one new per day.
Second, would you prefer that browsers blessed a new CA completely independently? If not then who should have that power? Governments? Non-profit organizations like ISRG?
The big alternative is to maintain your own list of trusted CA's, going through each and every new CA that you encounter and associate a trust relationship. Not even famous security researchers do this, and I can't really blame them as it is like a lawyer reading every EULA that they encounter and fully investigate the scope of them. The scope and complexity just get beyond what a single person can manage.
- gergles 11y agoYeah, I guess I think it makes more sense for the browser manufacturers to be the people to whom I delegate that responsibility. I already trust them not to run malware on my computer and to accurately display the SSL state of a connection. I just think it's odd that any CA can turn around and make any other random CA fully blessed. It seems like it completely circumvents the browser manufacturers including root CAs at all. Totally agreed re: maintaining your own list of CAs. I mostly do go through the system CA list and disabling any from foreign governments I don't ever plan on trusting, but that's mostly feel-good and not actual security.