3 ms·
The fundamental truth about health care is that no amount of taxation or insurance can live up to the demand. Even if you taxed every citizen a 100% there still
by ThomPete 11y ago
The fundamental truth about health care is that no amount of taxation or insurance can live up to the demand. Even if you taxed every citizen a 100% there still wouldn't be enough to pay for healthcare.
And so every society find themselves in one of the most complex paradoxes of modern times.
If you tax your way to healthcare and provide everyone with free healthcare like in ex. Denmark, then access to treatment is equal but it's always a cost center and your will always mostly lag behind access to the latest treatments.
The only way to be able to pay for new equipment or new medicine is either through higher taxes or by budget cuts somewhere else.
If you go the insurance way of the US and try to let market forces rule then you end up with highly inflated prices and a younger generation that don't insure themselves and therefore don't pay for the healthcare system until they need it which drives up the prices of the insurance (hence Affordable Care Act).
Here the access isn't equal but you have some of the best specialists in the world and always the latest treatments.
Then there are countries in the middle trying to find a balance like Switzerland, Germany, the UK and France but even here I fear that no one have found a perfect system either.
So no matter how you try and pay for it whether trough trade agreements or NGO etcs that problem still applies. Someone always have to pick up the bill and the bill is potentially infinitely big.
Edit: For clarification
- laotzu 11y agoSo if the problem is too much demand, lets look at how to lower the demand? The answer to lowering demand is clearly to encourage preventative medicine over reaction medicine. Most of the cash cows in the US for sickness profiteering are preventable, heart disease being number one. I know that's not profitable for sickness profiteers but until we start to value health and well-being over institutionalized greed well never have enough money to take care of our health. >He sacrifices his health in order to make money. Then he sacrifices money to recuperate his health. And then he is so anxious about the future that he does not enjoy the present; the result being that he does not live in the present or the future; he lives as if he is never going to die, and then dies having never really lived. -DL
- orangecat 11y agoThe answer to lowering demand is clearly to encourage preventative medicine over reaction medicine. Not really: http://www.reuters.com/article/2013/01/29/us-preventive-economics-idUSBRE90S05M20130129 http://www.reuters.com/article/2013/01/29/us-preventive-econ...
- caseysoftware 11y agoWow, thanks. I don't like the conclusions but great article.
- laotzu 11y agoThe article fails to convince. Mentions studies but does not cite them. Doesn't even mention the words "exercise" or "healthy diet", the two best and cheapest forms of preventative medicine. Narrowly defines preventative medicine as "low- or no-benefit measures include annual physicals".
- ThomPete 11y agoDo you know how few people have the energy or money to exercise and eat healthy? It sounds easy but it's a lot of work. It's not just a rational choice, people aren't rational. It's kind of like saying that the solution to overpopulation is to get less children. Thats not how things work.
- laotzu 11y agoI'm not saying at all that it would be easy to get people to do what is in their best interest; though once they are properly educated, it would create a positive feedback loop. The more you exercise the more energy you have to exercise. The healthier you eat the less you have to spend on preventable diseases like heart disease and diabetes and so the more money you have to spend on healthy food. The solution to overpopulation, as evidenced by the Demographic-Economic Paradox, is clearly to raise the standard of living by successfully distributing the renewable surplus of food, water, and shelter that is available but wasted every year. This is also an example of turning a negative feedback loop into a positive feedback loop which in turn pays for itself. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Demographic-economic_paradox https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Demographic-economic_paradox The issues of poverty, disease, and overpopulation are closely interrelated indeed.
- andygates 11y ago100%? Nonsense. Unless you expect us to beat Death, and that's a little outside of our jurisdiction. Innovation is always expensive but it always has been. There's a rolling wave of upgrade costs and older treatments becoming commoditized or dropped. The fundamental of a fair system is that people are treated according to their clinical need.
- ThomPete 11y agoA fundamental fair system is not possible exactly for the reasons I am pointing out. You don't want to get cancer in Denmark because they don't have the best medicine and treatments and you don't want to get cancer in the US without an insurance to pay for those best treatments and even then it's hard. Or put another way. You can claim that Denmark is one of the most fair systems IF you ignore the fact that they aren't providing it's citizens with the best and most effective treatments available. Thats not more fair. Thats just another system.
- chimeracoder 11y agoI agree with almost everything you're saying, with one clarification: > If you go the insurance way of the US and try to let market forces rule Market forces do not rule in the US. If you want an example of healthcare in which market forces rule, look at India. In India, there is massive disparity in terms of equality of access to care. But on the other hand, costs are entirely transparent (unlike the US), and the quality of care that one has access to given sufficient money is comparable to the quality of care in the US. The US is actually much more like socialized medicine than people realize, due to the fact that we have two monopsonic systems[0] that we force private insurers to subsidize. It's the worst of both worlds. That said, I agree that it's not clear that a single monopsonic system would be any better, for all the reasons you mention. I don't think there is a solution. Our actual demand and expectations for quality healthcare has risen dramatically over the last century, and our technology has not kept up (to the extent that, we are able to afford the top care for some people, but it is just not physically or economically possible to extend that to everyone right now, no matter how we structure the market). [0] If the phrase 'two monopsonic systems' sounds like an oxymoron to you, just think about how we refer to Comcast and Time Warner Cable as monopolies - they are, because their markets are completely segmented and do not overlap.
- zeveb 11y ago> The fundamental truth about health care is that no amount of taxation or insurance can live up to the demand. Yup. It's worth all of your money for me to live an extra day—to me. That's the fundamental problem with insurance and end-of-life care. > If you go the insurance way of the US and try to let market forces rule then you end up with highly inflated prices It should be noted that while the U.S. employer-purchased insurance model is extremely broken, it's not really a free-market model. We've not had a free market in healthcare for a very long time (and of course, if we did have one, there would be issues about fraudulent marketing and credentials). And let's not even get into issues of personal responsibility and choice. Should others underwrite lung care for smokers? AIDS medicines for the promiscuous? Mental treatment for drug users?Are some personal choices acceptable, and others not? Who decides? If a majority, who protects the minority?