5 ms·
No offense to Erik, but he seems to have interpreted the purpose of Atlas Shrugged as a recipe for building a society. On the contrary, the book is intended on
by grandalf 17y ago
No offense to Erik, but he seems to have interpreted the purpose of Atlas Shrugged as a recipe for building a society.
On the contrary, the book is intended only to shed light on some moral distinctions about capitalism that people are inclined not to appreciate.
- brecht 17y agoAre you implying Rand was secretly critical of a selfishness-driven capitalism? If so, that's a pretty radical interpretation of her work, and one that I doubt many objectivists would support...
- rinich 17y agoAnd it sheds that light by portraying a scene where a bunch of people critical of aspects of capitalism are sent by train into a tunnel and killed.
- Padraig 17y agoThe scene you are referring to is pretty blunt alright, but you're twisting it. The train enters the tunnel at hands of the 'baddies' (the irresponsible incompetents). And the passengers are not 'people critical of aspects of capitalism' (Though we are led to believe that they weren't entirely innocent) This is different to the 'people critical of aspects of capitalism are sent by train into a tunnel and killed.'
- rinich 17y agoIt's not. It's a slightly more complex setup than I wrote, but the end message is the same. The passage in question opens with this: It is said that catastrophes are a matter of pure chance, and there were those who would have said that the passengers of the Comet were not guilty or responsible for the thing that happened to them. It then gives a list of the people on the Comet, and lists in effect their sins. It ends: These passengers were awake; there was not a man aboard the train who did not share one or more of their ideas. As the train went into the tunnel, the flame of Wyatt’s Torch was the last thing they saw on earth. So, quite explicitly, it debunks the idea that "the passengers of the Comet were not guilty or responsible", and concludes with "There was not a man aboard the train who did not share one or more of their ideas." It's not just sentencing these people to death, it's supernaturalism. It makes the claim implicitly that catastrophes only happen to people that deserve them — a claim that's repeated at several points in the novel.
- spamizbad 17y agoThanks for pointing this out. I recall reading Rand's work years ago and thinking there appeared to be some element of "cosmic justice" leaking into her allegedly rational world. Perhaps the name Comet eludes directly to this, as it certain fits into Rand's heavy-handed and often clumsy way of story-telling.
- grandalf 17y agoYou may be right. Her storytelling is free of the sort of opaque language that lets people interpret it any way they like... such language is sometimes poetic and inspiring, but would not be a good fit for Rand's novel. Thus it is not a weakness of the novel that she avoided it. The passengers on the train symbolize the unwitting half-participants in the travesty that led to the train's malfunction. Surely none of them would have expected that their half-hearted support of the system that led to the crash would result in their own deaths. The reader is intended to focus on the thoughts of the passengers and the consequences of their prior beliefs. The point being that few would expect there to be any consequences, which is why the train crash is an effective plot element. The crash is not intended to symbolize the killing of those who oppose capitalism but to show the folly of loose, whimsically held beliefs.
- mschy 17y ago* The crash is not intended to symbolize the killing of those who oppose capitalism but to show the folly of loose, whimsically held beliefs.* Yes, A is A. If you are a capitalist then you may not have any ideological compromise at all, even if it appeals to you, and even if there's strong evidence that it's a smart political and economic decision. A is A. The world is black and white. Anybody who sees shades of grey must be killed. Fucking nonsense, IMO.
- rinich 17y agoYou may be right. Her storytelling is free of the sort of opaque language that lets people interpret it any way they like... such language is sometimes poetic and inspiring, but would not be a good fit for Rand's novel. Thus it is not a weakness of the novel that she avoided it. Opaque language, or simply shallow? Not everything lacking depth ought to be commended for the fact. The reader is intended to focus on the thoughts of the passengers and the consequences of their prior beliefs. That's because the reader of Atlas Shrugged is intended to either think very small, very simple thoughts, or to be semipsychotic. Indeed, this idea that people with "whimsically held beliefs" should deserve to die unwittingly in a train crash is exactly what Erik Naggum was writing about in this thread! So we've come full circle. Naggum writes that his interpretation of freedom has to do with an acceptance of risk, which is an interesting way to look at the concept. In Rand's society, as he notes, there is no acceptance of risk. Either you do things exactly how Rand would like you to, or you die in a fiery train crash. Or you die like Eddie Willers, who supports Dagny the entire time but isn't quite special enough to avoid dying with the rest of society, as Dagny instantly forgets about him and goes whimsically on her way. Look, I know what Rand was intending. I had my phase of thinking she wasn't a deluded psychopath too. My point was that her intent led to her thinking it was perfectly okay to write a scene featuring people dying in a train crash for thinking bad thoughts, and that furthermore it was okay to found an entire "school" of philosophy around the concepts laid out in the same book, which, for all its strict observances of "objective" reality, also has a scene where scientists build a torture device that miraculously doesn't work on John Galt. A rational philosophical assault on that scene might proceed as follows: How much control did the people on that train have over their beliefs? Is it possible for somebody to believe wholesale in something harmful, without ever having a chance to doubt themselves? Then we can actually look at how people act in real life and realize that, in many cases, our inbred beliefs aren't entirely under our control. So when those people are killed for their whimsical beliefs, perhaps it's not their beliefs that they die for. Perhaps it's the beliefs of their parents, who raised them not to question certain things and so blinded them to the future. These people might be rehabilitated, but no, in Atlas Shrugged they will die without a questioning of their motives. It's one of those scenes that's suspiciously close to Christianity — these pop up everywhere in Rand's writing. She believes that people are born evil or born good, that their character just pops out of the womb, that there's no chance to change. No character has a change of heart in the entire book. So by her logic it's okay to sentence evil people to die — not just in the train scene, but when Dagny shoots a guard, or when Ragnar destroys ship after ship because not a single talented captain on the planet will argue with him so he's just killing off virtual retards. It's the world ending in fire, with John Galt delivering the good people into salvation — and, let's remember, nobody is as pure as Galt in this story, and all of them would have died were it not for his brilliant idea. It's not worth further arguing here. Atlas Shrugged is a brittle enough novel that a sharp tap crumbles it. It's certainly not the sort of writing that deserves to be taken seriously.
- patrickgzill 17y agoNo that is a gross mischaracterization. Rand is talking about the degradation of society as a whole, rather than the depradations of just one person in a society..
- rinich 17y ago..which is shown to the reader as a scene with people sitting in a train, riding to their deaths, with a lengthy exposition explaining they deserve it.