4 ms·
The question should be, what is best for this particular intersection in the near future? The two designs have different characteristics. My understanding is
by mixmastamyk 11y ago
The question should be, what is best for this particular intersection in the near future? The two designs have different characteristics.
My understanding is that roundabouts are best when traffic is low, when it gets heavy they become much less efficient. Lights, while a lot of overhead in low traffic, scale better. There's also the question of space required.
Since the UK may have too many roundabouts due to traffic growth, and the US virtually none, they could both be building the opposite and making the right choice.
- rwmj 11y agoThe UK also has a lot of roundabouts retrofitted with traffic lights (especially at motorway junctions).
- msandford 11y agoOne of the great advantages of roundabouts is that they're approximately "fair" whereas traffic lights are not. What I mean is that a traffic light is very arbitrary and stops people who just barely didn't make the cutoff. Multiply that by 5, 10, or 20 traffic lights on a journey and an extra minute at each one can add up. So people have incentive to run the light and shave the 30 seconds or a minute. But then when people run the light, it slows down the cross-road who has to wait extra for the road to clear, despite it being "their turn". So then people on that side have an incentive to run the light, because they got wrongfully cutoff by the arbitrariness and the other jerks running the light first. Rinse and repeat for a few cycles and it's easy to see that this is not a good situation. Traffic circles on the other hand don't suffer from this as there isn't arbitrariness on such a 'long' timescale. If you have to wait for a couple of extra cars it's only a few seconds, versus a minute or so. Because it's just a couple of seconds, people have less to lose and are more inclined to be nice. Which ultimately means that driving is more pleasant, even if it's not as efficient. I also might disagree with the idea that roundabouts aren't effective at high traffic levels. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lwHfibl1AoI https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lwHfibl1AoI
- mixmastamyk 11y agoNot a traffic engineer, but it is what I was told by Kiwis when driving in NZ, and it matched my experience. Driving a particular roundabout was a breeze at lunch (much better typically than a light), but took a very long time just to get into it during the 5pm rush. Traffic lights have other trade-offs that can be tweaked such as timing length, it is hard to say what is best without knowing more.
- msandford 11y agoRight, for sure! I'm not suggesting that my analysis is correct, it's just something I've noticed in a big city with a lot of traffic lights. Red-running is endemic during rush hour, but I see much better behavior at the roundabouts. One of the bummers of traffic lights is that they tend to be more efficient with longer light cycles since you amortize the 'start up cost' of getting vehicles moving through the intersection over a longer period of vehicles moving at full speed. But the downside is that this increases the perceived unfairness because a one car length difference now means an even longer arbitrary delay. I'm not a traffic engineer either but living in a city with horrible traffic it is something I think about.
- jrbancel 11y agoThe problem with roundabouts is starvation. I grew up in France, which has more than 50% of the world's roundabouts. They are everywhere. Where I am from, there is a roundabout at the intersection of a major road and a small road with little traffic. During rush hour, it is impossible to enter the roundabout coming from the small road because there is a continuous flow of cars coming from the major road. It is truly an uninterrupted flow of cars because the cars come from another roundabout... Before the roundabout, there was no problem because there was a light that would be always be green for the main road expect when a car was detected on the small road. It was optimal.
- msandford 11y agoThanks for sharing! That makes sense that roundabout traffic flows can't be too lopsided or else you'll get this kind of behavior. It wasn't something I had ever thought of.
- sliverstorm 11y agoThey also seem pretty OK when traffic is moderate, but only in one direction. The minor flow direction pays a price but the dominant flow direction is largely unimpinged compared to a stop light or four-way stop.
- toast0 11y agoLights in low traffic can also be low overhead, if you have adequate sensors. If you only have sensors at the line, and there's a dominant flow, set the dominant flow to green, and cycle through when someone comes up on the non-dominant flow. If you have sensors back far enough, you can leave everyone on red, and cycle to green when someone comes up.