3 ms·
Actually, in the video he points out the following is invalid: 1. A -> B 2. B -> C 3. A -> C 4. ~A -> ~C Step 3 is valid (skipping over the co
by jerf 17y ago
Actually, in the video he points out the following is invalid:
1. A -> B
2. B -> C
3. A -> C
4. ~A -> ~C
Step 3 is valid (skipping over the correlation issue); the problem is actually step 4. ~C -> ~A is valid, but ~A -> ~C is a fallacy. The correlation issue doesn't come up, possibly because it isn't even necessary; this logic fallacy dominates it.
I used standard Aristotelian logic notation here; it really ought to be fuzzy logic, but step 4 isn't valid there either, so it would just muck things up, and I don't know the numbers for the fuzzy logic anyhow. Doesn't matter.
- ced 17y agoYou should use probabilities, actually. And while step 4 is not a logical consequence, it may have substantial probability, per Bayes' theorem: P(C | A) = P(A | C) * P(C) / P(A)