5 ms·
Not really. Temperature is one of those odd-ball scales where there's a real, absolute 0 to it. Years of debate converged on a physical reality.
by XorNot 11y ago
Not really. Temperature is one of those odd-ball scales where there's a real, absolute 0 to it. Years of debate converged on a physical reality.
- jsprogrammer 11y agoI don't believe anyone has ever shown something to measure at 0k.
- Terr_ 11y agoSo? We haven't clocked a physical object moving at the speed of light either. That doesn't mean the math is wrong.
- sobkas 11y agoMaybe because it's not possible to achieve 0K? It's physically not possible.
- bobthechef 11y agoAnd how would you know that without a theory that told you that?
- jonathankoren 11y agoTrue, but irrelevant. The definition of temperature (average kinetic particle energy) means it exists. Conversely, Absolute Hot[1], is an open question. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Absolute_hot https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Absolute_hot
- jsprogrammer 11y agoIrrelevant to what? The poster claimed that there was a real thing in a physical reality. If that is true, shouldn't we have observed it before? As the statement stands it claims as absolute reality something which no one has ever seen.
- akiselev 11y ago》 If that is true, shouldn't we have observed it before? No. The concept of temperature is based on the bulk interactions of matter due to the motion/collisions of atoms and molecules relative to an inertial reference frame. A frame that usually has to exist outside of the system for temperature to have practical meaning so it is a concept that by definition has an absolute zero, even if we haven't observed it yet. In this case, absolute zero really means zero motion relative to the instrument measuring the sample so it is possible for a Type 1+ civilization to build a planet sized (or bigger, don't know how the math works out but it probably has something to do with constricting atoms to a precision within a planck length) laser or other electromagnetic trap to cool some nontrivial number of atoms to absolute zero like those used for Bose-Einsten condensate experiments.
- jsprogrammer 11y ago>it is possible for a Type 1+ civilization to build a planet sized... It may be possible, but we seem to be a very long way away from being able to test such a hypothesis.
- jonathankoren 11y agoIt's not a hypothesis. It's a definition. Let me turn this around. What do you think the hypothesis is, and how would you know if you've succeeded? Do not use the term "absolute zero" because you think that is a hypothesis, and not a definition.
- jsprogrammer 11y agoWhat is a definition? The assertion that it is possible to build a planet sized laser that could cool something to absolute zero?
- jonathankoren 11y agoNo. The definition of Absolute Zero is zero kinetic energy of the particles of a substance. You've been complaining that this definition is somehow a hypothesis, or otherwise suspect because it has never been observed, which I've said, was irrelevant, we can calculate it. It's not hard. It's junior high physics. What's the kinetic energy of something that has stopped? It's zero. Your position is absurd. It's equivalent of saying, that distance is an unproven hypothesis, (which literally doesn't make any sense, because that's not what the word means), or perhaps more charitably a suspicious concept because we've never measured anything with zero distance between two items, because the closest two particle can get is planck length. I'm not trying to be mean, but what you've been saying is pure gibberish.
- Retra 11y agoThe temperature scale has a zero, and that's a fundamentally important temperature limit, so you'll want in on that scale.
- bobthechef 11y agoWhether a scale has a zero is something that is decided after the fact. Whether it is "fundamentally important" is, again, dependent on the state of the theory it is bound up with and the result of.
- robotresearcher 11y agoThe concept was well known and widely used before it was known to have a lowest possible value.
- bbq 11y agoA physical reality we describe with mathematical constructs - like 0. People acting as groups exchanging capital is just as real as atoms acting as groups exchanging energy.
- TeMPOraL 11y agoExcept groups exchanging capital are still an GAI-complete system, unlike atoms - even if they behave predictably, they can start doing weird things completely at random. Also, atoms themselves don't have equal voting or influence rights to change the way we compute temperature when it suits them.