4 ms·
Intelligence "works" in the same sense that torture does: to further the unstated private interest of whoever hired the intelligence and torture agencies. If we
by jessaustin 11y ago
Intelligence "works" in the same sense that torture does: to further the unstated private interest of whoever hired the intelligence and torture agencies. If we're interested in the truth rather than The Truth, we can't trust non-public sources that have repeatedly failed in public ways.
- presidentender 11y agoI would encourage you to read the article. While I am inclined to agree with your sentiment, the article presents a study that actually deals with the concrete effectiveness of intelligence analysts.
- jessaustin 11y agoYeah I read the article; it wasn't very long. Either the authors of the study are "insiders" with clearances, they have seen only redacted material, or (most likely) both of those are true. All of those conditions ask me to believe non-public sources. I won't do that. [EDIT: I hesitate to join the ranks of those who complain about shitty-but-common HN habits, but assuming for no reason that anyone didn't read TFA seems nearly as common as it is shitty.]
- jacquesm 11y ago> I would encourage you to read the article. I would encourage you to assume that those commenting on an article have read it.
- readme 11y agoWhat does your comment have to do with the article?
- jessaustin 11y agoTFA is like most popular-media accounts of the "intelligence community": adulatory pablum divorced from widely-known facts, because secrets. If it's repeated often enough then simpletons with short memories will believe it. I'm not tabula rasa; I've actually been paying attention for nearly half my life. The world is simply not as dangerous as they've long struggled to convince us. Much of the danger that is real, was created by them. No thinking person can claim that the horrible things we've done over the last 14 years have made the world a better place. All that shit was supported by "intelligence". It's even more obnoxious that this tiny study of non-public data is described as "even more striking because of its contrast with a famous earlier finding", which earlier finding was a vastly longer, more rigorous, and more scholarly study of more reliable, public data. That is, Tetlock's was a study one might call scientific. In TFA however it gets second billing to this spurious unrepeatable nonsense, because "professional analysts are more cautious than your average pundit". Sure, pull the other one.