6 ms·
The NYT editor in chief has responded via Medium: https://medium.com/@NYTimesComm/dean-baquet-responds-to-jay-carney-s-medium-post-6af794c7a7c6 https://medium.
by danso 11y ago
The NYT editor in chief has responded via Medium:
https://medium.com/@NYTimesComm/dean-baquet-responds-to-jay-carney-s-medium-post-6af794c7a7c6 https://medium.com/@NYTimesComm/dean-baquet-responds-to-jay-...
> In response to your posting on Medium this morning, I want to reiterate my support for our story about Amazon’s culture. In your posting — as well as in a series of recent email exchanges with me — you contested the article’s assertion that many employees found Amazon a tough place to work.
Specifically, he says had they known Olson had a conflict, they would have disclosed it. But the NYT asserts that Mr. Olson never disclosed such allegations, nor does he admit to them now.
> Olson described conflict and turmoil in his group and a revolving series of bosses, and acknowledged that he didn’t last there. He disputes Amazon’s account of his departure, though. He told us today that his division was overwhelmed and had difficulty meeting its marketing commitments to publishers; he said he and others in the division could not keep up. But he said he was never confronted with allegations of personally fraudulent conduct or falsifying records, nor did he admit to that.
If there were criminal charges against him, or some formal accusation of wrongdoing, we would certainly consider that. If we had known his status was contested, we would have said so.
edit: re-reading Carney's statement, it seems pretty unequivocal: "An investigation revealed [Olson] had attempted to defraud vendors and conceal it by falsifying business records. When confronted with the evidence, he admitted it and resigned immediately" The NYT is likewise unequivocal: "[Olson] said he was never confronted with allegations of personally fraudulent conduct or falsifying records"
Well, only Amazon has the time-stamped records that could prove who is lying here. It was a questionable tactic for Carney to start his response with such a bold and salacious allegation against someone who constituted a single quote in the NYT's story...assuming that Carney is right (because it's a complete unmitigated disaster if he isn't) now it seems he's going to have to go even more salacious, perhaps even post the actual pertinent records online.
How was this mudfest good for Amazon's image, again? And so late after the original story and Bezos's (pretty decent) response?
- mbca 11y agoPublic mudslinging between big names ... does that make Medium the new Twitter?
- exodust 11y agoMedium seems to be a reasonable neutral ground for such a show-down. No distractions, just words on a page, fighting it out, gladiator style.
- exodust 11y agoGrabs popcorn. Olson is clinging to a lie, trying to defend his reputation. Notice how he tries to blame Amazon for his departure, the "revolving series of bosses" and "overwhelmed" with work. "He and others couldn't keep up". Deflection. He's doing his best to construct a version of events where he is one of the innocents, caught up in the nasty Amazon shit-storm. I bet he got a shock to see Amazon reveal his fraudulent activity in a medium post! You think Amazon would make such a claim if it weren't true? Nobody wants to see personal information released like this, but Amazon were slapped in the face with that NYT piece. Let 'em have their medium return fire. Fraudsters and liars stick to their guns till the bitter end and beyond. It's best to weed them out, and have karma deliver what is deserved.
- lightbritefight 11y ago>I bet he got a shock to see Amazon reveal his fraudulent activity in a medium post! You think Amazon would make such a claim if it weren't true? So your stance is "it must be true, because it would be really stupid of them if it wasen't?" I think its equally valid to say they are acting stupidly, and counting on dollars and cents to keep any trouble off their door. The truth is, they have just claimed the above. They pressed no charges, and have provided no documentation to sustain it. Right now, they have no more proof then him, and have a strong reason (redeeming their reputation though mudslinging) to say that he was a bad man, so his opinion doesn't matter. Of course,as the NYT responds, they interviewed way more people than just the ones Amazon cherry picked to respond too, and those people all disagree with the new Amazon spin.
- exodust 11y agoI'm pretty sure a lot of companies would choose to deal with these sorts of internal matters without involving the law. When the NYT times story came out I remember thinking it sounded a bit spinny. "Let's find an angle" is symptomatic of a desperate click-baity news media industry. NYT isn't as guilty of this as other outlets by a large margin, but the story had what I perceived as fabricated bite. At the time, I wondered if any Amazon employees would come out defending their employer. Took me 5 seconds to find something... https://www.tbray.org/ongoing/When/201x/2015/08/16/Working-at-Amazon https://www.tbray.org/ongoing/When/201x/2015/08/16/Working-a... Are there others? Who knows, I don't care enough to search! I'm not interested to take sides, but in big companies it's more likely there's pockets of problems, rather than company-wide problems.
- puredemo 11y agoBaquet's response makes Carney's complaints seem infantile. Carney should have known better than to post this in this first place.