3 ms·
Why shouldn't it be the PR person? Someone at the level of Jay Carney is ostensibly more than just a mouthpiece, but someone who gathers the information and wei
by danso 11y ago
Why shouldn't it be the PR person? Someone at the level of Jay Carney is ostensibly more than just a mouthpiece, but someone who gathers the information and weighs in on what's useful and relevant to disseminate to the press. This isn't always a nefarious thing; sometimes employees have incomplete information but aren't in a position to confirm it with the executives.
At this phase, where the story has run and the damage has been done -- the response should be done by Carney. Take the rebuttal to Mr. Olson, for example. That revelation is absolutely not something that should be revealed by Mr. Olson's boss or a coworker. First of all, just because you're an engineer doesn't mean you have all of the facts. The PR person is in a position to collect the facts, including whether or not it's legal to reveal Mr. Olson's reason for termination, and confirming that reason for termination with HR. Even Mr. Olson's boss wouldn't have that same level of confirmation.
The other advantage of having Carney make this response is that you can be sure that this is, for better or worse, the official company response. If instead, this was a blog post by Mr. Olson's co-worker calling him out for being a fraud...and the reaction to it was negative...then Amazon could pedal back and say, "Oh well that co-worker blogged something he shouldn't have and now he is being punished".
But since the condemnation of Mr. Olson has come straight from Mr. Carney, any backlash will be rightly the reaping of what Bezos, Carney, and all their lawyers have sowed.
edit: FWIW, a non-anonymous redditor is saying that he knows Bo Olson, personally, and says "I can assure you that Bo was not the one defrauding vendors that was another employee in the same department"...it strikes me as improbable that Carney (again, not just Carney, but Amazon's lawyers and HR) would get this wrong. But if they did...it's going to be a great backlash, and a much more lasting one than had this allegation come from someone other than Carney or Bezos himself.
https://www.reddit.com/r/business/comments/3pcnlh/what_the_new_york_times_didnt_tell_you/cw585to https://www.reddit.com/r/business/comments/3pcnlh/what_the_n...
- amyjess 11y agoI think a lot of people's problem with this is that it's not very transparent. You don't find out who Carney is until the very bottom of the article, and it's presented as just another journalistic article published by Medium and not an official rebuttal by the company. If the whole thing was prefixed with "Following is Amazon's official rebuttal to the New York Times article", I don't think many people would have a problem with it.
- danso 11y agoFair enough...I saw his name at the top and immediately knew who he was but only because I work in media. However, Carney would be right to assume that his main audience -- the media -- will also recognize his role. That said, I don't know if this is them trying to be intentionally deceptive or if this is just a clunky use of the medium (no pun intended). It is his first post on Medium, and it's written not in the first-person (as a way to make a personal connection with the reader) but uses "we", e.g. "We were in regular communication with Ms. Kantor from February through the publication date in mid-August"...I don't think there's much evidence to show that they are trying to hide the author's bias or position, other than it's on Medium and not on news.amazon.com.
- srtjstjsj 11y agoWhat's a "journalist article"? Medium is a blog host, not a newspaper. Medium is just paste.org with a better UI.
- jsprogrammer 11y agoAs it stands, Amazon/Carney have made a defamatory statement about an individual while providing no evidence of their claims. Claiming to have the results of an internal investigation is not evidence. Now, the entire investigation will need to be made public and scrutinized. This will likely allow legal entrance into all of Amazon, as all internal policies will need to be examined.
- theptip 11y agoDefamation is by definition making a false statement that damages someone's reputation. You're claiming too much, since without any evidence, we can't tell whether the statements are true or false. If the statements Amazon made are false, then they are clearly defamatory, since they accuse the employee of criminal action. Do you really believe that Amazon's expensive lawyers didn't vet this post before it went out?
- jsprogrammer 11y agoThe statement should be assumed false until proven to be true by the accuser. A negative, public claim with zero evidence (nor even a promise of forthcoming evidence) should be viewed as defamatory. >If the statements Amazon made are false, then they are clearly defamatory, since they accuse the employee of criminal action. Here's a key piece. If Amazon is now claiming that their former employee took criminal actions: 1) Amazon took criminal actions. 2) Why reveal this now, instead of taking it to the proper authorities when it was discovered? >Do you really believe that Amazon's expensive lawyers didn't vet this post before it went out? Does it matter? Expensive does not mean they are competent, nor does it mean they are correct.
- cgy1 11y agoIt's only defamation if it's not true.
- ucaetano 11y ago"you can be sure that this is, for better or worse, the official company response" Quite the opposite: there's absolutely nothing official about it. It isn't published on an amazon domain, doesn't carry any signature as amazon, and the only evidence that this is in any way related to amazon is that the guy works at amazon.
- danso 11y ago"there's absolutely nothing official about it"...except that it's coming from Amazon's Jay Carney, who is described as "Senior Vice President for Global Corporate Affairs at Amazon". Could his Medium site use a custom banner to show Amazon's letterhead? Sure (I don't know, I haven't logged into Medium in awhile to know its design/customization options). But this message is signed by him, acting in his role as Amazon PR. Quibbling over whether it should've shown on an Amazon domain vs. an outlet like Medium does nothing to change that.
- ucaetano 11y agoThere's a difference between Elon Musk speaking as CEO of Tesla and as Elon Musk. Or pretty much anyone else.
- pseudalopex 11y agoSenior executives are usually careful to point out when they're not speaking for the company. Carney identifies himself as an SVP at Amazon, uses "us" and "we" throughout the piece, and refers to internal records and emails he would have no reason to access otherwise.