3 ms·
Also, success is not defined by superficial customer appeal, and certainly not by technical details. Success is defined by a combination of customer appeal, in
by TheOtherHobbes 11y ago
Also, success is not defined by superficial customer appeal, and certainly not by technical details.
Success is defined by a combination of customer appeal, investor persuasion, and ability to execute effective sales and marketing.
An initial Show HN typically includes details about the product and maybe the underlying technology, but doesn't usually tell you much about the other elements.
So I think it's unfair to judge HN on its prescience, when HN is as much about technical critiques as business potential.
It could be interesting would be to look at VC judgements of startups. VCs have a pitch deck, they have some hints about the financials and of customer growth, and they may know something about the reputations of the management team.
With the extra detail, you'd expect better prescience. I have no idea if that's what happens, but I think it would be very interesting to test the hypothesis that VCs make expert decisions.