4 ms·
> It's easy for geeks/nerds/experts (especially vocal ones) to misjudge how products could be accepted by the masses (who are not geeks/nerds/experts). That's
by scrollaway 11y ago
> It's easy for geeks/nerds/experts (especially vocal ones) to misjudge how products could be accepted by the masses (who are not geeks/nerds/experts).
That's a pretty bad conclusion. Is it any easier for non-"geek/nerds/experts" to judge the iphone on its mass market appeal? I don't think so. In fact that's pretty much what you figured in the BTTF "predictions" failing.
The thing is a lot of people here on HN, and in the tech community, like to judge products based on how easy or hard they are to build, and that has zero relation to how good the product is or how successful it will be. For a non-techie, it's in the realm of the impossible either way, so that stuff doesn't matter at all.
- jasode 11y ago>The thing is a lot of people here on HN, and in the tech community, like to judge products based on how easy or hard they are to build, and that has zero relation to how good the product is or how successful it will be. This is also true but that wasn't my point. I'm saying that the armchair quarterbacking from nerds is often predicting the business success (the mass acceptance) of a product. There is a huge disconnect between how expert tech communities think and how everyone else thinks. Steve Jobs was one of the few that seemed to bridge this disconnect. But Mike Lazaridis of RIM Blackberry could not. Jobs was more consumer-minded rather than technical. Lazaridis was more engineer-minded rather than consumer (e.g. consumers want a physical keyboard more than a touch screen.)
- VLM 11y ago"to judge the iphone on its mass market appeal" Note that you can make a lot of money out of a product that flops in the mass market like an iphone. Out of any group of ten Americans, roughly ten drink water, use indoor plumbing, and have access to utility generated electricity, all rather successful products. Its also true that nine out of ten Americans don't have or use an iphone, however, its possible to make an enormous stack of money out of stuff 90% of the population is uninterested in. For other examples of the same phenomena of making fat stacks of cash off practically no one, see pop music, television, professional sports, AAA video games... Its a failure to understand the market. Around 9 out of 10 comments about an iphone should be somewhere on the spectrum of "eh" to "that sucks" because a random sampling should indicate iphones are only about twice as cool as Congress. People on /. complained about the ipod because they're normies, not because they're nerds. Normies don't like that stuff, look at the actual sales figures, therefore normie hangout like /. is not going to like the product. Denigration and name calling of people who don't like a niche product is just Apple fanboyism.
- eric_h 11y ago> Its also true that nine out of ten Americans don't have or use an iphone [1] suggests that one in four americans own an iPhone. 1) http://fortune.com/2014/01/16/npd-better-than-1-in-4-adult-americans-now-own-an-iphone/ http://fortune.com/2014/01/16/npd-better-than-1-in-4-adult-a...