4 ms·
Not sure if I agree with the conclusion: > Such a specialized community is a great place to get feedback on the technical details of your product, but not to v
by danso 11y ago
Not sure if I agree with the conclusion:
> Such a specialized community is a great place to get feedback on the technical details of your product, but not to validate your ideas. The responses from people in these communities tend towards scepticism to negativity, even for products they use.
Or with the methodology. Take for example the Dropbox thread [1] which the OP's sentiment algorithm classifies as having a "negative top comment".
This is what the purportedly negative comment says:
> The only problem is that you have to install something. See, it's not the same as USB drive. Most corporate laptops are locked and you can't install anything on them. That's gonna be the problem. Also, another point where your USB comparison fails is that USB works in places where you don't have internet access.
> My suggestion is to drop the "Throw away your USB drive" tag line and use something else... it will just muddy your vision.
> Kudos for launching it!!! Launching/shipping is extremely hard and you pulled it off! Super!
In what universe, besides the one of a sentiment-analysis-algorithm, would that be considered a "negative" comment? Moreover, even if that last, congratulatory line didn't exist, the rest of that comment is very well-worth listening to. It might have been wrong (has Dropbox penetrated corporate IT as well as USB keys? USB keys have definitely taken a beating in reputation and in convenience...but has Dropbox been an easy transition in corporate IT? At Stanford, we have Box)...but it definitely wasn't non-constructive criticism.
If a submission gets a lot of upvotes, to me that's a positive-enough sign of validation. Is it really helpful to the submitter to see a dozen/hundred comments that are merely, "Awesome! I like it!"? I often like reading the comments before I check out the submission, because I don't want to have to parse Press-Releasese to understand what the product does, or who it may compete against, or what its flaws might be...Even if the comments were completely devoid of constructive and insightful criticism -- I'm sure after a big launch, it's helpful, yet annoying when people immediately nitpick grammar and typos -- if you're a founder of a great product, the hemming and hawing of HN is probably the least of your obstacles on the way to success.
[1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8863 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8863
- zamalek 11y ago> In what universe, besides the one of a sentiment-analysis-algorithm, would that be considered a "negative" comment? The algorithm likely has issues identifying if criticism is constructive. If you look at the negative/positive score of each word in isolation (e.g. fail, problem, drop, can't, hard) the comment is overwhelmingly negative. You actually have to parse and understand the comment to prove that it's very positive. They could have ditched the algorithm, but then they would lose a quantifiable positivity score and instead would have had to rely on human intuition - which has it's problems, e.g. spend the whole day looking at negative comments and neutral comments might start looking positive. The study may have had fundamental issues at the outset.
- thaumasiotes 11y ago> instead would have had to rely on human intuition - which has it's problems, e.g. spend the whole day looking at negative comments and neutral comments might start looking positive. If you assume the people looking to validate their ideas are familiar with the HN community, then this effect makes the analysis more accurate.
- mattlutze 11y agoWell negativity in: > I have a few qualms with this app: > 1. For a Linux user, you can already build such a system yourself quite trivially by getting an FTP account, mounting it locally with curlftpfs, and then using SVN or CVS on the mounted filesystem. From Windows or Mac, this FTP account could be accessed through built-in software. > 2. It doesn't actually replace a USB drive. Most people I know e-mail files to themselves or host them somewhere online to be able to perform presentations, but they still carry a USB drive in case there are connectivity problems. This does not solve the connectivity issue. > 3. It does not seem very "viral" or income-generating. I know this is premature at this point, but without charging users for the service, is it reasonable to expect to make money off of this? or skepticism in: > It's pretty nice, and I was thinking to myself - hey cool, I could make an online backup of my code. Then it occured to me - who the hell is this guy, and why should I trust my code to be on his server!? > That's a huge issue you should consider. Why would people feel comfortable leaving their valuable stuff on "Drews" server? Or this[1] conversation. Or this[2] one. That comments page is, I agree, not a troll-haven or something of the sort. But we do have a tendency to try and pick apart every potential flaw we see in something. It's not a bad thing! Thorough vetting of an idea is the only good way to find potentially fatal flaws. But if you're looking for what the response of the enthusiast Internet community is going to be, this is definitely not the place to go. A trial by fire we are. [1]: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8958 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8958 [2]: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9671 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9671
- kbenson 11y ago> But we do have a tendency to try and pick apart every potential flaw we see in something. If as the owner/presenter you aren't looking for that by posting your program/model/business to HN, I think you've not done your research. HN is great for getting constructive criticism. Not all constructive criticism needs to be accepted or acted upon, but if you can't really justify why it doesn't apply to you, then you should think about addressing the problem presented. Otherwise, you're just looking for people to congratulate you, and there's lots of other places to get that. (for the general you, of course).
- 11y ago
- jasode 11y ago>Or with the methodology. Take for example the Dropbox thread [1] which the OP's sentiment algorithm classifies as having a "negative top comment". [...] In what universe, besides the one of a sentiment-analysis-algorithm, would that be considered a "negative" comment? To clarify, they said they manually classified the top comment instead of leaving it to the judgement of the algorithm: ", we manually categorized the top comment for each thread." As for why their human eyes judged it as "negative", I'd speculate it was phrases such as "The only problem is", "That's gonna be the problem.", "your USB comparison fails" So yes, the top comment's criticism is constructive, but at the same time, it can also be subjectively classified as "negative." The positive back pat at the end of the post was not about the product itself but for the accomplishment of launching something. (You could say it's the attaboy "trophy for participating" consolation prize to soften the previous paragraph's criticism.)
- mreiland 11y agothat sentence is technically negative, but not conceptually. constructive criticism is a thing.