4 ms·
...but the app developers are understandably grumpy because they have a quarter-century of code that never had to deal with such a design principle. The thing
by CamperBob2 11y ago
...but the app developers are understandably grumpy because they have a quarter-century of code that never had to deal with such a design principle.
The thing we're grumpy about is the lack of respect for the central dogma behind the personal computing revolution: one machine, one owner, one user.
Recently, for example, Apple has literally granted themselves higher access privileges than the admin/owner of a machine running the OS X file system. There are files on the hard drive that they can write to and delete that you, the owner, can't, without extraordinary (and nonstandard) efforts. Naturally, it will only be a matter of time until Microsoft notices this innovative feature and copies it, more or less verbatim, into Windows. At that point, it's no longer "My Computer" -- it's theirs.
And all of this is accompanied by the sound of thunderous applause. Because, you see, it's For Our Security.
- johncolanduoni 11y agoI assume you are talking about System Integrity Protection. You can turn this off, so do you consider the fact that Ubuntu doesn't have a root user by default (and requires you to run everything through sudo) an imposition on your freedom as well? Or is it only barriers which require a restart to disable? In addition, no Intel Macs have any means of operating system lock-in. You can run Windows, Linux, or anything else that can handle standard x86 hardware. So you seem to have full control over the hardware at least (except maybe the SMC, which is not easily modifiable on standard PC hardware either). And given the fact that the Darwin kernel is open source[1], you are free to patch out SIP entirely and run that instead. [1]: https://github.com/opensource-apple/xnu https://github.com/opensource-apple/xnu
- CamperBob2 11y agoOr is it only barriers which require a restart to disable? Yes, that's what I meant by "nonstandard." Apple has invented a brand-new access control mechanism to keep people from tinkering with files that reside on their own computers. For now you can work around this feature. Once they close that particular gap, I'm guessing we'll still be able to use a debugger to get the job done... and I'm guessing you'll move the goalpost accordingly.
- TeMPOraL 11y agoThis is actually a battle that will soon merge with the primary frontline of the War Against General-Purpose Computing[0]. Windows 8 already has some things that you can't do without restarting and going through scary recovery screen with additional layers of security - in particular, installing unsigned device drivers. I predict the gap will close from both software and hardware side as Trusted Computing starts getting popular, finally sealing your fate as a leaser of computing device, not the owner. [0] - It's not really "coming" anymore.
- CamperBob2 11y agoAgreed, it's not really fair of me to single out Apple for criticism. I was just reaching for a recent example of something that can't possibly be justified on any grounds other than the usual "For the children" and "For the OS vendor."
- TeMPOraL 11y agoI didn't read it as singling out Apple, just wanted to share another example that you may not have heard of and that I remember vividly, after losing some time and patience trying to program a TI Stellaris LM4F120 using a Windows 8 laptop.
- johncolanduoni 11y ago> installing unsigned device drivers So, probably one of the most dangerous things you can do (opening the door to rootkits and an infected BIOS) doesn't take just a click and an undistinguished warning dialog? Also, this has been around since at least Windows 7, its not evidence of us sliding down a slope.
- TeMPOraL 11y agoI didn't have to reboot Windows 7 machine and go through recovery interface to find obscure option that needs to be toggled and authorized in order to do so. Yes, rebooting Windows one time to do it isn't that bad, but it's a start. I won't be surprised if the next version of Windows (next after Win10) removed that feature completely. Forcing users to run only signed drivers is a problem because only Trusted Vendors can get proper certification (after paying proper amount of $$ to Trusted Certification Providers). Such restriction will basically kill hardware tinkering, which is one of the goals of the War on General-Purpose Computing.