4 ms·
"due to lack of money..." There's actually billions of dollars being spent on projects like the 2nd Avenue line and the recently completed extension of the #7
by greenyoda 11y ago
"due to lack of money..."
There's actually billions of dollars being spent on projects like the 2nd Avenue line and the recently completed extension of the #7 train. For some reason, the powers that be consider this more essential than updating the ancient signalling infrastructure and maintaining the crumbling stations.
- tormeh 11y agoA new station is very beneficial politically - it sways voting, whereas nobody gets that excited by maintenance.
- zem 11y agosounds like every programming job ever :(
- greenyoda 11y agoA new station is only useful to the small minority of riders who use it, while system-wide infrastructure problems affect everyone. Upgrading signalling on a train line would make life better for many more people than building one new station: trains would be able to run more often (which would make them less crowded) and the system would break down less often (the ancient signalling hardware is currently the least reliable part of the system). I heard that the new signalling on the L line is economically reviving a large part of Brooklyn now that it has reliable train service to Manhattan. And wouldn't people who suffer daily from late and crowded trains and have to deal with leaky stations with perpetually broken elevators be likely to vote against the current politicians when they run for re-election?
- sdoering 11y agoThe problem with maintenance is, that it cannot be seen in public. What I imply is, that 2nd Ave or #7-extension are highly visible. Press writes about this and politicians that are associated with this leave a legacy. The legacy-part would also happen with maintenance (be the one who brings the system into 21. century) - but only after many years would this leak into history-books. Not fast enough to win the next election. Esp. if you are a local politician, who got the local construction for the extension, this might make a difference in incentives.
- wcummings 11y agoPart of the work done on the 7 was upgrading signaling, which you could count as maintenance.
- rdtsc 11y agoPerhaps not different than software world -- people want to be known for "created and built ..." on their resume, rather than for "mainted and supported ...". It is of course fun and exciting if we are talking about spotify for dogs, not as fun when talking about critical infrastructure.
- greenyoda 11y agoAgreed, but also nobody wants to be known for "the whole system fell apart while I was in charge".
- ambicapter 11y agoThen just reword: "Doubled the expected lifespan with preventive maintenance and upgrades"
- melling 11y agoIn the meantime, China FTW. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shanghai_Metro#Future_expansion https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shanghai_Metro#Future_expans...
- bradleyjg 11y agoThe federal government kicks in a lot of money for big new capital projects but not much if anything for station rehabilitation. As the issuer of fiat currency, and given that we've been at the zero-bound interest rate for a while now the federal government has a lot more money to throw around than the city or state governments. The MTA also has an arcane governance structure that makes for poor accountability. Four votes on its board are picked by the NYC mayor, 1 each by the county executives of Nassau, Suffolk, and Westchester, 1/4 each by the county executives of Dutchess, Orange, Rockland, and Putnam counties and six by the Governor of the state.