5 ms·
There can be quite a large amount of innovation even in iterating on existing designs. Boeing is using new materials, and the new high-bypass engines for the 7
by dogma1138 11y ago
There can be quite a large amount of innovation even in iterating on existing designs.
Boeing is using new materials, and the new high-bypass engines for the 787 and 747-8 are quite a technological achievement.
People also forget that Boeing like many other aerospace companies rely on government funding and military contracts.
Many of Boeing's commercial aircraft either started as military designs for long range bombers and cargo aircraft or were a sister project of one.
Airbus was pretty much a hail mary effort by Europe to revive their aerospace industry, the UK, France, Italy and Germany have dumped billions of tax payer money to get Airbus off the ground.
Airbus got preferential treatment in the EU market, and even it relies quite heavily on it's military wing for a large part of their profits.
As far as individual programs go the 787 like the 777 doesn't have military variants at this point, the "newest" Boeing aircraft with military versions is the 767 (there are plenty of 737 tankers and CIC/AW aircraft out there, and even 707's) and it does't look like they will ever receive one.
But it's also very hard to estimate the worth of a program, the 787 might not break even in the books, but the technology, experience, patents and intellectual property that came out of that program may very well be highly profitable.
- blisterpeanuts 11y ago+1 for pointing out that Boeing has significant revenue from military contracts. The Seattle Times analysis seems not to take that into account, but rather focuses on purely commercial aspects. New passenger planes are extraordinarily expensive to develop, and only 2-3 corporations in the entire world are capable of it. Boeing traditionally has introduced new models with advantageous features, then continued selling them for decades, gradually rolling out slightly modernized versions that the airlines can purchase to refresh their fleets without completely retooling to support a newer model (retraining mechanics, purchasing new parts, etc.). The article argues that Boeing will take ~5 years to break even. That actually sounds pretty good. I would give them 10-15 years. The fact that only one Boeing person seems to have been consulted for this article suggests that it's mostly speculation by outsiders and former insiders, and not a realistic analysis based on comprehensive data. If Boeing's betting on military contracts to keep it afloat while the more profitable 787-9 and -10 models come online, so what? Sounds like a reasonable thing for this kind of manufacturer.
- dogma1138 11y agoAnd those designs live for quite a long time, the brand new USAF tankers which will come into service in 2017 are based on the 767. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Boeing_KC-46_Pegasus https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Boeing_KC-46_Pegasus Those tankers however will use new technologies from other projects like the cockpit displays and avionics from the 787. And these ones will slowly replace the USAF current tankers the KC-135 which are based on the Boeing 367 (which turned into the 707 for it's commercial release) which has been flying since the mid 50's. People underestimate the life span of most aircraft designs, at least of the good ones if the design is superior it's practically timeless. The US is still building new U-2's because there's nothing comparable to it still.
- rory096 11y ago> The US is still building new U-2's because there's nothing comparable to it still. Last built in 1989 I'm afraid, though they're still pushing off retirement because drones haven't quite taken over the game yet.
- Phlarp 11y agoWhat can a U2 do that a drone can't do?
- dogma1138 11y agoThe U2 carries pretty much every airborne sensor we've built so far, when it comes to ISR roles the U2 can fly much higher and further than any drone, and give both line of sight and over the horizon coverage which most drones cant. The Global Hawk can almost match the U2 in altitude 60,000 feet vs 70,000 but it can carry only a fraction of the sensors that the U2 can, and it also is currently more expensive than the U2. If it retires I hope that the US will preserve some for private sale, I would rather fly in a U2 at this point than than on the spaceship one, there's just something about a minimalistic design from the dawn of the "atomic age" which is still relevant today that can bring you to 1/8th of the way to low earth orbit that is inspiring.
- dingaling 11y ago> Boeing is using new materials, and the new high-bypass engines for the 787 and 747-8 are quite a technological achievement. There are no "new" materials in the 787, and the engines were developed by GE and RR under their own financial risk. They fit on the A330Neo and A350 just fine, too. The now mostly-forgotten Raytheon Premier light business jet was the most relevant pioneer of all-composite commercial aviation structures[0] and the 787 is basically a scale-up of those principles, with a wound-barrel fuselage. It's really the engines and the high-aspect ratio wing that make the 787 more efficient than the previous generation of airliners. All the other fluff is just marketing. [0] and even that was decades later than all-composite home-builts, and the Learfan, Beech Starship, Avtek-400 and whole buch of others... plus of course Airbus have been using composite structural components since the late 1970s.
- xvf33 11y agoThe Trent 1000 and GEnx are bleedless engines so no they would not fit the A330Neo and A350 just fine.