4 ms·
I imagine the reasoning is that give people incorrect information about a disease they may have could be extremely damaging. Having models that predict the acc
by kbenson 11y ago
I imagine the reasoning is that give people incorrect information about a disease they may have could be extremely damaging. Having models that predict the accuracy of each diagnosis to within a few percent and presenting this percentage would be better (maybe requiring it be over a certain percentage), but the FDA is conservative enough I can imagine them requiring 99% accuracy or better on everything.
- TeMPOraL 11y agoI don't know the details of the particular case of FDA and 23andMe (I remember only the one when FDA asked 23andMe to fix their marketing, or else), but there is a known problem with giving medically-relevant information to people - that armed with such information, fully predictably, they go batshit insane. Most people are not properly equipped to handle such information. I see this as a failure of education, that could probably be easily fixed if e.g. high-school curriculum taught basic statistics and probability theory as applied to interpreting medical results. It's the simple things, like "just because you got a positive test on X doesn't mean you have X", "think of horses before zebras" and "if you read 'X causes cancer' or 'X increases risk of cancer by 1000%' in the news, take note if anyone is providing the base level - an increase of 0.00001% probability to 0.0001% means you can ignore the news and keep enjoying X", and "if commonly-used-in-food-X was really dangerous, you'd see people dying like flies around you; if you don't, it means it's mostly safe so don't panic".
- kbenson 11y agoWhile I agree with your assessment of how people act, I really hope that's not a reason that the FDA really uses to keep information from people[1]. It would be troubling to find out that the government had decided that I should not be able to freely access personal information about myself, given that it exists. Whether as a society we can deal with that information currently or not, there's no hope for us dealing with it in the future if we aren't given a chance. 1: I don't doubt it's some people's underlying motivation, I just hope it's not overt enough that it's valid reasoning in official reports.