3 ms·
Nutritional "calories" are actually kilocalories (kcal), which leads to occasional confusion when trying to do calculations that relate food energetic content t
by schoen 11y ago
Nutritional "calories" are actually kilocalories (kcal), which leads to occasional confusion when trying to do calculations that relate food energetic content to other things. For example, I had a book relating someone's calculation that you should be able to diet by drinking scotch and soda because "the body must furnish 7400 calories" to raise the drink from 0°C to body temperature, which would presumably dwarf the energy input from the liquor and indeed from whatever else the drinker consumed all day. (The author agreed that this "didn't work" but didn't understand why not.)
The problem turned out to be that, while the body does indeed furnish around 7000 calories to heat up an ice-cold beverage, the drinker is consuming 2000 or more kilocalories daily, including around 100 from the drink itself.
So, you should lose a factor of 1000 for the definition of nutritional calories. But the numbers in your calculation are so staggering that this barely affects your point, which is that human population isn't close to being fundamentally physically limited by energy inputs from the Sun.
I think you're basically right conceptually, but should give more weight to the difficulty of adapting to some kinds of environmental change. There's no guarantee that human beings can invent everything we need when we need it, and some changes are difficult or impossible to reverse. So even if some limits aren't at all theoretically insurmountable, humanity could fail to surmount them because things that would need to be done can't be done in practice in the required timeframe.