9 ms·
We’ve predicted and broken human population limits for centuries
- x5n1 11y agoi think we need to define limits in terms of energy. there is a certain amount of energy that comes in from the sun that life then uses to decrease entropy. that energy can be used by any form of life to do work. we broke those limits by in part by displacing a lot of other life. so yes we can probably push the limits even more and displace yet much more life on the planet. at some point however that fact will effect us unpredictably.
- iofj 11y ago> i think we need to define limits in terms of energy Ok. Let's do that. The earth receives about 10,000 exajoule per day (3850000 per year) [1]. Daily human caloric intake is 2500 calories [2]. Let's say inefficiency and the fact that you actually need food, not pure energy, let's say that means 20% efficiency, so 12500 calories per human daily. 12500 calories is about 50k joules. Things like running a tv/computer/... would be peanuts on top of that so they "come free". So divide one by the other. The earth, without space based power, can keep about 1e18 humans alive on this planet using just earth-based solar power. Plus you have to keep into account what humans actually do : they convert chemical energy into heat. If we cover the planet in solar panels, why couldn't we recover most of that human-generated heat ? Let's say we can recover 99% of energy that we put into humans back out, that's another factor of 100 right there. We could use nuclear to increase that number to 1e30 or so for a millenium and if you count fusion based power, the numbers become completely ridiculous. To put that number in perspective, take it like this : when every human alive today breeds into a population the size of today's entire human population, then we'd be near the "pure solar" carrying capacity of just the planet itself. If we were to beam power from space to the planet, we wouldn't run into the next limit until 1e50 at least. So we are very, very, very far away, even on an exponential population curve, from the carrying capacity of the planet. When fitting an exponential curve to some sample data (very inaccurate, but good enough for a ballpark figure), I get that if the growth since WWII (1.36% per year, starting at 2000 with 6 billion people), then we'd get to 1e18 a little after the year 3400. > we broke those limits by displacing a lot of other life Only for a few measurements. There are a lot of problematic measurements of life that are inaccurate and therefore full of noise, and can be outright deceptive. Some of those measurements look bad : number of species, for instance. But how relevant is that number ? Sure, if it keeps dropping our zoos will become boring, but what will actually happen ? The truth is nobody knows, and there doesn't seem to be a reason, aside from nostalgia, to assume it's bad. One "real metric" that is at least measurable and I believe is meaningful : the total amount of life is total biomass, and it is pretty well known that humans have increased that by a lot. > at some point however that fact will effect us unpredictably It seems to me to be pretty much a given that lots of things can affect the human race unpredictably, and given how many such factors there are, it seems a safe bet that a few are indeed going to affect us (though the vast majority won't). Malthusianism and global warming are such factors, malthusianism has been proven false 3-4 times at least, and many limits to growth theories both before and after have been (I like the economic "debt limit" ones, stating that we can never have an economy larger than the value of all gold, then we passed that, then money became "loaned gold", and the next theory was that there was some factor that limits how big the economy can be n * total_gold, n was to be 10, then 100, now it's at least 100 million, and they're still at it), I wonder what the fate of global warming will be. If you believe in Darwin and evolution, this is a positive. We will adapt to whatever effect, predictable or unpredictable, starts affecting us. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Solar_energy https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Solar_energy [2] http://www.webmd.com/diet/estimated-calorie-requirement http://www.webmd.com/diet/estimated-calorie-requirement
- eru 11y ago> Let's say we can recover 99% of energy that we put into humans back out, that's another factor of 100 right there. Thermodynamics doesn't work that way.
- dalke 11y agoI'll be more mathematical. By Carnot's theorem, the maximum possible efficiency of a heat engine = 1 - (T_cold/T_hot). Using very rough figures, T_hot = body temperature = 37 C = 310 K and T_cold = average temperature of the earth = 16 C = 289 K. Thus, the maximum possible efficiency is 1-289/310 = 6.8%. To get 99% energy recovery, assuming human body temperature remains the same, would require that the cold side of the heat engine be at 3.1K, or only slightly warmer than the background temperature of space. The only possible way to achieve that difference is by radiative heat transfer to space. However, we can use the temperature of the buried lunar regolith as an estimate of what the the "average" temperature of the earth could be without an insulating atmosphere. http://www.asi.org/adb/m/03/05/average-temperatures.html http://www.asi.org/adb/m/03/05/average-temperatures.html says it's -35 C = 238K. Even if we could use -35C as the cold side of our heat engine, that would still only be 23% efficient, assuming maximal thermal efficiency and, you know, no air.
- eru 11y agoThanks for actually doing the calculations!
- schoen 11y agoNutritional "calories" are actually kilocalories (kcal), which leads to occasional confusion when trying to do calculations that relate food energetic content to other things. For example, I had a book relating someone's calculation that you should be able to diet by drinking scotch and soda because "the body must furnish 7400 calories" to raise the drink from 0°C to body temperature, which would presumably dwarf the energy input from the liquor and indeed from whatever else the drinker consumed all day. (The author agreed that this "didn't work" but didn't understand why not.) The problem turned out to be that, while the body does indeed furnish around 7000 calories to heat up an ice-cold beverage, the drinker is consuming 2000 or more kilocalories daily, including around 100 from the drink itself. So, you should lose a factor of 1000 for the definition of nutritional calories. But the numbers in your calculation are so staggering that this barely affects your point, which is that human population isn't close to being fundamentally physically limited by energy inputs from the Sun. I think you're basically right conceptually, but should give more weight to the difficulty of adapting to some kinds of environmental change. There's no guarantee that human beings can invent everything we need when we need it, and some changes are difficult or impossible to reverse. So even if some limits aren't at all theoretically insurmountable, humanity could fail to surmount them because things that would need to be done can't be done in practice in the required timeframe.
- petercooper 11y agoLess than 0.0000001% of the Sun's energy output ever reaches the limits of our atmosphere, simply due to our size and distance away from the Sun. Long-term, energy is not the key absolute problem, but actually being able to get the technology, materials, short-term energy, and political will together to be able to harness the mind-boggling amounts of space and energy that's out there.
- jkot 11y agoI lived in Ireland and Greece. Many regions there had population peak centuries ago and now are in decline for several decades.
- wongarsu 11y agoMost developed nations currently have declining populations. For now it seems like we can simply stop population growth by bringing the rest of the world to our level of wealth. Then again there's the question whether earth has enough resources to make that even possible.
- eru 11y ago> Then again there's the question whether earth has enough resources to make that even possible. In terms of energy: definitely. Nuclear or now solar suffices.
- thaumasiotes 11y agoI saw someone once refer to the great potato famine as a disaster from which Ireland never recovered. From an evolutionary perspective, this is far from obvious; the famine prompted a lot of emigration to the US, with the result that the world Irish population now dwarfs the old peak Irish population, even though the population of Irish in Ireland is smaller. With large ongoing emigration flows, it's hard to say that the smaller population in Ireland reflects hard times in Ireland... it could just as easily reflect good times!
- wavefunction 11y agoA quarter of my ancestry is from Ireland but I don't consider myself Irish. I find your post weird, how are you considering "world Irish population?" The famine was a political issue anyways, the English oppressors could have released the abundant stores of wheat to feed the starving Irish but didn't want to depress the commodity price of wheat and were also content to let the Irish die. The Irish potato famine happened during an abundance of food withheld, which is the real tragedy.
- shoo 11y ago> Humans don’t just extract from a fixed set of resources, but can create new resources through invention. Perhaps I am being pedantic, but that sounds like nonsense. Sure, humans invent stuff, but they don't invent the resources. They invent new ways to access previously inaccessible resources, or extract accessible resources more efficiently. But they don't magic more resources into being.
- Confusion 11y agoNothing is intrinsically a 'resource'. Something becomes a resource when it can be used to further some human activity. Iron wasn't a resource until iron forging was invented. Without humans, no resources exist.
- jacquesm 11y agoBut the iron was already there before we declared it something useful. Ants use 'resources', so do bacteria so without humans resources definitely do exist and are being used actively, whether we declare something to be a resource to us or not does not change the fact that it was a resource before our wandering eye fell on it. Asteroids are a nice example. They're 'untapped resources', objects we one day may use as resources but which for now just sit there because we haven't found a way to make tapping that resource cost efficient.
- Confusion 11y agoFine: nothing is intrinsically a resource. Nutrients weren't a resource before some self replicating process started using it for some purpose, probably fairly directly related to replication. And iron ore still wasn't a resource until humans came along and invented forging. The term 'resource' does not describe the natural state of something. It describes a relationship between things: something is a resource for some goal(s), by some entity(ies). The relationship did not exist when the other party was not in that relationship, for instance because the other party did not exist. Thinking new resources cannot come into existence is making a category mistake, thinking whether something is a resource is absolute, intrinsic, independent of context.
- hellofunk 11y agoI suspect that at 7 billion now, if the world population rose to even 100 billion, we'd find a way to survive. It would be a very different life experience, but it would still be life.
- jacquesm 11y agoI highly doubt we'd be able to feed and house 100 billion people.
- pflanze 11y agoAble yes, but at very high risk of deadly instability through destroying most of nature and accordingly higher dependence on technology, and smoothly working social structures?
- jacquesm 11y agoUnsustainable to me means 'unable'. If you can't sustain a model in the long term that means that sooner or later there will be a crash. Whether the number of people we can sustain long term is 10, 20 or 50 billion people is currently not known but most people that have spent significant time on this problem put the long-term sustainable number closer to 10 than to 20 billion. Now, as the article states we've consistently under-estimated these numbers but even very generous allowance for errors would cap the number that we could long term sustain in any form well below 100 billion.
- pflanze 11y agoI said "risk of deadly instability through destroying most of nature" but really meant to say "high risk of deadly instability through having destroyed most of nature". I.e. we might get ever closer to a world which is sustainable in the sense that humanity doesn't live off limited resources anymore (say, using machines to convert solar power to food more directly than using plants), but where most of nature has been destroyed and hence the possibilities for recovering by falling back to (even temporarily) using reserves increasingly vanishes (no place to build cheap or simple housing anymore, no land or even suitable climate to fall back on using plants as food). Thus all sorts of small crises can each lead to a lot of dying (perhaps like today's famines in Africa, but now all over the world). But you may know more than me and your point may well be true. (I'm not a researcher, just fantasizing. I should get some experience in mathematical modeling.)
- weddpros 11y agoPopulation growth is exclusively cultural. See how it's declining in Europe, still growing fast in Africa, etc. Science could change that very fast: birth control isn't available to everyone on earth... yet. But religion could change that fast too. So I guess estimates for the earth population will depend on both science and religion more than anything.
- shoo 11y agoalso helpful in reducing birth rates: education and the available economic opportunities for young women
- danbruc 11y agoWhy is this issue getting so much attention? It is a problem that will solve itself, wherever the limit is. The only reason to worry about where the limit is, is if you want to avoid it with birth control so that some nicer forces than famines or resource wars keep the population stable. But even that seems unnecessary, at least in the developed world, because the population growth rates or even the populations are already declining. Which of course is a good thing, why would you prefer a more densely populated world over the status quo? Why would you want to raise child after child if two and a half are enough to sustain the population?
- facepalm 11y agoIt will solve itself, but billions of people might die as part of the solution. Mankind will survive, but for the individual some worrying might make sense.
- danbruc 11y agoThe people that can prevent overpopulation don't suffer from it, the people that suffer from it can't prevent it. So it's more of worrying for once children's children.
- anbu32 11y ago"because the population growth rates or even the populations are already declining." The population of both the us and w.europe is growing. (Immigration)
- danbruc 11y agoBut migration and the normal population growth are qualitatively different - normal population growth is an exponential phenomenon given a constant growth rate, migration is a linear phenomenon given a constant migration rate. And at least in developed countries I see now real issues controlling both forms of growth, limiting the number of immigrants as well as establishing a two children policy if required.
- jzwinck 11y ago
- facepalm 11y agoThere are also cultures that vanished after thousands of years, and crisises in which millions of people died. Human ingenuity and technological progress didn't solve every problem. We just forgot about the dead (classic survivor bias). Collapse by Jared Diamond has some examples of societies that failed - by comparison, our current civilization is very young and hasn't really "played out" yet. Maybe the estimates of Malthus were wrong, but the underlying concern is still correct. Our current food production is not sustainable because it relies on non-renewable energy sources. I don't claim no solution can be found for that, but there is also no reason to believe there will be a solution. Another way to look at it makes it very plain: the surface area of earth certainly is limited. So if population would grow forever, we would reach a point where every person would only have one square foot of ground to live on. Even that might be doable - we could live in a stacked way (skyscrapers), or Matrix-Style in coffins with virtual environment. Nevertheless it doesn't seem like a very desirable future.
- thaumasiotes 11y agoPopulation limits are certainly a well-documented phenomenon. Chinese history shows excellent conformance to a "punctuated equilibrium" model -- the population is stable nearly all the time, with two obvious sudden increases. (From memory, I believe the increases correspond to (1) the local development of a new, more productive strain of rice, and (2) the introduction of crops from the new world.) The inference is painfully obvious: for most of history, China has been populated at its own carrying capacity. The fact that the limit was broken (really, raised) a few times doesn't mean the limit isn't a worthy concept.
- wavefunction 11y agoMy question is why do we need more people or want to encourage or allow it to occur? My immodest proposal is to introduce a natural decline in human populations to more easily sustainable levels via the introduction of a reproductive "right": every individual when born is entitled to one child. A couple, then, could have a family with two children. Those who aren't interested in having children could sell their "right" off on a market to people who want to have more than their one child individually, so a couple could buy the rights to more children and a larger family from those who don't want to have children. The market could even fractionalize/derivatize those rights so that individuals could sell "half" a childbirth right and two of those individuals could have a family with one child. The best part is, at two children per two parents, it's lower than the replacement rate of "2.1" which means population levels would humanely decrease with no need for wars or murder. Our current societies are predicated on larger youth populations than parent populations to support us in our old ages, but this strategy combined with robotic technology for the elderly and post-scarcity economics would free us from that pyramid scheme. This helps support a basic-income type scenario for those people who assume that everyone (or 'THOSE PEOPLE') living in our society will just have tons of kids due to boredom. Like the fears trotted out about "welfare queens" having tons of kids because they supposedly get "free stuff."
- biztos 11y agoSo the rich have large families, and the poor have forced sterilization?
- wavefunction 11y agoIt's voluntary. Perhaps you missed the part about the basic-income and right to a child.
- qrendel 11y agoWhy is lower or stable population of such an imperative that such a totalitarian invasion of natural rights needs be imposed? There are plenty of advantages to larger populations - more people to take part in the creative processes of production, for one. The disadvantage is the dubious assumption of inevitable resource scarcity. If resource scarcity has yet to become a major problem, and may not in the foreseeable future, why impose population limits?
- thomaslkjeldsen 11y agoAccording to Swedish professor Hans Rosling the fast population growth is coming to an end and the population size is expected to stabilize at 11 billion people by the end of this century. His statistics and predictions are based on data from the UN Population Division. http://www.gapminder.org/videos/dont-panic-the-facts-about-population/ http://www.gapminder.org/videos/dont-panic-the-facts-about-p... http://www.gapminder.org/news/world-peak-number-of-children-is-now/ http://www.gapminder.org/news/world-peak-number-of-children-...
- qrendel 11y agoYikes. I didn't realize the population density in Mumbai was near 53k people per sq. mile. Apparently Manila is nearly twice that at 111k.[1] Still, it surprises me overpopulation fears are so commonly expressed. Seems like a greatly overblown meme that will end up doing more harm than good. Much like Malthus opposing projects to feed the poor and hungry, I sometimes hear people going as far as saying we (meaning relatively wealthy, white Americans) should just "let them die" when it comes to impoverished people all over the world. Despite the fact that, if energy consumption and environmental damage is the fear, people in industrialized countries use as many resources as dozens, hundreds, maybe thousands of lives in the "developing" world. The world could likely support orders of magnitude more people than we give it credit for. We haven't even started harnessing materials from space industry, space-based solar power, or using the oceans and seabed as living space. There's another 70% of the Earth's surface that hasn't even been touched yet, and that percentage grows even more when you consider the vertical spaces available within it. The overpopulation meme seems more dangerous to global welfare than actual overpopulation has ever been thus far. Kevin Kelly's edge.org response is a good read on the entire overpopulation issue: http://edge.org/response-detail/23722 http://edge.org/response-detail/23722 [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_cities_by_population_density https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_cities_by_population_d...
- jzwinck 11y agoThe world probably could support lots more people than it has now. The question is, why? If we believe 30 billion people is possible, should it be a goal? What's better about 30 billion than 6?
- hk__2 11y agoYou don’t have the choice.
- qrendel 11y ago1) Reproduction is a natural right, and some people would consider having children to be a great fulfillment. The evolutionary basis of this desire would make it all the more powerful, and restricting it would only cause the drive to grow stronger over time (as traits evolved to promote the circumvention of the restrictions). 2) If there's no specific advantage to a lower or stable population, why is any particular number preferable to another? 3) There are lots of advantages of large population: larger communities for people with low-frequency deviations from social norms, a broader spectrum of human social and psychological possibilities represented, increased production and creative capacity, greater base of working-age citizens to support the non-working portion (retired, children), more people at the top of the bell curve to draw from for important positions (better leaders, more geniuses, etc)... This is not an exhaustive list. 4) Likely other advantages as well, which would seem to counter the disadvantages of larger population, judging from past human history (and assuming no weird non-linear relationships). If the world is better with fewer people, would you want to go back and live in a world with only 100,000? 1,000,000? Some other specific number?
- daniel-cussen 11y agoSame thinking as "housing never goes down." How did that one go?
- daniel-cussen 11y agoEdit: also, remember Easter Island, where the population dropped by over 99% after an ecological disaster last millennium.