5 ms·
Parents stimulating their children does probably more to the brain structure than a check in the mail. And educated parents tend to better stimulate their kids.
by cm2187 11y ago
Parents stimulating their children does probably more to the brain structure than a check in the mail. And educated parents tend to better stimulate their kids. I remember a French statistics from the 90s showing that about 25-30% of the kids going to the Ecole Polytechnique (top engineering school in the country) come from families which do not own a television. Not sure there is a direct effect between watching TV and success but there is a direct effect between good parenting and success. This is why a good education system is fundamental to make up for what sometimes the parenting does not provide.
The other possibility, though not a politically correct one is genes. Rationally I find it hard to believe that genes play no role in our intellectual capacity, and they would mechanically self perpetuate poverty.
Without any hard science to back it, my intuition is that a brain is like a muscle, people are born with different muscle structure, largely driven by genes (but with a certain degree of randomness). So not everyone can make it to the olympics. But going to the olympics also requires hard work and training. If all one does is eat burgers and watch TV, the only outcome is to become obese irrespective of the muscle structure.
- ryandamm 11y ago>Without any hard science to back it I think this is the problem. Here's research that's trying to find some quantitative data about this issue, trying to cut through our received wisdom and intuition. And the response is... rooted in received wisdom and intuition. (I don't mean to dispute your proposed model -- merely to suggest that us sitting here and speculating about models is precisely the wrong way to understand these issues.) Frankly, I'm a little disappointed with the tenor of the discussion on this site; it seems the collective will to libertarianism is stronger than the belief in empiricism. I'm happy to be proven wrong, though.
- cm2187 11y agoOnly science can really close this debate, but we don't really understand how the brain works, what drives intellectual capacity, character, sexual preferences, etc. So I don't see how we can do anything else than invoke what each of us think is our common sense to form an opinion until science tells us what really happens.
- cookiecaper 11y agoYou have far too much faith in "science". Academics are human, and subject to human frailties. Studies are often sponsored or otherwise "encouraged" by outside parties with a certain interest. Academics often modify their reports until they get a result that "demonstrates" their desired outcome. Conventional wisdom, supported by the day's best "science", is regularly disproved. Consider that every side in every political debate believes the evidence supports their opinion, and that the evidence the other guys are using is a sham. Although academics have a bias in aggregate, which should not automatically be mistaken as valid consensus, you can usually find at least a few outlying reports to support any desired political position. What it boils down to is that people believe whatever they want, probably for emotional reasons, and they can't really be convinced otherwise. They're only ready to come to the table when those emotional links have been severed by something in their life experience.
- TeMPOraL 11y ago> Parents stimulating their children does probably more to the brain structure than a check in the mail. Yes; a check in the mail does not raise a kid, parents do. But what a check in the mail can do is enable one of the parents to stay home and do the kidraising instead of having to seek another job so that the family can have heat in the winter. That's why it is useful.
- cookiecaper 11y ago>Yes; a check in the mail does not raise a kid, parents do. But what a check in the mail can do is enable one of the parents to stay home and do the kidraising instead of having to seek another job so that the family can have heat in the winter. That's why it is useful. Nobody does that any more.
- TeMPOraL 11y agoChecks in the mail or heating the apartment for winter? If the first, s/check in the mail/electronic transfer/; if the second, well, global warming and stuff...
- cookiecaper 11y ago>one of the parents to stay home and do the kidraising
- TeMPOraL 11y agoReplace that with one of the parents working less. Or in case of single-parent households, with the parent working two shifts instead of three. Additional income helps one redirect some time from work to children, in one way or another, and kids benefit from that time.
- cm2187 11y agoI can't talk for the US but in Europe at least, the image of blue collar workers working really long hours is more of a XIX century cliche. The vast majority of blue collar workers today work fixed hours, usually 35-38 hours a week, which is ample time to raise kids. It's not a matter of time spent. White collar workers are the one doing very long hours in modern societies. Though their kids somehow seem to still get better parenting.
- DanBC 11y ago> Parents stimulating their children does probably more to the brain structure than a check in the mail. When you give someone cash you give them the ability to buy books, or go to places, or buy lego, that stimulate a child.
- devonkim 11y agoIn many poor, underprivileged environments, children are not encouraged to do these things with income. Furthermore, a lot of the socially encouraged spending patterns make it more likely for indoctrinated children to fall back into patterns of poverty even if they have the motivation and capability otherwise to get out. I'm not sure if you've seen how kids interact much but peer pressure is extremely strong and if you're off reading books and playing with Legos at an early age there's little guarantee that it will persist into puberty and beyond. Plenty of friends I grew up with early on had a lot of these interests but most fell into a typical lower/lower-middle class trap of drugs and sex (with partying linking both together, of course). There were some middle-upper/upper class kids that participated a little, but there are different forces at work for those kids entirely that makes it quite easy for them to escape a bad cycle with merely competent parenting skills compared to a completely overworked, overwhelmed single parent or split parent household that defines a great deal of lower income household living situations.
- DanBC 11y agoThreads like this just need a fucking huge [citation needed] and "stop using your anecdotes" banner.
- devonkim 11y agoIt's a bit exhausting to have to pick up all the citations but I can certainly find a good reference or two for the first part if you know a couple phrases. Firstly, there's a couple papers on the phenomenon of "acting black" that shows how even gifted black kids are held back by themselves almost http://news.vanderbilt.edu/2008/03/acting-black-hinders-gifted-black-student-achievement-58236/ http://news.vanderbilt.edu/2008/03/acting-black-hinders-gift... or perhaps as a set of papers by a Harvard professor that grew up poor and black in a rough area http://www.washingtonpost.com/news/wonkblog/wp/2015/04/30/meet-the-economist-who-grew-up-among-crack-dealers-and-won-a-mini-nobel-for-his-research-on-race/ http://www.washingtonpost.com/news/wonkblog/wp/2015/04/30/me... This other paper explores how drug use is correlated with peer drug use but can be mitigated by relationship strength with the mother, which can be rather darn hard if she's working 12-hour days http://sitemaker.umich.edu/356.darnell/peer_pressure_and_drug_use http://sitemaker.umich.edu/356.darnell/peer_pressure_and_dru... If you add in anti-social behaviors, being poor translates quickly into anti-social behaviors as the sort of "unproductive behaviors" that is being banded about in the thread http://www.researchgate.net/publication/232460627_Poverty_Parenting_Peer_and_Neighborhood_Influences_on_Young_Adolescent_Antisocial_Behavior http://www.researchgate.net/publication/232460627_Poverty_Pa... We're not here on HN trying to solve the world's problems or something in comment threads anyway, so being a bit qualitative and subjective is something that goes with the territory of a lot of social science. We could go really rigorous but measuring people and behavior is really, really hard to do well without making the results of papers so narrow they're irrelevant for making meaningful social commentary arguments.