6 ms·
Prison Without Punishment
- jit_hacker 11y agoThere are no absolutes when it comes to criminal punishment. There is always an exception to everything. That said, I've long thought if you stop treating people like animals, they'll stop acting like it. I've never studied prisons, or psychology, or anything remotely related. But I genuinely believe this philosophy is investigating.
- dethstar 11y agoWell there's countries like Norways which make prison look like vacations to people in countries with less resources (except the not going out whenever you please of course) Foucault argued that the point of prison is to create more crime though.
- rdtsc 11y ago> Foucault argued that the point of prison is to create more crime though. Add profits generated by the prison industrial complex and it actually starts making real economic sense to keep them coming back.
- TeMPOraL 11y agoThen there are countries like Poland where prisons look better than hospitals, at least in terms of food quality and access to entertainment. Complaining about it is a popular pastime here.
- rdtsc 11y ago> There is always an exception to everything. Unless there is minimum sentencing involved, which became popular in US during War On Drugs. That took a lot of discretion that judges had and turned decisions into absolute black and white type things.
- rokhayakebe 11y agoNote that in the US, prison is a multibillion dollar industry. It cost around $30,000 (on the low end) to incarcerate someone yearly. Even if they spend a day or two, someone is making money. Nothing to be said of the calling minutes. All in all this may be a $50-$100B industry in the US. That is not going anyway.
- TheSpiceIsLife 11y agoWhen I first read your comment it immediately brought to mind privately run prisons, but after a few moments though I realised you're comment calls attention to the ongoing wealth transfer from the general tax-payer to the prison associated workforce, who then go on to spend that money in the general economy. Prison generates economic activity, which generates tax revenue. Governments have a vested interest in increasing tax revenue.
- kiba 11y agoDigging holes generate tax revenue as well.
- TheSpiceIsLife 11y agoThat's what the highway department is for.
- fleitz 11y agoJust google prison worker union contributions :)
- wanderingstan 11y agoThis model only works if you give up on gaining tax revenue from rehabilitated inmates.
- rokhayakebe 11y agoThe second part of your comment is an interesting perspective, I actually meant what you had in mind at first.
- scrapcode 11y agoIn the Federal system inmates work towards something similar through their behavior. Look up Federal Prison Camps.
- wanderingstan 11y agoAs someone who was just visiting a prison today, I can assure you that prison camps are nothing like this. Just a glorified version of home ankle monitoring. No psychologically training. No saving money. Read the description by the CEO of y-combinator's Pigeonly. They look for any possible infraction to send you back to prison. He had to illegally keep a cell phone in order to found his business.
- d357r0y3r 11y agoCould it work? Of course, the data is abundantly clear here. If you treat prisoners like shit, then their chances of recidivism are much higher. If you want to reduce crime, then you have to treat prisoners well. There's really very little controversy here from an academic perspective. The barrier is cultural. The public in the U.S., by and large, expects prisoners to be punished harshly. Retribution and deterrence rank way higher than rehabilitation in terms of the desired outcome of incarceration. As far as the average American is concerned, anything that happens inside of the prison walls, including but not limited to rape, murder, torture, is the price you pay for breaking the law. If we want to have better prisons, then we'll need people to develop some degree of empathy for prisoners, and that's a tough battle in the U.S.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- ams6110 11y agoIf you want to reduce crime, then you have to treat prisoners well. There are no prisoners without there first being criminals.
- fleitz 11y agoNelson Mandela, Allan Turing, and Oscar Wilde might disagree with you on that. To be fair on Mandela the modern US stance is that he should have been assassinated, rather than imprisoned. https://wikileaks.org/cia-hvt-counterinsurgency/press-release.html https://wikileaks.org/cia-hvt-counterinsurgency/press-releas...
- srtjstjsj 11y agoMandela was at war with the govt of SA, so that's a complicated case.
- fleitz 11y agoHe was imprisoned for inciting workers' strikes and leaving the country without permission... it doesn't seem that complicated to me... His charges of overthrowing the government were so baseless they had to be thrown out.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- linuxhansl 11y agoGerman here, living in the US (and liking it here in the US). I can confirm that generally there is a different viewpoint. In Germany prison is somewhat of the last resort mostly to be avoided, and even then the aspect of rehabilitation (and deterrence) is most important. In the US I find there's often a notion of revenge, as in "This person must suffer for what for (s)he did!"; and more severe sentences usually to be considered as "more justice". Edit: Some spelling for clarity
- trhway 11y ago>In the US I find there's often a notion of revenge US is puritans. Revenge is one of the cornerstones of the puritan moral.
- gdwatson 11y agoYou should read some Puritans some time. You might be surprised.
- larsiusprime 11y agoThat's as simplistic as saying Australia is a bunch of criminals. The USA spans a huge continent which was settled by a huge number of very different groups all with different moral and philosophical foundations.
- justthistime_ 11y ago> "But, but ... we play both kinds of music, Country and Western!" Yeah, but somehow it's only one group of people who seems to call the shots: Those with a disdain for the poor, the weak, the ill, the black and women.
- trhway 11y agoNo. There is no national party in Australia with a base consisting mainly of criminals. Whereis the US Republican party's base display all the worst characteristics of puritanism, including their "holier than thou" main driving attitude which directly feeds their views on crime and punishment.
- clamprecht 11y agoIn prison (US federal), when a guard was a dick to inmates, our saying was "We're here AS punishment, not FOR punishment".
- cubano 11y agoI violated 3 years felony probation late last year here in Florida and was picked up on the warrant on May 18th. The original charges were possession charges from about 5 years ago, and I only had 6 months to go when I was violated for working out-of-county (I had to go where the contract was). It was a simple "technical" violation so I figured I would be ok. I was not. I was sentenced to 15 months in prison for some reason that no one could explain. I didn't even "score" prison time, yet my crap public defender just sacrificed me to the state prosecutors. Thank goodness I had 13 months credit time served, so I only had to do like 51 days "up the road". Florida D.O.C decided to make it hard on me for whatever reason, and sent me back to Gulf C.I. Annex in the panhandle, some 9 hours from my home. I was first assigned to a "T-dorm" where approx 80% of my fellow inmates were serving life sentences. Yes, you heard correctly...they made me, with my little 51 days, live in that particularly dangerous environment. Needless to say, I avoided talking about my release date. There are absolutely no programs at Gulf C.I. I am 100% convinced that the entire system is designed to create recidivism, not prevent it. The C.O's smuggled in K2 and it seemed everyone was smoking that shit constantly. It was easier to get drugs then it was to get a book to read. I was released on the 7th with no phone, money, and prison issued clothes. I had to stay in shelters for 2 nights until I finally made it back to central Florida. I am in the process of writing a blog post about the entire incredible experience, but the tl;dr version of it is that the system is a sledge hammer and every problem is a block of concrete to be smashed to dust and swept away.
- code_sterling 11y agoJust curious, possession of what? And how much?
- cubano 11y agoPossession of heroin, Possession of over 20g of weed...both felonies. You can read my previous posts about it. I'm just glad it's all finally over and I'm free to move and work as I need.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- jorde 11y agoWe have pretty relaxed prison system in Finland as well and it seems to be working pretty well[1]. They doesn't have the stigma as it does here the US and actually my sister lives next to a closed prison with her small kids and it's a no biggie. [1] http://www.theatlantic.com/international/archive/2013/09/why-scandinavian-prisons-are-superior/279949/ http://www.theatlantic.com/international/archive/2013/09/why...
- megablast 11y agoDifficult to compare the two, when Finland has a very homogeneous culture, and is tiny.
- angersock 11y agoOur culture might be more homogeneous if we didn't use the prison-industrial complex to foster racial tensions and divide the populace.
- jellicle 11y agoI often see this given as an excuse for the U.S.'s prison system, but it seems a sort of non-sequitur along the lines of "difficult to compare the two, because Finland is named Finland". Is it just a codeword for the sentiment that the U.S. has black people, and they're inherently evil, so cannot be rehabilitated or treated nicely like Finland? That seems to be the only explanation that fits. If that's what you think, why not say it? If that isn't what you meant, maybe you can explain further. For instance, you could try to finish these sentences: "The USA is a larger, richer, country, and therefore it cannot build a prison facility that holds 300 people and is rehabilitative rather than punitive because......" or for homogeneity: "The USA has a somewhat more diverse population than Finland, and therefore it cannot build a prison facility that holds 300 people and is rehabilitative rather than punitive because......" I'm curious to see what the explanation is. It certainly isn't anything obvious to me.
- EliRivers 11y agoI believe you are incorrect. It is, in fact, extremely easy to compare the two. Happens every day. Nobody seems to have any trouble doing it. If you meant "the comparison is not valid because something", we'd all like to hear what that something is. It can't be because it's small, because that's irrelevant (what, being big makes it impossible to have a rehabilitative justice system, does is?), and it can't be because there isn't much population diversity, because that's also irrelevant (what, some kinds of people are just natural criminals and there's nothing anyone can do about it?).
- hwstar 11y agoI think the treatment of prisoners in the US is a big part of the problem. European countries don't force prisoners to wear orange prison uniforms, or transport them in waist chains and leg irons. Sometimes respect and dignity for the prisoners by the prison authorities can go a long way towards reforming the prisoner.
- Confusion 11y agoThe title derives from a single quote of someone that claims prisoners in Germany are not put in prison as punishment, but only to protect the public. But that is simply not true: punishment most certainly is a goal of accusers and most prisoners certainly feel punished by being locked up, so that goal is at least partially achieved. The major difference is that the government does not consider it the main goal and other goals, such as rehabilitation, are given more weight than in the US.
- rbehrends 11y agoThe claim is entirely true (§2 StVollzG [1]), but you may be misunderstanding something here. The rehabilitation of offenders and the protection of the public are indeed the sole two permissible objectives of incarceration in Germany. But there is a difference between (1) the imposition of prison sentences and (2) how they are being carried out. Judges may take other factors into account to determine the severity of a sentence, but once imposed, rehabilitation of offenders and protection of the public are the only two goals that the process of carrying out the sentence may serve. [1] http://www.gesetze-im-internet.de/englisch_stvollzg/englisch_stvollzg.html#p0013 http://www.gesetze-im-internet.de/englisch_stvollzg/englisch... (and yes, the translation of the section title is ... imperfect).
- Confusion 11y agoPunishment is not an official goal of the government. Nevertheless, in practice it certainly is a goal, as required by the people the government represents. Punishment is a goal of many victims and of people who believe punishment discourages crime. When the perpetrator is brought to justice, the victims-turned-accusers will demand punishment. It is the goal of the government to represent their interests. It partially does this by setting up the prison system as it is and imposing prison sentences. If dealing out punishment, as wished by the victims, was not an indirect goal contributing to the way things are, prisons would be more comfortable. The circumstances in prisons, their austerity and severity, cannot be explained except by wanting to punish the people in there. They are not optimally suited for only rehabilitation and protection of the public. This is of course entirely understandable.
- Overtonwindow 11y agoSounds like a good idea to me. In America, we do too much imprisonment, and not enough rehabilitation. I understand has a lot to do with costs and politics, but I really think we should stop warehousing people for years and years, with no rehabilitation.