3 ms·
Society agrees to let individuals have exclusive access to particular resources based on a system of rules. That's close, but you're missing an essential point
by mindcrime 11y ago
Society agrees to let individuals have exclusive access to particular resources based on a system of rules.
That's close, but you're missing an essential point. To the extent that we can speak about "society" in an general sense, it would be more accurate to say that "society agrees to help you defend your property rights if you play by their rules". That doesn't mean that property is a fiction that requires government or society. And by the same token, there's no reason you couldn't construct a system where everybody helps everybody else defend their property simply in terms of "mutual aid". Taxation is not an inherent property of all systems for defending property. In fact, I will continue to argue that taxation is inherently inimical to the idea of property.
- aninhumer 11y ago>there's no reason you couldn't construct a system where everybody helps everybody else defend their property simply in terms of "mutual aid". Are there penalties for not providing this "mutual aid"? If so, you're just describing a highly localised tax system. EDIT: And if not, I think you might find your system struggles in the presence of noticeable inequality. (Why should we protect the rich guy's stuff?) > Taxation is not an inherent property of all systems for defending property. Of course not, but it is a feature of pretty much all existing such systems. >In fact, I will continue to argue that taxation is inherently inimical to the idea of property. I believe a property system will inevitably trend towards inequality over time, because those with more money have more power, and thus greater opportunity to earn more money. Inequality makes the system less efficient at utility generation, because it diverts production towards more marginal utility improvements. In order to avoid this, you need some system of wealth redistribution.
- hga 11y agoAnd by the same token, there's no reason you couldn't construct a system where everybody helps everybody else defend their property simply in terms of "mutual aid". Just such a system existed in the English common law, and from what I've read in the early days of America: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hue_and_cry https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hue_and_cry