3 ms·
I agree and disagree. SMTP is bad, but it isn't the primary problem. The problem is social conditioning. Since the 19th century, postal services have been mono
by peterwwillis 11y ago
I agree and disagree. SMTP is bad, but it isn't the primary problem. The problem is social conditioning.
Since the 19th century, postal services have been monopolized by government institutions with a fee levied for storage, processing and transportation costs.
Physical mail delivery in bulk is costly, which makes it more profitable to send directly rather than en-masse.
But SMTP requires no fee. Originally, your ISP would provide you with e-mail in exchange for the fee you paid for your connection. Since the advent of "free" email services, people got used to not paying for mail anymore.
With electronic mail, it's cheap and easy to send in large quantities. Before we never needed to verify who was sending us mail, but now it's the only way we can filter out the noise.
To make electronic mail better we have to make it more expensive. Requiring a payment to send mail would reduce the cost-effectiveness of spam, and I would argue it would make the systems more verifiable. You could even preserve anonymity by having anonymous mail services, as long as you paid to send those mails, say with bitcoin.
Want to run your own mail server? Fine, but relaying will cost you. FedEx doesn't deliver mail from the USPS for free, and so relays shouldn't be expected to pass on mail without transportation costs.