24 ms·
"When Netflix or any other rental business buys DVDs, they don't just buy the same copy you and I do, but a rental version with different licensing terms which
by ghshephard 17y ago
"When Netflix or any other rental business buys DVDs, they don't just buy the same copy you and I do, but a rental version with different licensing terms which costs considerably more"
Citation?
- anigbrowl 17y agoRead the license terms on the back of any movie DVD you own. Also: http://www.videobusiness.com/article/CA6642010.html http://www.videobusiness.com/article/CA6642010.html As you'll note therein, if a DVD is on sale in the store, the first sale doctrine of copyright law means you can legally rent it out to people, same way you can sell second hand books without getting publishers' permission to do so. The reason I cite the rental version above is that is how it has been done up to now: the rental version is made available with a restrictive license before the consumer version goes on sale, precisely to avoid the cannibalization of rental revenue due to the first sale doctrine - which is why studios are looking at adding value to rental version by including content that won't be available on the consumer one. But even then, renting out the consumer version is legally dubious. It would appear to be OK under the first-sale doctrine, and the link above mentions a case known as NEBG vs Weinstein, (the film studio), with the implication that studios can do nothing to prevent such rental. So says Wikipedia too, but without any citation for this assertion. Here, on the other hand, is a description of how the case went down, including the fact that it was dismissed on the basis of ripeness (ie a complaint brought about something that hasn't actually happened yet) rather than being adjudicated and thus settled case law: http://williampatry.blogspot.com/2007/05/first-sale-fandango.html http://williampatry.blogspot.com/2007/05/first-sale-fandango... In a nutshell, a video rental business sued a film distributor over their plan to label consumer DVDs as 'for sale, not rental' claiming that to do so would be an unfair restraint of trade, not least since the distributor had an exclusive rental deal with blockbuster at the time. It would be foolhardy to assume that freedom to purchase automatically implies freedom to rent, as a rental exception for musical works already exists in law, and while this does not explicitly mention DVDs, the spirit of that legislation (Record Rental Amendment of 1984 which modifies Section 109 of the Copyright Act) would clearly apply, and courts would certainly take that into consideration. so you might get away with it, and studios/distributors would rather not go to court and been as the same kind of bad guys as the RIAA. But if push came to shove, I believe they would do so since a consumer-copy-rental business would horribly gouge their profits, significantly increasing their commercial risk.
- ghshephard 17y agoSo, anigbrowl, I appreciate your passion, but you made a fairly broad claim, ""When Netflix or any other rental business buys DVDs, they don't just buy the same copy you and I do, but a rental version with different licensing terms which costs considerably more"" After spending 45 minutes or so googling "Blockbuster", "Netflix" "Retail Chain" "channel" - I can't find any reference whatsoever to "costs considerably more". Indeed, it appears that blockbuster doesn't even buy the DVDs that it rents, but instead just gives a cut of their revenue to the movie industry: http://nwitimes.com/business/technology/article_feee2db5-425a-5889-85b9-0e8808f814c8.html http://nwitimes.com/business/technology/article_feee2db5-425... Which probably explains how they can guarantee availability of recent releases - they get a basically infinite supply of the DVDs and only have to pay for what they rent out. With regards to Netflix, they too will be getting a significant discount now that they've signed their "30 day blackout" window. Indeed, the only people I could find paying retail for DVDs were Redbox - and that's because the movie industry is forcing them too. Retail prices appear to be a _ceiling_ - it's what you pay if you can negotiate a discount. Any citation indicating otherwise would be appreciated. I really have enjoyed reading your review of the case law, I'm just wondering if you've got the pricing on DVD rentals correctly leveled.
- anigbrowl 17y agoHere you go, although it has the dreaded [citation needed] tag too - best I can do on short notice. I don't know what the exact terms of Netflix's distribution agreements are - my comment about the rental fee was meant as a general one, to give a capsule explanation of how the industry works, so I'm sorry if it seemed like an overly specific statement about that one company. Generalities about the film business are awkward; it's opaque insofar as much pricing is contract- rather than market-based. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Blockbuster_Inc.#Business_model http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Blockbuster_Inc.#Business_model
- jhancock 17y agoNext time you watch a DVD you bought, not rented, pay attention to the intro screen text. You will usually see a clear statement that the movie is licensed for home/personal use only. Some claim such a license statement cannot be enforced by U.S. copyright law, but there it is. Without regard to whether it is or is not a legitimate position for the copyright holder to take, you can be certain that Warner and others would not sell large amounts of DVDs to Netflix without Netflix agreeing to these conditions.