4 ms·
There's several types of "errors" here: (1) failing to help a person in need, (2) trying to help a person in need and failing, or (3) trying to help a person an
by epistasis 11y ago
There's several types of "errors" here: (1) failing to help a person in need, (2) trying to help a person in need and failing, or (3) trying to help a person and instead enabling destructive behaviors.
Different people weight these two errors differently. Some people think it's really terrible to fail to help an honest person in need, but don't care as much about the cost of enabling a self-destructive person. Others don't care much about (1), and would in fact not help a single person rather than let (3) happen once.
Public policy needs to be informed both by the available interventions, (i.e. give cash, give cash only after a drug test, give treatment after a failed drug test, then cash after completion, etc.)
Unfortunately the 'loss function' of the different types of errors is what really gums up most honest debate on these issues. A lot of these are evaluated on moral principles more than economic costs, which further complicates the story. I disagree with them, but there's a lot of people that think there should be harsh penalties in the world for using drugs, no matter the societal costs. Or that giving anybody a handout from taxpayer money is wrong, even if it ends up saving taxpayer money in the future.
- SixSigma 11y agoExcept giving drug users.cash stops them burglarizing and robbing.
- DanBC 11y agoExpanding on SixSigma's point: Drug users sometimes engage in acquisitive crime to get money to buy drugs. Or they become sex workers. The public health burden of (unregulated) sex work is considerable. So giving these people cash reduces the crime they commit, and reduces the need for them to become sex-workers. Often just giving them the cash is far cheaper than the legal system alternatives - the police investigation and the trial is likely to be expensive. (I accept your point that some people just don't care about saving that tax money, they want "tough on crime" policies) > Public policy needs to be informed both by the available interventions, (i.e. give cash, give cash only after a drug test, give treatment after a failed drug test, then cash after completion, etc.) This is so simplistic it's almost hateful. It's a failure to understand the complex drivers of a lot of severe drug addiction. http://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2010/oct/21/drug-addicts-sterilised-children-protect http://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2010/oct/21/drug-ad...
- epistasis 11y ago>This is so simplistic it's almost hateful. Whoa, I didn't intend to advocate for any particular interventions, just giving some of the difficulties of talking about these in the US political environment, and that short parenthetical list is the sort of interventions that are often brought up tin these discussions.