3 ms·
> When poor people are explicitly given a room, 3 square meals/day, and government issue poor-people sweats What if someone inherited a place to live, but has
by smt88 11y ago
> When poor people are explicitly given a room, 3 square meals/day, and government issue poor-people sweats
What if someone inherited a place to live, but has no money? What if she grows her own food, but she can't afford the suit she needs to interview for jobs?
Premise 1: Each person's situation is distinct. In other words, there is no standard group of benefits that would solve everyone's problems.
Premise 2: Poor people will use cash to improve their lives in the long term, rather than just blowing the money on short-term pleasures.
That second premise is exactly what's being demonstrated in small studies, national programs outside the US, and surveys.
- yummyfajitas 11y agoWhat if someone inherited a place to live, but has no money? If someone has wealth I'd generally expect them to consume that wealth before receiving wealth transfers. But more generally, if people have some of their needs being met but not all, then they can consume only some of the available in-kind benefits. E.g., a wealthy person with no income (like you described above) might provide their own housing but get their food from the government cafeteria. Premise 2 is both debunked in the US. Google the consumer expenditure survey and witness poor folks spending money on short term pleasures. Your premise 2 also conflicts with the article: Even if bad behavior does make poverty worse, it’s also the case that poverty causes bad behavior in the first place. Now you can try to improve the choices that poor folks make. But you can also just eliminate the bad choices and directly manage their lives until they develop the ability to manage their own life.
- chongli 11y agoIf someone has wealth I'd generally expect them to consume that wealth before receiving wealth transfers. You don't need to make it so complicated. Just tax people on their wealth and income, then pay everybody the basic income. Those at the very top will end up paying far more in taxes than what they receive in basic income.
- smt88 11y agoRecent article about this: http://www.fastcoexist.com/3040832/world-changing-ideas/a-universal-basic-income-is-the-bipartisan-solution-to-poverty-weve-bee http://www.fastcoexist.com/3040832/world-changing-ideas/a-un...