6 ms·
Interesting, reminds me of a related question. I've looked recently for 10 gig ethernet on a new laptop and haven't been able to find it. I know it is overkil
by mixmastamyk 11y ago
Interesting, reminds me of a related question. I've looked recently for 10 gig ethernet on a new laptop and haven't been able to find it.
I know it is overkill, its just that it has been about ten years already, isn't it cheap enough yet? Can't a modern ssd keep up with it?
- _wmd 11y agoProbably a combination of lack of need until recently (125MB/sec is more than fine to saturate a classic disk), parts cost and power consumption. I can't think of anything except connecting to a _fast_ SAN that would require a 10GBE port in a laptop. Maybe something specialized for a network engineer, but even then it's probably easier to buy dedicated equipment for line rate port monitoring
- mixmastamyk 11y agoThe use case is high-def video editing, which people could do on laptops, and there are thunderbolt connections at that speed. I found this: http://www.fastestssd.com/featured/ssd-rankings-the-fastest-solid-state-drives/#pcie http://www.fastestssd.com/featured/ssd-rankings-the-fastest-... Pushing 3000MB/s, which is 3GB/s which should be times 8 for gigabits, I think it should be viable now, no?
- noja 11y ago> I can't think of anything except connecting to a _fast_ SAN that would require a 10GBE port in a laptop. An off-the-shelf consumer raid-5 nas would require more than a gigabit port (so a 10 gig port would be needed).
- jamesblonde 11y agoA very cheap RAID5 setup with 4 spinning disks and a filesystem like ZFS or btrfs should get you about 3-500 MB/s, so 10 GbE is good for that setup on nodes.
- trentnelson 11y agoThe only way you're getting 3-500MB/s on a 4-disk ZFS RAID5/raidz is with very, very fast SSDs and a very, very fast CPU. Not exactly "very cheap". (The compute and I/O overhead for raidz is significant.)
- mitchty 11y agoYep, i have some wd red 3tb drives in a raidz6 pool. At best I can get 60m/s out of it. Each drive can do about 100m/s sequential but that is rare. Putting an ssd on for caching read/writes though really changes the calculus of this.
- illamint 11y agoThis is... not my experience at all. I have a RAIDZ2 comprised of 6 4TB Seagate drives (the 5900RPM variety) and it can do about 600MBps read/write with moderate CPU usage on an Intel i3. A mirrored zpool of two Samsung 850 EVO SSDs can do nearly 1GBps read/write. That's not a particularly expensive setup.
- trentnelson 11y ago600MB/s write over 6 drives in RAID-Z2 is very good on an i3.
- noja 11y agozfs maybe not, but btrfs does it.
- sliken 11y agoEven a cheap $100-$200 SSD can do over 2Gbytes/sec these days: 256060514304 bytes (256 GB) copied, 95.4762 s, 2.7 GB/s The M.2 interface has finally shrugged off the SATA bottleneck for commodity hardware. It's common on new motherboards, new laptops, and I recently read there's similar circuitry in the new iphone 6s.
- detaro 11y agoBuilding it in doesn't really make sense. Nearly no users, power hungry (although that has gotten better), bulky. And what connector do you use? 10Gig Base-T? Not really common and power intensive. SFP+ port? Really bulky. There are Thunderbolt adapters. USB3.0 only has 4Gbit/s available, ExpressCard only 2GBit/s, so both aren't really good options.
- Spooky23 11y agoWindows doesn't keep up with it well. We had alot of issues with VDI workstations running 10GB interfaces. Lots of weird latency problems, solved by presenting a 1GB adapter.
- trentnelson 11y agoCompletely the opposite of my experience with PyParallel; I can saturate 2x10GB Melanox-2 ($35 each off eBay) via TransmitFile() with about 3% CPU use.
- Spooky23 11y agoThe tests we run are based on our workload. Lots of Windows rpc, Outlook MAPI/RPC traffic and similar stuff.
- matheweis 11y agoThere are Thuderbolt adapters, as another comment noted few other interfaces have the bandwidth. There's a lot of other bandwidth issues that aren't sorted out yet, too. If the adapter and drivers don't have TCP offloading, you'll be very hard pressed to get more than 3Gbit for anything other than a UDP dump. Most of the OS network stacks aren't properly tuned for 10Gbit either. I'd say give it a few years; as it becomes more mainstream, things should improve.
- vardump 11y ago> If the adapter and drivers don't have TCP offloading Any modern adapters you can think of that don't support TCP & UDP offloading (+ARP, etc.)? As far as I know, all of them support it.
- Qantourisc 11y agoBut not all drivers/network cards are bugfree :/
- matheweis 11y agoWell, it doesn't apply to OP's question, which is why I didn't mention it directly, but I know for sure that most enterprise class virtualization software doesn't accelerate through to the VMs. (Yes, there is SR-IOV, but then you lose hot migration and other HA features. SolarFlare had it a while back but it no longer works) I didn't mean to suggest that it's hard to find, just that there are a host of things that need to be in place before you'll get the expected speeds. This isn't a knock on the tech or any manufacturer, it's just that it's not mature enough to to be like 1Gbit where you plug it in an almost everything starts running at 100Mbyte/s. Here's an example of what to expect (I have no affiliation with this thread): https://forums.creativecow.net/thread/197/860183 https://forums.creativecow.net/thread/197/860183
- vardump 11y agoI doubt IP/TCP offloading even makes that big of a difference, if SIMD (SSE2+ or AVX2+) can be used. A single CPU core is probably capable of TCP checksumming more than 100 Gbps. Of course it's a completely another story without SIMD. A naive traditional checksum loop with a register dependency stall is just not going to be fast.
- Qantourisc 11y agoI have to wonder why 10gig, why don't the make an intermediate step ? Like 5gig ?
- wmf 11y agoUntil recently Ethernet only increased in speed by factors of 10. This made sense when it was increasing 10x every 5 years, because it takes years for standards and products to be developed. But now there are intermediate speeds like 2.5G, 5G, 25G, and 40G.
- imaginenore 11y agoWhat do you do on a laptop that it requires 10 Gbit?
- Keyframe 11y agoDon't know about OP, but I could use it to connect to fast storage on network and do some video finishing. Laptop has sufficient power, but no storage of that capacity.
- imaginenore 11y agoGigabit should be more than enough for that. There's no way your CPU/GPU can process video faster than Gbit/second.
- Keyframe 11y agoDepends what I'm doing. For editing it's usually just fine. Color and fx work require higher bandwidth. For example, at 2k a single frame is 12 MBytes (times 24 or 25 per second, depending on the project). And we are at the dawn of an era where we are talking about 4k dci or QHD mastering for all. That wpuld be 48 MBytes per frame. So,we're looking at 300 and 1200 MBytes per second for a single workstation. Gigabit is not up to it.
- imaginenore 11y agoI doubt your CPU/GPU can do color/fx at 1200 MBytes/second. Heck, I don't doubt, you're making it up.
- Keyframe 11y agoIf you say so. Explain how am I running 2K DPX 10-bit in realtime with color correction applied on Lustre then? Does my machine and Autodesk software perform magic?
- mixmastamyk 11y ago