9 ms·
Leaked Pinterest Documents Show Revenue, Growth Forecasts
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- seibelj 11y agoSometimes I use pinterest when I'm looking for cooking inspiration. It is absolutely nothing like 4chan, I have no idea what you are talking about.
- dogma1138 11y agoWell Pintrest and 4Chan are quite similar in their underlying ideas, both are twitter (yes i know 4chan predates twitter) with images basically. There are quite a few differences but they aren't that far apart as people think. Forget the "quality" of content and trolling for a moment, you can't really say that these 2 do not look similar. http://boards.4chan.org/ck/catalog http://boards.4chan.org/ck/catalog https://uk.pinterest.com/categories/food_drink/ https://uk.pinterest.com/categories/food_drink/
- ZoF 11y agoOne is a catalog of images with description. The other forces login or an app download.
- dogma1138 11y agoI see what you did there, kudos :)
- detaro 11y agoIMHO with pinterest the long-term memory aspect is quite important (collect things and look through them later), which 4chan is completely missing.
- kristopolous 11y agoWhat similarity do you see between pinterest and 4chan?
- eachro 11y agoFacebook was just a better myspace. Google was just a better askjeeves/altavista/etc.
- prawn 11y agoI don't get the 4chan comparison in any way. Pinterest helps people catalogue things they find inspiring or are shortlisting to buy. They're right there between someone with an intent and a product for sale. That's a valuable position to be in.
- qq66 11y agoA Boeing 747 is a better donkey.
- dexterdog 11y agoBut it's a way better donkey.
- gitah 11y agoThe 2018 projection of $2.8 billion revenue with 329 MAU for Pinterest is roughly what Twitter will achieve in 2016. Twitter has a market cap of 20B vs 11B for Pinterest, so there is plenty of upside if Pinterest hits 2018 numbers and goes public. That is assuming Twitter's current valuation is reasonable which is debatable.
- idlewords 11y agoHeaven help us if Twitter becomes the standard ruler for sane valuations.
- arjunnarayan 11y agoIt's not clear at all that 1 Twitter MAU = 1 Pinterest MAU. The really hardcore Twitter users spend all day on Twitter (@pmarca comes to mind, it seems Twitter is his full time job). I'm not sure the same is the case for Pinterest (although this might just be my ignorance of Pinterest speaking). So maybe Twitter gets more money out of each MAU because the users spend more time on the site. But maybe a Pinterest MAU is worth more - I don't know. Intuitively it feels more susceptible to "native" advertising - my little impression of Pinterest is that it consists of lots of curated glossy photos scrolling by of aspirational consumerist things. Seems very monetizable. In any case, in order to apply your logic, the epistemic burden is on you to show that a Pinterest MAU should be financially treated the same as a Twitter MAU. I don't see that as being straightforward at all.
- jedberg 11y agoIt's unfortunate that potential LPs can't be trusted to keep these kinds of things secret, because it makes it harder for founders to trust them in the future. As an occasional LP myself, I always consider financial documents like this just as secret as my own bank statements and health records.
- jsprogrammer 11y agoWhy do they need to be secret? If secrecy is such a large concern, why not go the TPP route and keep the available copy in a locked room under supervision?
- coke12 11y agoPart of the reason a company stays private is to have more control over the release of financial information. Why would a company that values privacy choose to do business with a firm (a16z) that it can't trust?
- jsprogrammer 11y agoThat doesn't give a motivation for the secrecy. I don't know why someone would or would not do business with a16z. Was a particular contact breached here? I don't remember reading such an allegation, but I may have missed it.
- coke12 11y agoPrivacy is a reasonable thing to expect in basically all business transactions, regardless of whether it's listed specifically in a contract. Firms that want to maintain good relations with the startup community want to be seen as trustworthy.
- jsprogrammer 11y agoI'm reading lots of justification, but no reason for why the secrecy is desired.
- djcapelis 11y agoAnyone know if there's data on their expenses or is it all just a report on one side of the profit curve?
- hayksaakian 11y agoPromoted Pins anybody who's ever tried them knows that pinterest is doing very well
- jgalt212 11y ago> TechCrunch has obtained documents that show Pinterest has been forecasting $169 million in revenue this year and $2.8 billion in annual revenue by 2018. So in three years, they'll have to grow revenues by 16.5X. These sort of outlandish growth assumptions necessary to substantiate their valuation is exhibit A as to why the a16z valuation is extremely suspect. Of course, 16.5X growth is doable when you are starting from a low number, but $169MM ain't spit. And all the being said, $169MM for 2015 is just a forecast, so if they miss on Q4 numbers, the 16.5X assumption can easily be 20-25X. On the plus side, their revenues per active user target of $9.34 is relatively modest, and I think doable as FB does $4.18 per user per quarter in revenue.
- nugget 11y agoAdvertising platforms can scale that fast. What if they are only monetizing 5% of pin boards at the moment? Going to 100% coverage would be 20x. Devil is in the details but order of magnitude growth isn't out of the question.
- petercooper 11y agoJust some more data to support your point. Some research by Institutional Venture Partners in 2013 showed that in companies over $150M in revenue, around 30% revenue growth per year was the median, so 155% per year (16.5x growth over 3 years) is incredibly keen.
- pftom 11y agoConsidering this revenue number, it really can't be valued at 10Billion dollars.
- pdq 11y agoBoth Pinterest and Twitter are getting hammered by Instagram in popularity over the past 2 years. Have a look at Google Trends [1]. [1] https://www.google.com/trends/explore#q=instagram%2C%20twitter%2C%20pinterest&cmpt=q&tz=Etc%2FGMT%2B5 https://www.google.com/trends/explore#q=instagram%2C%20twitt...
- onion2k 11y agoIf those are navigational searches then it might indicate people don't have the service's app installed. That's fine for Twitter and Pinterest as they're accessible from the web, but it'd be bad for Instagram as a web search isn't an entry point to their service.
- orthoganol 11y ago$90 million revenue run rate this year and an $11 billion valuation... Are VCs trying to rush everything onto the public while they can, or what? Slightly disconcerting when people say VCs aren't trying to do things like they did in the last boom. Yes, I really don't think you can justify a valuation like that. It all depends on Pinterest having the popularity of Facebook in a few years, which is an incredible lie.
- adevine 11y agoBut the forecasts given in the article most certainly could support that 9 billion valuation (i.e. 2.8 billion in revenue in 2018). Looking at the 90 million run rate is pretty meaningless given that Pinterest only relatively recently started advertising. I think there are plenty of completely absurd valuations in the tech scene right now, but if anything Pinterest has probably the easiest revenue story to tell.
- eva1984 11y agoNot really. Advertising as a way of monetization might be easy to understand, but harder to actually implement and sustain. It is not like 'just put ads on it', then money will flow by itself. It will take some non-trivial efforts for Pinterest to actually make their model working. The competition is out there: Facebook has one of the biggest and richest demographic data in the world, and it could easily leverage that to drive sales on Instagram, make it more appealing to advertisers, which I think Pinterest should be afraid of.
- gdilla 11y agoIt's all based on growth. You can't value it like an established company. "When Twitter went public in 2013, it was valued at $24B — 12 times higher than Times market cap. Twitter was losing money while the Times earned $133M the same year. Why do startups have such big valuations? The answer is: cash flow. It is different between high-growth startups and low-growth businesses. Startups would usually be profitable in the future. Startup’s main metric is growth."[1] [1] https://medium.com/@paulmillr/zero-to-one-summary-8dbda22e1559 https://medium.com/@paulmillr/zero-to-one-summary-8dbda22e15...
- free2rhyme214 11y agoWho knows what revenue numbers Pinterest will hit. Lucky for them their competition is nil.
- eva1984 11y agoInstagram is pretty close to be their competitor.
- free2rhyme214 11y agoTrue but the ability to buy stuff on Pinterest is pretty cool.
- gdilla 11y agoinstagram is a completely different dynamic than pinterist. Besides, if they do compete, it's not zero sum. People use both (and use them differently).
- rwmj 11y agoWhat stops Pinterest being sued by the magazines/photographers whose photos are being ripped off?
- maxerickson 11y agoThe DMCA.