3 ms·
Prisons or Colleges?
- bilbo0s 17y agoI applaud the Governor's intentions, it is far more sensible to allocate resources to higher education than to prisons. Having mentioned that, I think it should be stated that he is solving the wrong problem here. The reason tuition is increasing so rapidly in California is because the State no longer has the wherewithal to properly fund its educational institutions. This is a direct consequence of the fact that Californians are able to vote on ballot initiatives obligating that state's government to take on, sometimes quite expensive, commitments. Pair this with the fact that Californians have made increasing their tax burden exceedingly difficult, and you can see the Governor's problem. That situation is really a mess. Even for prisons, he can't cut spending below a certain amount, or the law enforcement brotherhoods and lobbyists will come after him. He can't decrease the number of people in prison because of the Three Strikes ballot initiative, which obliges him to incarcerate large numbers of nonviolent offenders indefinitely. And the worse part about it is that he needs to do both, decrease spending and the number of incarcerated people. And that is one of what must be a large number of issues he needs to work through to get the budget on track. Its prisons vs. education, that decision should be the easiest. I don't envy that State's leaders. People anywhere make democratic leadership challenging but the people of California must be especially difficult to manage.
- hugh_ 17y agoSounds like what we really need to do is outsource the prisons. To, say, Mexico, or China. I'll bet the Chinese don't pay $50,000 per prisoner per year to keep their prisoners locked up -- heck, they probably harness their labour to turn a profit.
- bilbo0s 17y agoYou know the sad thing is that the law enforcement interests would probably come after you on that too. Sad.
- teeja 17y agoHeck, they're probably not a democracy. And probably have no constitution or bill of rights. And probably haven't caught up with the 19th century. And probably disappear people left and right. Great role model.
- tomjen2 17y agoI have wondered for years why it costs money to have inmates. Slaves in the old south would cost about as much as a good new car (40k according to free the slaves) so you would think there would be some value in inmates. I compare them to slaves because they have about the same motivation for doing work.
- hga 17y agoNot so minor point: the California Three Strikes law requires the first two felonies to be "violent" or "serious". From the reference I just checked, the only non-violent serious crimes are "lewd or lascivious act on a child under the age of 14 years" and providing hard drugs to minors ("heroin, cocaine, phencyclidine(PCP), or any methamphetamine-related drug" or a precursor of the latter). I find it impossible to work up any sympathy for someone who commits two such crimes and then shows he has no intention of staying on the right side of the law by committing any felony, violent or not. I also don't see how it's bad public policy; as one person put it WRT Giuliani's clean up of New York City: "He found the root cause of crime, criminals."
- bilbo0s 17y agoNo one is arguing that it is bad public policy. I myself am only arguing that it is prudent to reconcile public policy solutions to the public's bank account prior to implementing them. I live in Houston, yes I'm a Texan. No one is tougher on crime than Texas. In some cases, yes, Texas is too tough. One of the major reasons Texas did not follow along on the whole Three Strikes bandwagon was because the political leadership thought it might not be cost effective. Now I don't know if it is or it isn't, I would need more data to make that determination. My point is, the leadership here in Texas, at least had the ability to analyze the likely fiscal consequences of such a policy and then decide whether or not to enact it. Balancing the fiscal consequences with the public safety benefits. In California, unless I am misunderstanding their ballot initiatives, the leadership has no choice but to enact the policy. Regardless of the policy's fiscal consequences. I'm just not so sure that is a good way to do things.
- anamax 17y ago> This is a direct consequence of the fact that Californians are able to vote on ballot initiatives obligating that state's government to take on, sometimes quite expensive, commitments. The voter mandated spending is less than the revenue, so the gap is due to spending that the legislature and governor insisted on. > Pair this with the fact that Californians have made increasing their tax burden exceedingly difficult Not true, and not relevant due to the above. > the law enforcement brotherhoods and lobbyists will come after him. It's interesting that you didn't mention the education lobbyists, who get 50% by statute. > the people of California must be especially difficult to manage. Let me suggest that politicians are not supposed to "manage" the people that they supposedly represent and should fail when they try. BTW - CA has three strikes because politicians couldn't be trusted to keep violent thugs in jail. That was a change - until the 70s, they did.
- CWuestefeld 17y agoEmotionally this sounds appealing. But it seems to me that htis is just another example of the kind of government that brought California to bankruptcy. Governing by emotional appeals to the way our values tell us the world should behave is not a recipe for success in a world that behaves as the chips fall. More to the point, read Friedrich Hayek's The Fatal Conceit for a discussion of the hubris of believing that we can engineer a world to our liking, and that this world be at all sustainable.
- Alex3917 17y agoExactly. Why should the government be spending more on the school system than on prisons? There isn't even a real argument, it's just being taken as a given. If anything improving the prison system should be given higher priority than fixing the college system, because prisoners have to be there. They don't have a choice. Whereas students can just opt out of college, or else go to a private college.
- bilbo0s 17y agoVery good point.
- jfornear 17y agoI think this idea is premised on the notion that there may be an inverse relationship between education and crime. http://www.jstor.org/pss/27529879 http://www.jstor.org/pss/27529879
- hugh_ 17y agoAre the folks in prison really the same folks who would otherwise be attending the University of California? I think they're generally pretty different demographics. Better K-6 education could probably decrease crime, if we can turn the illiterate, shiftless dullards who make up the lower rungs of society into literate and hardworking (if still dull) citizens. But this requires more a new educational strategy rather than just more money, and I don't know if anyone has thought of a good one yet.
- 17y ago
- gojomo 17y agoAllow the CCPOA to unionize TAs. Problem solved!
- danteembermage 17y agoIronically, that would work quite well. So would $10,000 scholarships funded with a $10,000 lump sum tax on UC and UC State students
- teeja 17y ago"California spends about $50,000 a year per inmate" On the surface, that number looks somewhat insane.
- hugh_ 17y agoOne of my favourite theories on prison reform: a huge problem with prisons is the formation of gangs and other social structures within the prison walls; not only do these promote the emergence of a criminal culture within the prison, they also make the prisoners harder to guard. This could be solved by keeping everybody in solitary confinement, but that's overly cruel. Instead, I'd propose splitting the prison into a whole bunch of separate units, each consisting of maybe a dozen prisoners, who would share facilities and never interact with prisoners outside their own unit. Every month, the units would be broken down and prisoners reassigned to different units, preferably arranged so that no prisoner would encounter the same fellow prisoner twice in one sentence. This way we could give prisoners enough social interaction to stop 'em going crazy while preventing them from ever constructing any more than the most rudimentary social structures. Any downsides I'm not considering? I'm assuming that the whole thing could be accomplished without occupying any more space than the existing prison system, and hopefully with fewer guards.
- marcusbooster 17y agoJust that many prisoners already know each other from their own neighborhoods. The groundwork of the social structure is already in place. The problem is not guarding prisoners, the problem with prison reform is that it doesn't reform anything. The question is what do we want prisoners to do once they're out? There is always a political push for longer sentences but it's economically infeasible. So if we're then asking what we can do to make these people productive members of society again, then that takes money.
- qw 17y agoYes, that's the problem. They need to get an incentive to prepare for life outside prison. Many of the prisoners don't have the education or the skills to get a real alternative. If they have a choice of a minimum wage or selling drugs, they will often choose the easy way. I think the best solution would be to increase prison sentences, but give a similar (if not greater) reduction if they choose to re-educate/train themselves. They would also have to show a real intent, so that they don't just sit there without making an effort. This will not work for everyone, but I am sure that it will reduce the number of prisoners with 3 strikes. The second problem is the actual workplaces. The state should pay a large amount of the ex-prisoner's salary for the first year, and a smaller amount in the second year. This will encourage companies to hire them. I'm not an economist, but I assume that this cost will be payed back by keeping them out of prisons.