3 ms·
"Is there absolutely no way for ISPs to react to this in such a way that they save money rather than lose it?" Yes, the one I laid out. The ISPs ban their cust
by jerf 17y ago
"Is there absolutely no way for ISPs to react to this in such a way that they save money rather than lose it?"
Yes, the one I laid out. The ISPs ban their customers from participating for "bandwidth reasons", then directly provide the services to the distributed CDN, rather than going through the users. My argument is not that the ISPs will find this too expensive; it's the exact opposite! If there is value here, the ISPs will find it too profitable to resist, and they will not let their users in to the party.
The problem here is that in the long run, the users aren't bringing anything to the party; they only bring bandwidth, which isn't actually theirs, it belongs to their ISP. (And some fairly minimal storage, but that is already a commodity and rapidly becoming even more so; CPUs have stalled some but all the other bits of the computer are still marching on Moore's style.)
For contrast, consider a "legal botnet" that does computational work where the computation dominates the data transfer. We know that works; SETI@home has been running for over a decade. Users simply divvy up the ISP's bandwidth, but users own orders of magnitude more processing power than the ISP does, so there's actually a resource here that the ISP can't just tap itself. (Well.... legally anyhow.)
I'd even say the fact that the ISPs have not already implemented this distributed CDN is a powerful argument against the idea that there's a lot of value here to be captured, though of course that's not proof.
- bdonlan 17y agoActually, akamai hosts their CDN nodes right at ISPs already - though this is mostly to serve customers on that very ISP without paying for backbone bandwidth. So in a way we already have this distributed CDN...
- jerf 17y agoYeah, I thought that was the case but wasn't 100% sure, so I didn't mention it. This further dilutes the value of a botnet CDN, probably straight into negative territory.