3 ms·
I find your logic interesting. So let's say I have this new way of doing things. It's called "hit your head with a hammer". I'm crazy about it and wrote a bunc
by DanielBMarkham 17y ago
I find your logic interesting.
So let's say I have this new way of doing things. It's called "hit your head with a hammer". I'm crazy about it and wrote a bunch of books about it. Other people have tried hitting their head with a hammer and, although there are many detractors, there are also some big fans.
So what you're saying is: we cannot make a legitimate (or "interesting") observation about "hit yourself in the head with a hammer" unless we also have mastered the art of doing it. Only then would we have something worthwhile to add.
I'm not saying TDD is bad. What I'm saying is that it's perfectly fine to look at the phenomenon from the outside and make general observations about it. For instance, "TDD is very hard to impose on most teams" or "When implementing TDD for the first time, teams experience a significant drop in performance"
I'm sure there are lots of others.
Uncle Bob (and others) have made a mockery out of informed discussion in regards to TDD. Here's hoping we can keep a reasoned and civilized discussion going in the community.
- lyudmil 17y agoI agree. I would say the observations you give as examples are backed by evidence and thus interesting to read (and, in fact, legitimate). I stated my case badly, but I would include such statements in the third category. I meant what I said to be a call for civilized discussion about the topic which echoes your sentiment. I also wanted to point out that such discussions have an annoyingly low signal-to-noise ratio. [Edit] I also was not trying to suggest a general strategy for evaluating programming practices. I made the assertion it was clear TDD has value at least in certain contexts. In the case of TDD I think it is evident its benefits are subtle enough to approach the issue more carefully.