3 ms·
Babylon 5 (1st 4 seasons, season 5 well meh) while potentially one of the best "space" shows ever created is hardly science fiction, actual science plays very l
by dogma1138 11y ago
Babylon 5 (1st 4 seasons, season 5 well meh) while potentially one of the best "space" shows ever created is hardly science fiction, actual science plays very little role as plot devices it's more of a space opera than classic SciFi.
- TeMPOraL 11y agoI mentioned TNG as best science-wise, because after long holding the first place, it was defeated for me by Battlestar Galactica (reimagined), which I now consider as The Best Made Sci-Fi Series Ever. TNG may have had much greater impact on my life, but the new BSG is a work of art in ways TNG was not.
- dalke 11y ago"is hardly science fiction, actual science plays very little role" I've read a lot of SF and can assure that science is not required for the genre. "A Scanner Darkly" comes to mind, where SF elements were added to the story to make it SF, but play little role in the story. Silverber's Majipoor series has technology, but it's so ancient and unused it might as well be fantasy. Things like the ability to send dreams are nominally done by machine, as are many of the things in Babylon 5. Farmer's Tiers series is another SF example where the super advanced science - the ability to create artificially-constructed universes, for example - are explained as science, but the science element do little to advance the story.
- dogma1138 11y agoAgain that's a matter of interpretation and classification, many people do not classify Star Wars as scifi but rather as high fantasy because of the force. And i don't consider A Scanner Darkly to be pure scifi, just like most of Dick's other works, it's fiction for sure but not necessarily scientific.
- dalke 11y agoIf you want to be that sort of gatekeeper then feel free, but know that "science fiction" has long had a larger umbrella than the term you want, and your beliefs are in the minority. For example, "Star Wars" won the Hugo for 'Best Dramatic Presentation' in 1978 so right there it's obvious that a lot of people - and those who are more identifiable and influential than your bland 'many people' - classify it as science fiction. (Bear in mind that "The Force" or an equivalent has long been a thread in SF. Think of the mental powers of the Lensmen, or precognition in 'Dune', or telekinesis in 'Stranger in a Strange Land'. You cannot handwave it way as "fantasy" without throwing out a lot of other SF.) I also gave two other examples of mainstream science fiction which are no less fantastical than Babylon V. To that list I'll add Pellucidar. What is the science driving "Tunnel in the Sky"? A magic device that can slow time and allows space warp. What of the rest qualifies as 'scientific' which makes it notably "science fiction" instead of simply "fiction"? What is the science behind "The Hitchhiker's Guide to the Galaxy"? Or "The Dispossessed"? The main characters live on a moon, the primary is also inhabited, there is occasional radio and rocket connection between the two, and there's a computer that helps with resource planning. None of those details drive the plot. For that matter, is there any TV series you think should be called "science fiction"? What actual SF do you think deserves being called SF? I gave names. Now it's your turn.
- dogma1138 11y agoStar Wars as a high fantasy isn't my definition, and the Hugo Award is for scientific and Fantasy fiction. Science Fiction's classical definition is a work of fiction that uses science as a story telling device to explore ideas. I don't want to be a gatekeeper to anything, mainly because it's just as presumptuous of me to do that as the opinions you've presented. There are quite allot of categories in speculative fiction https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Speculative_fiction https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Speculative_fiction including Science Fantasy ,and Comic Science Fiction which is where i would put Douglas Adam's work in there. The more finite definition of a work is really dependent on the setting, story telling device used and interpretation. A tunnel in the sky is a very good example of works that can be classified as Science Fantasy a genre that it's author Robert Heinlein was quite instrumental in it's creation. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Science_fantasy https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Science_fantasy