3 ms·
How is a $700 grinder better than any burr grinder?
by sp332 11y ago
How is a $700 grinder better than any burr grinder?
- peapicker 11y agoI've had cheap (~$100) burr grinders and still got too much dust in my ground for a proper-tasting espresso. Bought a Nuova Simonelli MCF (back when they were $350 instead of $600) and the commercial-level burrs and worm-gear infinite grind adjustment made my espresso incredibly better. Details on features of a grinder like this: https://www.seattlecoffeegear.com/nuova-simonelli-mcf https://www.seattlecoffeegear.com/nuova-simonelli-mcf
- Retric 11y agoEgo. PS: Most people fail blind taste tests with this stuff. But, just like the high end audio market spending money on junk makes some people feel good.
- nicpottier 11y agoSource please? It isn't an ego thing, it is a consistency thing. People go mad about getting higher end grinders, machines, etc... because they are trying to control for all possible variables. Espresso is incredibly finicky about those variables, but you can control for them with the right equipment. It is pretty easy to demonstrate that the higher end burr grinders have greater adjustability and consistency than the lower end ones. It is also totally obvious that they are needed on any higher end machine. I used to think it was all bullshit too, then I got a Silvia, started with a blade grinder, then a low end burr grinder, then a rocky before I could finally get the grind both fine and consistent enough to pull a proper shot. It isn't a subtle difference between a good shot or a bad one, anybody can tell the difference.
- Retric 11y agoEX: http://www.drbunsen.org/coffee-experiments/ http://www.drbunsen.org/coffee-experiments/ Based on this analysis, subjects did not show a statistically significant preference in coffee brewed from a blade grinder or burr grinder. First off only ~1/3 of coffee drinkers take it black which masks a lot of taste variation. Second, taste sensitivity varies widely. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Supertaster https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Supertaster Put together well under half of coffee drinkers notice subtle differences in grinding methods. Assuming the devices are setup to similar grinding levels and use similar source beans. Note: You can find examples on both sides of this issue. But, the blind taste tests that repeat over time fail to provide the expected consistency. PS: There are a few people that both notice and care about these issues, but they really are the minority of coffee drinkers.
- luma 11y agoBrewed coffee != espresso. I think that might be the essential piece you are missing. Espresso is brewed at very high pressures and as a result the grind size and consistency has a large impact on the resulting shot. The difference is not at all subtle and is quantified by the extraction time for each shot.
- HeyLaughingBoy 11y agoI'm kinda with you on the ego thing, but I will claim that there is a noticeable difference (in brewed coffee, I'm not an espresso fan) between beans ground with a good burr grinder vs a blade grinder. I couldn't match the quality of my local Dunn Bros coffeeshop until I started asking them to grind my beans when I bought them. Switching from my cheap blade grinder to their in-shop one made the largest difference in taste.
- Retric 11y agoYour assuming it was using there grinder vs. there grinder settings that was important. In other words proper technique vs. proper device. Also, time sitting around post grinding is a large factor.
- HeyLaughingBoy 11y agoWell, considering that simply by virtue of being completely different types of device, there's no way I could match their settings with my grinder. Yes, time is a factor, but a week after the beans were ground in store, they still tasted better than mine, so...
- nicpottier 11y agoAs someone else noted, drip (brewed) coffee is a different beast than espresso. A blade grinder will probably do you just fine for that. Espresso is brewed under pressure, if you don't have a consistently fine grind then the water will pass straight through without extracting any of the flavor. If your grind is too fine, then it will block the machine and you'll get a bitter extraction. Again, this isn't a subtle thing. If you've had a real espresso machine (one that has a pump that applies the proper pressure) then it immediately becomes obvious that you need a consistent grind that you can adjust. The variable you track is generally the length of the extraction, ie, how long it takes to get an ounce or an ounce and a half of espresso for a given amount of time. (aiming for 16-22 seconds or so) Too fine a grind and you'll block it up and you'll never get the oz, too coarse and it will all come out too quickly. You often need to adjust the grind minute amounts every day based on local temperature, humidity and the age of the beans. This isn't audiophile stuff, it is obvious to anybody who makes espresso and actually wants it to taste good. (ie, isn't drowning it in milk, sugar and syrups)
- luma 11y agoWhile I understand where you're coming from on this with respect to high-end audio and other fields where eye-watering price tags are applied with poorly-defined reasons, this isn't the case here. The espresso process is EXTREMELY finicky and highly sensitive to initial conditions. Recipes vary from bean to bean, machine to machine, and based on personal preference, but they all generally specify the same 3 things: the mass of coffee going in ("dose"), the mass of the resulting shot, and the time for the extraction to complete. I typically am pulling shots with Madcap's Third Coast blend. In their shop they target an 18.5g dose yielding a 31g shot completed in 25 seconds (with no pre-infusion). The dependent variable here is the shot time. Anything +/- 4 or more seconds is dumped in the sink as completely undrinkable. The difference is not at all subtle - the shots are awful even to a novice palette. The reason we have PIDs (and rotary pumps, heated group heads, calibrated tampers, doses measured to the 1/10th gram, etc) is to control every last variable that will impact this process. Every variable here can and will create wild swings in the resulting shot time, so we fix everything we can as accurately as we can to avoid dumping $1 worth of espresso down the drain. With everything else fixed, what we then control as the independent variable is the size of the grind. This then is how espresso is tuned to land within the time given by your recipe. Grind finer (smaller particles), the process will take longer. Grind looser (larger particles), the process will run shorter. Anything more than 3 seconds one way or the other is another dollar bill down the drain. Very small changes in grind size can yield very large changes in the resulting extraction time. Every time you miss the mark, another dollar bill hits the sink. As a result, grinder performance is probably the single most important piece of the espresso puzzle, and it's easy to quantify the difference.
- draker 11y agoCommercial coffee grinders are periodically calibrated to ensure they are providing the proper grind. When new both the $100 unit and $700 unit would likely provide similar results. Over time the commercial unit (built to handle higher volume) would remain in-spec without calibration for a consumer user whereas the grind of the $100 unit would likely degrade from wear.