3 ms·
As you say: second-order effects. If user home broadband connections are being sold cheaply enough to be able to be resold for a profit, the ISPs will either ra
by jerf 17y ago
As you say: second-order effects. If user home broadband connections are being sold cheaply enough to be able to be resold for a profit, the ISPs will either raise the price to recoup this (the value of the connection has gone up to you and therefore you will be willing to pay more), or cut out the middleman and directly provide these services with their bandwidth (forbidding end users from participating), pocketing the money.
This entire plan hinges on the ISPs doing nothing in response. And the responses the ISPs would make aren't even "evil" or anything, it would just be rational market behavior on their part.
Furthermore, there would be major quality issues. Clever programming and design could make this work with enough redundancy in the system that even as people log in and out the content wouldn't disappear, but this does not come for free. You must pay a price somewhere else: increased latency (one of the most likely outcomes, many P2P systems make this tradeoff), decreased bandwidth, grotesque requirements for content replication that goes a long ways towards mitigating the capacity of the system. You can often trade one kind of quality for another, but you can't increase the total quality available, and a home consumer broadband connection is a low-quality connection for this purpose. And the quality of home connections aggregates distinctly sublinearly, especially since so many of them are badly asymmetric.
This is a terrible idea and anybody going into it will lose everything they invest, excepting the IMHO faint possibility that some interesting technology could emerge that could eventually be repurposed for something sane. (I call this a faint possibility because that would then be facing competition from technologies directly purposed for whatever this later domain is and given the likelihood of a large difference between the initial design constraints and the final design constraints you're likely to have a very inferior solution.)
- milkshakes 17y agoI still don't understand why this is a terrible idea. Is there absolutely no way for ISPs to react to this in such a way that they save money rather than lose it? If decreasing traffic between providers doesn't save money, then wouldn't there be some savings at least from decreasing traffic between subnets?
- brazzy 17y agoCDNs don't scale down that well. The likelihood that there is demand for one particular piece of data within the same subnet (and thus the value of having it there) decreases dramatically with the size of the subnet. As the article itself points out, some CDNs already do this with large ISPs, directly. This kind of thing may increase and get more sophisticated, but it will never include the users themselves as middle men.
- milkshakes 17y agoCDNs don't scale down that well. The likelihood that there is demand for one particular piece of data within the same subnet (and thus the value of having it there) decreases dramatically with the size of the subnet. Is there no inflection point in between, where this makes sense? I guess what I'm trying to say is that CDNs cant be everywhere, but users can
- marcamillion 17y agoI agree with milkshakes on this one. Brazzy...you are right. CDNs (in their current form) don't scale well. A properly executed p2p CDN can scale much better, IMHO. As for not including users themselves as middle men, I must disagree with that. It makes economic sense for the ISPs to want to convert bad p2p traffic to good p2p traffic. That's their goal...all the while monetizing that good p2p traffic. Put it this way, the ISPs will do nothing, except sign a revenue share agreement and possibly change their TOS to allow customers to resell their bandwidth. For every GB resold, the ISP makes money. So in essence, they are converting bad p2p traffic to good p2p traffic and making a killing - the economics works in their favor.
- brazzy 17y agoTo the ISP there is no "bad" or "good" P2P traffic, just costs vs. income. And why would an ISP want to share revenue on bandwidth rather than get all the revenue themselves, since they are ultimately providing it?
- jerf 17y ago
- marcamillion 17y agoJerf, There are many truths to your point, and I do agree that the post as presented does come against some of those inherent problems with the ISPs. Because I wanted to simplify the post, in an attempt to strip it to its bare minimum, I left out a very important aspect of the model - which changes the economics of the legal botnet a bit. Revenue share split with the ISPs. The bet is not on whether or not ISPs would do nothing in response to an inordinate amount of their network being used for P2P traffic. The real goal is to convert the 'bad' P2P traffic, but incentivizing the current P2Pers to use their machines for good use (and earn some money) while doing so. Again, of course, at the limits there might be some problems with the economics of it all - but I think rather than it blowing up, it is just unknown. No one knows exactly what will happen when the majority of the bad p2p traffic converts to good p2p traffic. I do agree that there are major quality issues, but I think we have reached the stage of technological advancement that those problems can be solved. Maybe not with something off the shelf, but definitely solved. As to your last point, the truth is that this idea actually has two business models and uses. I think I might do another post to flesh out that side, but the name of the post bares it out. A legal botnet. In other words, a legal way to fight fire against fire for DDOS attacks. The only way to defeat a DDOS (as far as I know) is to throw more bandwidth at the packets being sent. As it stands right now, it is very expensive to do that from one single ISP (or even a handful of ISPs). With a network like this, it would become an arms race. I would postulate that the legal side would win, because economics is on its side - for many of the larger targets anyway.