5 ms·
Am I the only one who think it's perfectly logical that the speaker ratio is the same as the ratio of the tech population? Of course we should try hard to find
by Kiro 11y ago
Am I the only one who think it's perfectly logical that the speaker ratio is the same as the ratio of the tech population? Of course we should try hard to find minority speakers just to be proactive since we do have a diversty problem. However, when you go to a conference you want to see the best speakers and then it's only logical that a minority is less represented since, you know, there are less good speakers to choose from.
Nordic.js is doing a great job with their "50% women speakers" policy but if we forcibly try to overrepresent every minority where do we end up? "50% black trans women speakers"? I wouldn't go to such a conference since the probability of bad talks would be too high.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- jackweirdy 11y ago> I wouldn't go to such a conference since the probability of bad talks would be too high. Why?
- Kiro 11y agoBecause only a small % of all people in tech are good speakers. Having a smaller population to choose from would mean a higher risk of putting a bad speaker on the lineup.
- wpietri 11y agoYou're assuming that a) good-speakerness is a fixed quality, and b) that the speaker selection process is something like pulling bingo numbers. Neither is true.
- paulojreis 11y ago> but if we forcibly try to overrepresent every minority where do we end up? "50% black trans women speakers"? I wouldn't go to such a conference since the probability of bad talks would be too hig\ You end up with hiring quotas in companies, where a less-than-competent candidate can be hired instead of a competent one because he/she belongs to a minority. Will the bet on minority over competence will yield greater gains in the long run? That is a question for the ages. :)
- onion2k 11y agoThat point you've apparently missed is that current hiring practises among some companies can be discriminatory. There are hiring managers out there who won't hire a female developer because they're just outright sexist. Quotas get introduced because there are brilliant minority developers who get passed over because they're in the minority. All that said though, I don't believe there's any actual evidence that people end up hiring less-than-competent people because of quotas. It's only a theoretic possibility that could be true if the available candidates only included one incompetent person from the minority group, but I don't think that's ever going to be the case in practise. The choice always comes down to two or three competent people, and the quota system then pushes the decision on one direction. White male programmers don't like it because it's not in their favour, but the reality is that they could be passed over even if there wasn't a quota system. While people continue to discriminate quotas will be necessary.
- dijit 11y agothe hiring process is completely opaque, so this can never be proven or disproven. ideally, we'd have a system where we have a balance sheet that gets tallied up- but interviewing is an important part in gauging competence and culture fit (yes, this is a real thing, I know some developers who don't wash and I would not call them culturally fitting), so it's not something that can be solved easily. We all, inherently have a bias- we can't divorce ourselves from that bias, so how do we hire? by tribunal? I certainly believe quotas to be a shitty solution.
- onewaystreet 11y agoThe fear of not having the best people speaking at a conference might have some merit if the people speaking at most conferences today were actually the best people. They are usually not. The best people speak at very few conferences because they are busy working.
- tajen 11y agoIn other words, women are overrepresented in conferences compared to their presence on the field, and it's going to be the same with ethnicities. In my business experience, women are already overrepresented in management positions compared to developer positions. Who wants to remain a developer anyway?
- provemewrong 11y ago> Who wants to remain a developer anyway? I do.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- wpietri 11y ago> if we forcibly try to overrepresent every minority where do we end up? I am so tired of this sort of fantasy catastrophe based on a fantasy exaggeration of of a reasonable point. If your question is, "What would happen if we reversed the polarity on the diversity-suppression machine and suddenly conferences were as diverse as they had been previously vanilla?" then the answer is: the conference would be about the same, but with a different set of speakers. Heck, let's try it. The industry has been unusually straight white male for, what, 30 years? [1] Let's try 30 years of conferences that are exactly as biased but in the opposite direction. In fact, let's just try 3 years and see how it goes. My guess: lots of good conferences and a much more diverse set of people joining the field and not quitting the field because they're tired of dealing with bias. > I wouldn't go to such a conference since the probability of bad talks would be too high. You understand, don't you, that your implicit assumption here is that there just aren't enough competent non-straight-white-dude speakers to fill out a conference list? In my experience, the conferences that work really hard on diversity are better. Why? Because to get a diverse speaker base, you have to work really hard on outreach. You're going out beyond the usual suspects. You're finding people who wanted to speak but had never got a shot. You're finding the people who never even thought about speaking but would be great. [1] http://www.npr.org/sections/money/2014/10/21/357629765/when-women-stopped-coding http://www.npr.org/sections/money/2014/10/21/357629765/when-...
- malandrew 11y agoYou understand, don't you, that your implicit assumption here is that there just aren't enough competent non- straight-white-dude speakers to fill out a conference list? I think you're deliberately misrepresenting the OP. The way I read the OP, they are making the assumption that for every single identity group in tech, that the prevalence of great speakers to bad speakers is approximately equal. For shits and giggles, let's say that assumption is 2% of white guys, 2% of white women, 2% of black women, 2% of black men, 2% of asian women, 2% of asian men, 2% of trans people, etc. etc. etc. are no only competent by talented speakers you'd want to see at a conference. The moment you intentionally ignore base rates of the availability of each group, you're no longer getting the 2% of the engineering population that are the best speakers regardless of their identity. You're instead optimizing for diversity over technical excellence. Nothing wrong with that, just be clear that you can't optimize for both unless the base rates for all groups are approximately equal or unless one identity group actually have a greater percentage of technically excellent speakers than another identity group. That said, I don't really care about conferences either way, just statistical truths. I rarely go to conferences any more, since I prefer reading code, papers and technical writings that are shared based on the quality of content instead of the identity of the author. In my experience, the conferences that work really hard on diversity are better. I'm really curious to know your definition of "better" because I would venture that both you and the OP are completely correct in your viewpoints and arguments, because you two don't share the same definition of "better". Those conferences are better based on your criteria of better, but may be subjectively worse for the OP based on their criteria of better. FWIW, I'm a non-straight "white" dude (half anglo, half latino (by way of iberian and mediterranean descent) (more specifically a anarchoamorous, pansexual, agender male with a cisgender visual appearance because I don't see the value of wearing my identity on my sleeve)
- scintill76 11y ago> "50% black trans women speakers"? Bingo, this seems the natural end (or just the beginning of absurdity, really) of emphasizing equal representation of intersectionality, and it doesn't seem productive, dignified, or fair. Can anyone show that this is distorting the article's point? I don't see why transexuality should be minimized more than race or gender, and why it's not a component of intersectionality. Or defend why it's actually a good idea to turn people into a tuple of (gender, race, ethnicity, age, sexuality, sex, sex at time of birth, religion, caste, language) and select uniformly (or oppression-intersectionally)? How are you even going to find all those things out? (In some cases, asking would be a legal liability, and doesn't seem the most appropriate thing to ask.) I'd rather wear down barriers where I see them and let diversity organically grow, than to constantly be categorizing people and fudging the numbers into something artificially diverse.
- petercooper 11y agoJust my opinion, but the idea of "50% women speakers" isn't out of some sort of over-representative fairness to a "minority", but a reflection of real world demographics. In any case I can think of, roughly 50% of people in a given conference's catchment area are women, and since tech is an industry in which anyone could excel, having "50% women speakers" is promoting and encouraging a desired ideal to both the industry and potential participants in that industry. (I must note that "failing" at having 50% women speakers at a conference is by no means a fatal flaw, but having the ideal there and the principles in mind can still effect long term change.) The idea of having 50% "trans" people at an event would be a very different one given less than 1% of people are trans, allegedly (although given the stigma still attached, I think being trans needs to become more acceptable in society as a whole before we'll know the true number. They're probably a lot higher than we'd suspect, as we saw with homosexuality through the 20th century).