3 ms·
The reason why the laptop example works like you say is that laptops are commodities for you. It isn't that hard to exchange laptops and it isn't that big a de
by btilly 17y ago
The reason why the laptop example works like you say is that laptops are commodities for you. It isn't that hard to exchange laptops and it isn't that big a deal once you do.
The problem with software is that once it is integrated into your software ecosystem you often wind up locked in. If that software stops being able to work for you (for instance your license stops working and you can't purchase another one), then you frequently have a very difficult transition ahead since there is no drop in replacement available.
RMS sees this, knows that users often don't realize their potential future pain until they are committed to it, and concludes that non-free software is evil. By contrast an economist sees this, assumes that the market will be rational, and writes a book like Information Rules explaining how one should best act given the economic facts.
My view is that most people who really care about software have been around the block enough times to have experienced the economic fact and in practice act more like economic theory says you should act. Of course this provides an economic argument for free software, which has of course lead to the open source set of arguments.
YMMV. And on this topic it tends to vary widely.