2 ms·
I originally wrote this post as a response to Osmode, but it ended up swelling more than I'd intended. I fundamentally agree with his goals of supporting free
by paulmd 11y ago
I originally wrote this post as a response to Osmode, but it ended up swelling more than I'd intended. I fundamentally agree with his goals of supporting free discussion and suppressing self-censorship. However, I see several problems with this approach to achieving those goals.
The core problem with social-capital type schemes like Reddit (or indeed HN) is that they're very susceptible to bandwagoning. On Reddit the groupthink varies by community, but there's some mixing bowls and as a result the community does have an overall balance, despite having some short-term bandwagons. HN has a really strong bent towards the opinions of 20-something Silicon Valley startup coders without much counterbalance, and I know that I've certainly self-censored on certain topics that go against the grain here. Yes, in the words of Drew Carry, "everything is made up and the points don't matter", but then why is there still a counter in the corner of my screen?
Here, you're literally talking about putting a pricetag on dissenting opinions. If you go against the grain you're not just getting downvoted, each post actually costs you a certain amount of real money on servicing the blockchain. Conversely, circlejerking will get you a lot of kudos. That is - in and of itself - a strong social pressure that hampers the full spectrum of discourse. Much like the Bitcoin blockchain, it is fundamentally based on the assumption that no one group controls a non-trivial portion of the [social] network.
The same mechanisms that work against reprisal or spam also work against opinions that dissent from the common wisdom. It's vitally important for a strong discourse that sometimes-unpopular opinions be heard. Otherwise it's far too easy for the majority to carry themselves along (the Iraq war immediately springs to mind). I don't know how you counterbalance that against suppressing actual spam - because botnets and such mean that those groups will also have a great deal of capital from blockchain/network operation.
Some of the best communities on the web have actually been gated ones. Back in the day it cost $10 to activate an account on SomethingAwful. If you trolled, well, at least you're helping pay for the servers. If you leech on private trackers, you get banned and someone else takes a hit for inviting you. Gated NZB sites work in a similar way. I don't have a problem with such communities at all, but fundamentally they work on the basis of clearly defined social standards. On the flip side, Twitter and Tumblr have a very low level of discourse, because it's all about pithy soundbytes that get you retweeted. People leech from ThePirateBay all the time, because from their perspective, why not?
I don't see how this is different from "twitter, but using bitcoin". Something like FreeNet seems to accomplish the above goals much more effectively - popular opinions result in distributed re-caching, unpopular ones still get served if they have sufficient traffic, and really unpopular ones can be broadcasted by vigorous network participation and re-seeding.