4 ms·
Wow, thanks so much for the reply! Your answer to my second question is interesting because I kind of understand the tin-foil-hat argument, but I don't totally
by smt88 11y ago
Wow, thanks so much for the reply!
Your answer to my second question is interesting because I kind of understand the tin-foil-hat argument, but I don't totally see how Rice would create additional pressure to violate privacy. She's a civilian now and, presumably, completely locked out of the current administration.
To me (someone without a tin-foil hat), I think the issue is more symbolic. Rice is a terrible human being and a seasoned deceiver of the public. It's almost like we're asking ourselves, "If you'd allow her to be part of your leadership, what else would you do?"
When I've thought about it, that wasn't enough to counterbalance exactly what you mentioned -- the idea that a single privacy breach at Dropbox could mean the end of the company. She's barely a part of the leadership and may have almost no say in what the company does. The ultimate decisions are probably still in the hands of the executive team. That's why I was a customer until very recently.
All that said, I don't understand how Rice is valuable enough to counterbalance the bad PR from the tech community. Tech-y people get small companies to adopt certain brands over others, and then those small companies grow into large companies. Maybe I'm naive, and Rice offers some amazing connections or something?
Either way, if much of the Dropbox team has your attitude and values, I can honestly say I hope the company has a prosperous, breach-free future ahead of it.
- marcoperaza 11y agoThese attempts to blackball people in their professional lives for their political opinions (see Brendan Eich at Mozilla) and political decisions (this DropDropBox stuff) are really no better than the Hollywood Blacklisting during the McCarthy witch-hunts that we all look back on as a dark chapter of American history. It really goes against the spirit of tolerance and plurality that America has embodied at its best. I can only hope that just like for McCarthyism, we will all wake up from this binge in a few years and realize just how far we've strayed from our best ideals.
- mhurron 11y agoI too believe that all people should be free of any consequences of their actions.
- dredmorbius 11y agoShould I supply your sarcasm tag?
- Touche 11y ago> These attempts to blackball people in their professional lives for their political opinions (see Brendan Eich at Mozilla) and political decisions (this DropDropBox stuff) is really no better than the Hollywood Blacklisting during the McCarthy witch-hunts that we all look back on as a dark chapter of American history. In this case her political opinions directly affect the business she joined.
- jacobolus 11y agoRice is not being attacked for her “political opinions”, and euphemistically describing torture, assassination, indefinite imprisonment without trial, war under false pretenses, mass surveillance, etc. as a “political decision” is disingenuous. Direct participation in war crimes is not comparable to being vaguely associated with American leftists during the mid-20th century. What Rice contributed to was a violation of American and international law, a betrayal of her oath of office and of the public, and a shameful episode in our history. I too hope we can “wake up from this binge in a few years and realize just how far we've strayed from our best ideals”. If we had any such ideals, the justice department would have aggressively prosecuted the criminals involved, up to the highest levels of government.
- smt88 11y ago"Tolerance" should never apply to bigotry. Fifty years ago, we'd be having this debate about the version of Brendan Eich that believed black and white people shouldn't get married. Society didn't tolerate bigotry then, and it shouldn't tolerate it now. Brendan Eich has the right to his opinion, and his employers (and customers) have the right to fire him for them. Political beliefs are not a protected class. (As for Condoleezza Rice, she participated in war-mongering, which is totally different from "political opinions".)
- marcoperaza 11y agoTo the credit of Mozilla's board, Eich wasn't fired. He quit because the hoopla made doing his job impossible. It was the right move on his part because his presence became damaging to Mozilla. To your point about it being fine to fire people for their political beliefs, the legal right to do something doesn't say much about whether you should. I think everyone would be appalled if it became common practice for employers to look through every campaign you ever donated to, every cause you ever lent support to, to find something to disqualify you over. It also does nothing but further alienate and divide people. Going back to the McCarthy era, there was nothing illegal about firing communists. And the people doing it had lots of reasons to think they were doing the right thing. The US was in an existential battle against an empire that had worldwide gulags and purges as its goal. Stalin was a proven master of infiltration and palace intrigue. More recent evidence shows that McCarthy's paranoia was not ill-founded -- Soviet intelligence had infiltrated large parts of American society and government. It was still morally wrong to fire people for their political opinions. Especially if they aren't loudly advertising them.
- grinich 11y ago> Rice is a terrible human being and a seasoned deceiver of the public. This is a pretty callous thing to say, even for HN. I think there's a real discussion to be had here about data privacy and the power of law enforcement agencies, but demonizing Condoleezza feels like creating a straw man. She's just a board member-- it's not like she's VP of Product or CEO or something. I get your point, but calling her a "terrible human being" is kind of extreme, don't you think? Not sure that statement adds to a well-reasoned argument. I personally don't agree with all her politics or behavior, but I don't think she ranks up there with the truly "terrible" humans. She was a professor at Stanford, is an accomplished musician, has done a lot for international US diplomacy, was the first woman in many of her roles, etc. etc.
- felixgallo 11y ago"has done a lot for international US diplomacy" is what we're talking about here. As of 9/11, the US enjoyed unquestionable moral superiority and absolute world support. Then Sec. Rice squandered that by lying to the world, invading Iraq, and creating the current quagmire, which includes the deaths of probably hundreds of thousands of innocents. I'm sure she plays a lovely piano sonata though.
- underbluewaters 11y agoAs part of senior leadership pushing for the war in Iraq under false pretenses, which killed hundreds of thousands of Iraqis, thousands of Americans, and burned nearly 2 trillion dollars, I'd say she's earned the adjective of "terrible human being".
- victorhooi 11y agoThe Iraqi thing has been done to death. It's never a black and white decision. Yes, we may not agree with his decisions - but I guarantee that if you go through history, you will find many political decisions that each of us would disagree with. I may not like a lot of the decisions my political leaders make (I'm Australian). However, I don't pretend for a second that political leadership is an easy calling - it's a tough job, and a lot of pressure - which can affect people in different ways. I dislike armchair pundits who will dissect every decision, and then try to force it into their own black/white view of things. At the end of the day, they made the call to topple Saddam Hussein, and take out Iraq. I don't think anybody will argue that Saddam was a great human being, or that his regime wasn't responsible for atrocities - for me, the question was more that did we (well, America and its allies) have better things to do with their soldiers and money? And look, we took out one dictator and put in a democratic government - and gave them aid and training - but it remains to be seen what they can make of it.
- dang 11y agoWe detached this subthread from https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10394830 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10394830 and marked it off-topic.