3 ms·
People won't take you seriously because of your handle, but if we take your image for what it is (a political cartoon), I think it brings up some very important
by omginternets 11y ago
People won't take you seriously because of your handle, but if we take your image for what it is (a political cartoon), I think it brings up some very important (albeit contentious) points.
In no particular order:
- There's an overwhelming preference (across all academic and professional disciplines) for women to prefer working with people and for men to prefer working with things [1]
- Gender theory is a sociological and political theory that's often touted as being scientific. To be sure, it's contributed to science (e.g.: the idea that gender roles are socially-influenced), but the idea that men and women are equivalent outside of socially-constructed differences is (a) unsubstantiated (b) unfalsifiable (we can never fully remove social influence) (c) in contradiction with what cognitive neuroscience tells us about anatomy and physiology shape cognition.
Where gender theory has a role to play is in telling us how to structure our societies despite eventual differences between the sexes, but I really don't care for it's opinion on empirical questions.
[1] http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/19883140 http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/19883140
- SHIT_TALKER 11y agoI've found the admin to be hostile to discussion of biological determinism and have given up on discourse on this site. I'm surprised to find, given the general tenor of the commentary on this thread, that there has been a seeming absence of intervention. Perhaps on sex he is more tolerant of such views than on race.
- omginternets 11y agoThis doesn't surprise me in the least. SanFran is a hotbed of a particularly harsh branch of anti-essentialist feminism, and YC is a SF company. On the whole, though, I feel like these ideas can be discussed, provided you mince your words and ignore the trolls.